The best Orioles bar in New York City

East Village (Manhattan, New York)New York UniversityAnnapolis

These can be lonely times for an Orioles fan in New York City.

But just like the team they love, Orioles fans always find a way. Orioles fans enisled on Manhattan have started flocking to the Horsebox, a two-and-a-half year old bar on Avenue A in the East Village.

"I was born in Baltimore, grew up in Annapolis," said The Horsebox's owner David Pettebone. "And my partner, Noel Foley, who's from Carlow, Ireland, fell in love with the Orioles, too. We always have on our O's caps behind the bar."

Patrons, some of them Marylanders attending New York University, took notice. And word started getting around. (I heard about it from Regi's owner Alan Morstein, whose son, Ryan, watched the Orioles win the play-in game on Friday night.)

"The customers made it an Orioles bar," Pettebone said. Fans started bringing in memorabilia. A signed photograph of Cal Ripken, taken on the night he broke the consecutive-game streak, hangs on the wall.

The Horsebox has no mission or theme, which makes it stand out from the crowd in the 21st-century East Village. "It's not like it used to be," Pettebone said. "It's one of the neighborhood's few bars that's just a bar." (From the website: "The bartenders know your name, know your drink, know the score of the ballgame, know the subways and the weather, and know how to make you laugh..." Sounds to me like a great Baltimore bar.)

"We try to keep it open to everybody, " Pettebone said. "At night the average age is 25 to 35, but lots of old-school Yankee fans come here during the day. We're always busting chops with them."

If an Orioles fan does show up at the Horsebox on Sunday night, he won't find Pettebone - he was down in Baltimore on Sunday, with tickets for the series opener. "I'm blinded by happiness," said Pettebone, who comes down for about 15 games a year.

Orioles fans won't find Natty Boh at The Horsebox, either. Pettebone said he can't get the sentimental suds up in New York City.

The Horsebox is at 218 Avenue A in the East Village. For information call 646-370-1791 or go to

Follow Baltimore Diner on Twitter @gorelickingood

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
East Village (Manhattan, New York)New York UniversityAnnapolis
  • Orioles fans in New York City flock to the Horsebox
    Orioles fans in New York City flock to the Horsebox

    On Sunday, we told you about The Horsebox, a bar in New York's East Village that Orioles fans have adopted. Josh Adams was among the displaced Marylanders who found their way to Avenue A to watch the Orioles take on the Yankees in ALDS Game 3. Here's Josh's report:

  • Adam Jones stays hungry [Pictures]
    Adam Jones stays hungry [Pictures]

    When he's not smashing home runs, Adam Jones is getting ready to smash some pancakes. Or maybe some Popeye's chicken. Even grilled chicken and red beans and rice draw a "smash" from the Orioles outfielder. For proof, look no further than his Instagram feed (@simplyaj10), where his bio...

  • New food at Oriole Park [Pictures]
    New food at Oriole Park [Pictures]

    Delaware North Sportservice sports unveiled some of the new food they've come up with the Oriole Park at Camden Yards at an event on Wednesday. All of these items will be available at locations in the general concessions throughout the stadium. Use the comments field below to tell us what...

  • Baltimore bars honor Orioles' playoff run with drink and food specials
    Baltimore bars honor Orioles' playoff run with drink and food specials

    As the Orioles head to the Bronx for the third game of their playoff series with the Yankees, at least a few bars in Baltimore will honor the home team and its fans with specials. (These deals only apply for tonight's 7:30 p.m. game unless otherwise noted.)