A panel of Democratic and Republican lawmakers on Tuesday recommended against Gov. Pat Quinn's plan to close six state facilities, including the state's only super-maximum prison in downstate Tamms.
The governor proposed closing the sites to save money, and he can choose to follow or ignore the votes taken by the Commission on Government Forecasting and Accountability.
The only location the commission suggested should close was the Department of Children and Family Services office in Skokie.
Lawmakers agreed with Quinn that there should be closures, but couldn't agree which places should close. The outcome reflected the contrast between Quinn's position that he's looking at the state as a whole and lawmakers who can afford to be parochial and political when looking at such issues.
For example, Sen. Matt Murphy argued the state needs to close facilities to rein in expenses, but the Republican from Palatine voted against shutting down prisons in Tamms and Dwight as well as the adult transition center in Peoria and the Murray Developmental Center in Centralia. Murphy voted in favor of closing the family services office in Skokie, the Illinois Youth Center in Joliet and the prisoner halfway house on Chicago's West Side.
Sen. Mike Frerichs, D-Champaign, and Rep. Patti Bellock, R-Hinsdale, said they support the push for more community-based group care rather than institutionalization, but they voted against closing the Murray site. The lawmakers from different parties and regions said Quinn isn't providing enough time or information for residents to transition safely from the center.
The governor respects the commission's input but must deal with the state's overall financial instability, said Annie Thompson, a Quinn spokeswoman.
"We have incorporated a great deal of their input into our facility closure plans, however, we must continue to deal with our budget challenges and make the difficult decisions necessary to restore fiscal stability to Illinois," Thompson said. "We will continue to work with legislators … as this process moves forward."
The union with the largest number of state workers applauded lawmakers on the commission, saying they represented an example of good government and a move to preserve more than 2,000 Illinois jobs.