Review: In 'The Brontës,' Juliet Barker plays detective

AuthorsBiography (genre)Arts and CultureCancerTuberculosis

The Brontës
Wild Genius on the Moors — The Story of a Literary Family

Juliet Barker
Pegasus: 1,200 pp., $39.95

Just about everything you thought you knew about the Brontës is wrong.

That's the essential message of "The Brontës" by Juliet Barker. Eighteen years after her landmark biography was published, the author — a former curator of the Brontë Parsonage Museum at Haworth — has produced a revised edition with new material, including letters and juvenilia that were unavailable when the author wrote the book.

Hers is not the typical account of the famed sisters Anne, Charlotte and Emily; this is a group portrait. She redeems unfairly maligned figures (such as the children's father, Patrick Brontë) and dismantles images of sainthood, as in the case of Charlotte. In other words, Barker shows the family as flawed and human rather than as the mad, freakish clan of isolated geniuses portrayed in many biographies. She expresses astonishment that a vast trove of archival material, including local newspaper accounts of the era, has never been used by other scholars.

Spelling is among her first concerns about the Brontës: "I believe that the policy of 'correcting' the Brontës' often wildly ill-spelt and ungrammatical writings gives a false impression of their sophistication," she writes, explaining that she has transcribed original manuscripts with "warts and all."

Although she concedes that producing "yet another" biography of the Brontës seems to warrant an apology — What else is left to say about them? — Barker bluntly justifies her contribution to the pile. "The Brontës have been ill-served by their biographers," she writes, citing shoddy work based on bowdlerized, inaccurate texts. She does not cite by name any contemporary offenders. (Biographies by the scholars Lucasta Miller and Rebecca Fraser were published within the last 10 years, and both were fine, insightful works.)

The distortions and myth-making around the Brontës can be traced to the novelist Elizabeth Gaskell, who published "The Life of Charlotte Brontë" in 1857, two years after her "dear friend" died at 38. This book, which suppressed certain facts and misinterpreted and embellished others, set the tone for subsequent Brontë biographies and is regarded as an important reference work by scholars today. Barker calls it "a flawed masterpiece."

It is thanks to Gaskell that we see Emily as the mercurial, rebellious wild child, given to unseemly outbursts; Anne as quiet and conventional; Charlotte as the stoic, dutiful, morally upright sister; and brother Branwell as a brilliant but self-sabotaging, ignominious drunkard. Father Patrick has been universally cast as a cold, tyrannical figure. (Two sisters, Maria and Elizabeth, died of tuberculosis in 1825; their mother died of cancer a year after Anne was born.)

Even Haworth, the Brontës' Yorkshire home, was mischaracterized by Gaskell as a remote village. "'Isolated,' 'solitary,' 'lonely' are the epithets on every page," Barker writes. In reality, Haworth was "a busy, industrial township" with a growing and thriving population.

She is dismayed, to say the least, that the lives and works of the Brontës have been "taken apart and reassembled according to varying degrees of sanity." She seems personally insulted that other biographers have relied on literary criticism for their portraits and that they were fixated upon identifying the "real" people based on characters in the sisters' novels — a search that Barker calls "fanatical and irrelevant." At one point she goes further, asserting that "it is always dangerous to argue autobiographical facts from fiction." However, when fiction and fact do match, Barker notes the connection.

Certainly there is much in Barker's account that will be familiar to readers — notably, the public shock and moral outrage that the Brontë sisters faced upon publishing their revolutionary novels. (These works were released pseudonymously, under the names Acton, Currer and Ellis Bell.)

And some of the new information uncovered by Barker is simply more mundane than revelatory. For instance, she quotes from a moving 1854 letter by Charlotte describing her wedding dress: "white I had to buy and did buy to my own amazement — but I took care to get it in cheap material …. If I must make a fool of myself — it shall be on an economical plan."

Yet the additional material helps fill out the family portrait and overturns the legends around them. Charlotte, for one, is seen not as a passive martyr but as strong-willed, controlling and often self-absorbed. She also comes across as far more interesting than she has been presented in other biographies: bossy, judgmental, flirtatious and wickedly funny, with a fondness for sarcasm.

Patrick is portrayed as a loving father and a kind, sympathetic figure in his community. He was a much-admired preacher at his church, one who advocated vigorously on behalf of the poor. Although he once admitted resenting the "caricature" of himself and "many unfounded things" in Gaskell's biography, he nonetheless graciously welcomed Gaskell and her daughter, Meta, to Haworth in 1860. (He died a year later, having outlived all his children.)

Barker also dispels long-held assumptions about Emily's literary output. After "Wuthering Heights," Emily never wrote another novel. Some insist that because it was such a powerful work, Emily had "exhausted all her genius" in writing it. Others have said that the savage reviews from critics had crippled her, preventing her from writing fiction again. Barker says that both views are wrong and that, despite conclusive evidence, Emily would have most certainly begun another project.

It would be fair to assume that, at more than a thousand pages, "The Brontës" is a slow, daunting read. Surprisingly, this book doesn't drag at all. Barker is an impressive, exhaustive researcher, but she's also a great detective and a lively storyteller. Each section offers further insight into this family's struggles, illnesses and losses and, above all, their closeness and affection.

It is this unique intimacy, Barker argues, that yielded their extraordinary creative endeavors — despite difficulties, rivalries and temperamental differences, each family member ultimately sustained the other.

After more than 150 years, the Brontës remain as fascinating (and inspiring) as ever. They have lost none of their allure. If any writer has earned the final word about their lives, it's Barker, with her triumphant and eloquent book. She can savor this distinction, of course, until the next Brontë biography comes along.

Ciuraru is the author of "Nom de Plume: A (Secret) History of Pseudonyms."

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
AuthorsBiography (genre)Arts and CultureCancerTuberculosis
  • Heavy reading
    Heavy reading

    Juliet Barker's lives of the Brontës may be a doorstopper, but it's hardly the only one this season resisting quick consumption. The following three tomes don't beg so much as wallop you on the head with their sheer size.

  • Reader recommendations a growing business in the book world
    Reader recommendations a growing business in the book world

    Need help finding your next favorite title? With new works like 'Start Here' and 'Read This!,' bloggers and booksellers aim to ease the way.

  • Casting the classics
    Casting the classics

    Taking a classic work of fiction and adapting it for the screen is an ambitious project. Much more can be packed in between two covers than can be portrayed in two hours, for starters. And actors must embody a character that has lived in the minds of readers for generations. Casting can make...

  • Haruki Murakami's upcoming novel excerpted at Slate
    Haruki Murakami's upcoming novel excerpted at Slate

    There is more than a fortnight to wait for Haruki Murakami's new novel, "Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage," but today fans can get a taste at Slate. A review of the book that had been posted by The Guardian early Monday has been removed because it breached...

  • Jason Boog on reading to newborns and other parenting adventures
    Jason Boog on reading to newborns and other parenting adventures

    The journalist Jason Boog has long been a book lover. He’s written about the publishing industry for the Galley Cat blog, and about literary culture for NPR and the Los Angeles Review of Books, among many other publications. Three years ago, his daughter, Olive, was born, and he got an...

  • In Amy Bloom's 'Lucky Us,' sisters remain plucky in face of tragedy
    In Amy Bloom's 'Lucky Us,' sisters remain plucky in face of tragedy

    "There is no such thing as a good writer and a bad liar," Amy Bloom wrote in her 1999 short story "The Story," which remains my favorite of all her work. It's a vivid bit of double vision, Bloom commenting on the process of storytelling even as she engages in it, and it...

  • 'Excavation' digs up memories of an illicit child-teacher relationship
    'Excavation' digs up memories of an illicit child-teacher relationship

    When she was just 13, Wendy Ortiz began to learn important lessons about love, honesty and human depravity. She was a precocious eighth-grader, and she was about to fall under the spell of her 28-year-old English teacher.

  • 'Close Your Eyes' looks at normal moments amid nuclear horrors
    'Close Your Eyes' looks at normal moments amid nuclear horrors

    Chris Bohjalian is a master of depicting the small moments — the inevitable routines — that follow in the wake of a trauma. In "The Light in the Ruins," an 18-year-old girl crafts clothes for two dolls as she watches Axis warplanes fly over Tuscany. In "The Double Bind,"...