Los Angeles Times

Congressional redistricting is entirely political — and it should be

The proposed Maryland congressional districts should not put current representation at risk by further fracturing the continuity of districts ("Two maps emerge in redistricting discussions," Sept. 30). The current districts fairly and accurately represent the dominance of party registration, unlike the 1990 districts created by then-Gov. William Donald Schaefer to protect two of his GOP cronies and to "get" Rep. Charles McMillen, which resulted in a very unrepresentative 50-50 party split.

Districts should reflect the major population centers. The 1st District should cover the Eastern Shore, wrapping around the top of the bay and not coming over the Bay Bridge. The 6th is currently well drawn, being contiguous but reflecting views of the area's voters. Obviously the 7th should reflect largely Baltimore City. The 5th should reflect Southern Maryland, as it currently does. The 4th might well consolidate in Prince George's County, while the 8th should similarly center on Montgomery. Between them, the 2nd and 3rd should concentrate on either Baltimore County or Anne Arundel and Howard. These districts currently yield Gerrymanders which are hard to defend. The proposed districts would make them, as well as the 4th and 8th, worse.

Redistricting is naturally a political — that is to say, democratic — process, resulting from the representatives elected by the citizens, and thus by definition in our republic, legitimate. Unfortunately, calling the democratic process "politics" deliberately seeks to delegitimize the only process we know to legitimize governance.

James Kelly, Ellicott City

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Partisan redistricting undermines representative democracy [Letter]

    Partisan redistricting undermines representative democracy [Letter]

    I read with interest the recent article "Carroll conservatives clash with Van Hollen" (Nov. 12). I could readily relate to Carroll County Republican Bill Schroeder's statement — "We have nothing in common with Montgomery County — absolutely nothing" — concerning his representative, Chris Van Hollen,...

  • Redistricting reform matters to middle class families

    Redistricting reform matters to middle class families

    As one who successfully challenged Gov. Parris N. Glendening's blatantly political legislative redistricting plan in court in 2002 and the following year introduced legislation to create a gubernatorial task force to reform our redistricting process, I was pleased to see that Gov. Larry Hogan has...

  • Redistricting reform: Hogan makes good on his promise

    Redistricting reform: Hogan makes good on his promise

    Gov. Larry Hogan took an important step toward fulfilling one of the most important promises of his campaign today by naming a commission to come up with recommendations to reform the process by which Maryland redraws congressional and legislative district maps. Granted, he made a lot of important...

  • Why should redistricting be so complicated?

    Why should redistricting be so complicated?

    Surely by virtue of the U.S. Postal Service and/or past census data we much know the population of every ZIP code in the country. (If not, we could probably buy it from Amazon or UPS). So why not just go from east to west, or west to east, one ZIP code at a time until the proper population for...

  • Hogan's right about one thing: Md. district lines are ridiculous

    Hogan's right about one thing: Md. district lines are ridiculous

    Gov. Larry Hogan's proposal for a commission approach to redistricting is the best thing I've heard coming out of the governor's office since he took office ("Hogan: Redraw district lines," Aug. 7). I wish our politicians would be more interested in being public servants and less concerned about...

  • Straddling the city-county divide

    Straddling the city-county divide

    In a recent editorial you noted that Lt. Gov. Anthony G. Brown, who lives in Prince George's County, followed the traditional formula of appealing to the Baltimore region by choosing Howard County Executive Ken Ulman as his running mate ("Twin controversies for Gansler," Oct. 14).