A gas tax is unfair to everyone

The gas tax is just about the most regressive tax that exists in a place like Maryland, where living in a safe community with good schools means one must live in the suburbs ("Va. takes the lead," Jan. 10).

Taxing the gasoline that people need to work, to acquire higher education, to seek medical care and to buy food makes as much sense — i.e. none — as paying for:

•K-12 education by charging parents tuition equal to the cost per child, with higher fees for parents of special needs children since they are so much more expensive to educate than other children;

•Police services by charging a fee to each victim of an accident or crime;

•Firefighting by charging a fee per fire or accident or per life saved;

•Snow removal by charging property owners a fee per foot of property frontage;

Paying for highways and supporting public transportation with a gas tax makes no more sense than funding other essential public services through user fees.

It is grossly unfair to the poor, the unemployed and to middle income citizens who are least able to pay it and who are most likely to be deterred from seeking better employment and higher education because of the added cost.

The proposal of the Virginia Gov. Robert McDonnell to eliminate the gas tax shows a genuine recognition of how fundamental gasoline is to life in America. Maryland would do well to eliminate the gas tax and fund transportation with an income or capital gains tax increase instead.

Anita Heygster, Pasadena

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
    Related Content
    • The transportation lockbox [Editorial]
      The transportation lockbox [Editorial]

      Our view: Vote 'yes' on Question 1 and lock down state transportation funding — but don't expect Annapolis to throw away the key

    • Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]
      Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]

      A proposed state constitutional amendment creating a firewall for the Transportation Trust Fund will be on the ballot this fall, and while the legislation is flawed, it deserves voter support. The legislation (Senate Bill 829 of 2013) received bipartisan support in both the House and Senate.

    • Highway funding needed — and concrete, too [Letter]
      Highway funding needed — and concrete, too [Letter]

      In regard to the commentary by Brian Dolan ("Get riled up over roadways," July 14), I am in a similar position to Mr. Dolan of the Maryland Asphalt Association, as I work for the Maryland Ready Mix Concrete Association. I, of course, disagree with Mr. Dolan's recent comments disparaging...

    • Concrete is not the problem [Letter]
      Concrete is not the problem [Letter]

      I've known Brian Dolan for nearly 25 years, back to a time when I was the concrete engineer and he was an assistant district engineer, both for the Maryland State Highway Administration. As old colleagues, I wasn't surprised to see his informative commentary on the state of our roads ("Get...

    • America is squandering a precious asset: its highways [Letter]
      America is squandering a precious asset: its highways [Letter]

      Brian Dolan's article, "Get riled up over roadways" (July 14), was extremely well written. Message received loud and clear. We need to be reminded of our crumbling infrastructure as we begin to accept it as the norm.

    • A temporary patch [Editorial]
      A temporary patch [Editorial]

      Our view: With the Highway Trust Fund within weeks of bankruptcy, Congress looks to kick the transportation can down the road