Los Angeles Times

Your turn: Would you rather have Ngata or Asomugha?

Nnamdi Asomugha is atop the offseason wish list of many Ravens fans, and understandably so. Adding a Pro Bowl player such as Asomugha, who has been one of the NFL’s top cornerbacks the past few seasons, would give the Ravens a difference-maker at every level of their defense. With Ed Reed, Haloti Ngata, Ray Lewis, Terrell Suggs and Asomugha, the Ravens would again have the makings of a truly elite NFL defense.

We know Steve Bisciotti has the cash and the willingness to sign any player who can help his Ravens win the Super Bowl, but the issue is fitting Asomugha under whatever salary cap constraints are put in place when the lockout finally ends. Ravens coach John Harbaugh has said the team’s top priority is retaining its own players, and Ngata, Joe Flacco and Ray Rice will all need to be re-signed in the not-so distant future.

Still, some in the national media are speculating that the Ravens will have serious interest in Asomugha once free agency begins. Sports Illustrated’s Peter King listed the Ravens as one of his three favorites to sign the All-Pro cornerback. “Everything says no -- the Ravens need to sign Haloti Ngata long-term, and how many megabuck defensive players can you have in a cap era?” he wrote. “But Ozzie Newsome knows the only thing his defense lacks is a shutdown corner.” But what would Ozzie have to sacrifice to get him?

You have to think the Ravens would be forced to let a few key contributors go or keep Asomugha for the long term instead of one of their young building blocks, but it’s hard to say right now because the cap is in flux. So here’s a hypothetical to debate this morning: Would you rather have Asomugha or Ngata? Each is one of the NFL’s most dominant players as his respective position.

Asomugha would eliminate a third of the field on passing plays, and since Reed is capable of covering 25 percent of the planet (if you believe this Facebook group), I’m pretty sure that means the Ravens’ other defensive backs would only have to cover about 16 square feet of turf. Even Frank Walker could do that.

Meanwhile, Ngata is as big as a grizzly bear and as nimble as a ballerina, and his all-around domination of the line of scrimmage helped Suggs have a monster season in 2010 and allowed Lewis to roam relatively free and pile up tackles. Ngata, who has signed a one-year tender, deserves Albert Haynesworth money.

So which player would you rather have? Remember, this is a purely hypothetically debate based on the abilities of these two Pro Bowl players. You never know, the Ravens might find a way to sign both.

Your turn: If the Ravens had to pick between Nnamdi Asomugha or Haloti Ngata, which Pro Bowler should they take?

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Your turn: Will Orioles-Nationals ever be a real, relevant rivalry?

    Your turn: Will Orioles-Nationals ever be a real, relevant rivalry?

    The Orioles renew their supposed rivalry with the Nationals on Friday, assuming they don’t get gridlocked on the Beltway on the way down to Washington. The Orioles took two of three against their neighbors to the south on Preakness weekend, but that series was as compelling as the cornhole tournament...

  • Your turn: The best wire-to-wire season you have witnessed?

    If you watched Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Finals on Wednesday night, you witnessed the end of one of the greatest wire-to-wire seasons in recent sports history. Tim Thomas, the former journeyman turned unlikely All-Star goalie, capped off his superlative season by leading the Bruins to their first...

  • Your turn: Why have the Orioles struggled so much in Toronto?

    The Orioles haven’t won a game in Toronto in 22 months, a crazy road losing skid that continued Tuesday night when the Blue Jays won in extra innings, 6-5, on Adam Lind’s walk-off home run. Of course, the Blue Jays have had their number at Camden Yards, too, but the losses at Rogers Centre have...

  • Your turn: What's your take on the proposed MLB realignment?

    Your turn: What's your take on the proposed MLB realignment?

    A proposal for realignment in Major League Baseball is reportedly gaining steam with the owners and the players, and though the structural changes might not be what some desperate Orioles fans are hoping for, the subtle switch being considered makes too much sense when it comes to competitive balance.

  • Your turn: Should the Orioles listen to offers for Guthrie?

    Your turn: Should the Orioles listen to offers for Guthrie?

    In case you missed it over the weekend, my colleague Peter Schmuck raised an excellent question in his column for Saturday’s newspaper. Would it make sense for the Orioles to trade veteran starter Jeremy Guthrie, who has never had a full winning season in the major leagues, at next month’s trade...