A family of drug-resistant bacteria that experts say kills up to 50 percent of people infected is spreading in Chicago and elsewhere, prompting doctors and public health officials to step up efforts to protect patients.
Infections caused by these germs — called carbapenem-resistant enterobacteriaceae, or CRE — are still rare, but they are difficult and sometimes impossible to treat. Carbapenems are antibiotics used as a last-resort treatment for seriously ill people.
No one knows the exact number of CRE infections or deaths in Illinois or nationwide, though the federal
But the CDC says an increasing percentage of germs in the enterobacteriaceae family are becoming resistant to carbapenems. A decade ago, 1 percent of these bacteria were resistant; now 4 percent are. One type has increased from 2 percent to 10 percent. In all, more than 70 kinds have developed carbapenem resistance.
So far, CRE have been identified only in patients in hospitals,
During an outbreak of one type of CRE in 2011 at the
The type identified in Chicago is called carbapenem-resistant Klebsiella, first reported in the U.S. in 2001.
It didn't exist in Chicago before 2007, experts say, but by 2011 it had emerged and spread quickly. A state health department survey conducted that year found that every hospital in suburban Cook County and 80 percent of hospitals in Chicago had identified at least one patient infected with it.
"CRE are nightmare bacteria," Dr. Tom Frieden, director of the CDC, said recently. "They pose a triple threat. First, they're resistant to all or nearly all antibiotics. Even some of our last-resort drugs. Second, they have high mortality rates. They kill up to half of people who get serious infections with them. And third, they can spread their resistance to other bacteria."
For example, carbapenem-resistant Klebsiella could spread genes that interfere with the body's ability to respond to antibiotics to
Information about the number of CRE infections is scarce in part because only six states require health facilities to report cases — Tennessee, Oregon, Minnesota, Colorado, Wisconsin and North Dakota. The CDC said its surveillance systems pick up the percentage of pathogens resistant to particular drugs, not the number of cases or deaths.
Wisconsin, which required hospitals to report CRE infections starting in December 2011, has since identified 25 cases in 17 of the state's 137 hospitals and long-term acute care facilities. Nineteen involved a carbapenem-resistant Klebsiella species; the others were carbapenem-resistant E. coli.
The CDC has tracked CRE from a single health care facility in 2001 to health care facilities in at least 42 states. In some of those places, these bacteria have become relatively commonplace, Frieden said.
Illinois health officials are working on a rule that would require hospitals to report CRE cases. Meanwhile, hospital administrators across the area say they are accelerating their infection control efforts.
CRE are spread by unclean hands, but medical devices such as ventilators or catheters increase the risk of life-threatening infection because they can introduce new bacteria into the bloodstream.
The CDC last year recommended that facilities promote proper hand washing by health care workers, remove medical devices such as catheters as soon as possible, isolate patients who are infected or carry the bacteria and make sure that health workers are using protective gloves and gowns when touching patients with CRE, among other things.
The first Chicago case was reported in December 2007, said Dr. Mary Hayden, an infectious disease specialist who has been studying the organism as part of a CDC-funded project.
Hayden is director of the clinical microbiology laboratory at
"We knew it was a big deal to see even a single case, so we immediately started investigating and defining the problem," Hayden said.
She said taking a regional approach is key because patients often are transferred between facilities, such as from a nursing home to a hospital or from one hospital to another. The movement of undiagnosed patients creates an opportunity for the bacteria to spread.
"That's not the kind of thing that any one hospital can deal with successfully," Hayden said. "We need to cooperate among ourselves and work on this problem together in order to be successful in slowing the rate of increase and, ideally, eradicating CRE from the region."
Frieden urged health facilities to employ a "detect and protect" strategy, which involves identifying the presence of the organism and protecting other patients to prevent its spread.
In February, Rush started screening all adult ICU patients upon admission and all adult patients directly transferred from any outside facility to a medical unit, said Mary Alice Lavin, Rush's director of infection prevention and control.
"We're being proactive in our approach to identify infected patients so that we can put them in isolation and use contact precautions like (protective) gloves and gowns," Lavin said.
Patients whose clinical cultures detect CRE are not placed in rooms with uninfected patients, and all patients in the medical unit where the CRE patient stayed are screened to make sure the bacteria was not transmitted, she said.
"We have been very successful with that approach," Lavin said.
Given the seriousness of the problem, Hayden said health professionals need to take a broad approach.
"We need help from people at the highest level to address this in a long-term, big-picture way," she said. "We need new antibiotics. We need to study the best ways to address this problem with health care workers. But we don't need panic. That's not particularly helpful. We need a measured approach to this."
Frieden said health facilities have been successful in controlling CRE by using CDC-recommended prevention and control techniques.
But Betsy McCaughey, chairman and founder of the Committee to Reduce Infection Deaths, a patient advocacy group, said CDC officials haven't gone far enough. She wants the CDC to push for mandatory CRE screenings at hospitals in all states and require public reporting of data.
"If patients are going into the hospital for something elective like a hip replacement, they would want to avoid going into a hospital that is battling carbapenem-resistant bacteria," she said.
Health authorities advise consumers to take simple precautions to protect themselves, such as frequent hand washing. They also say people should avoid taking antibiotics unnecessarily because overuse can contribute to the development of drug-resistant organisms, decreasing treatment options. Antibiotics treat bacterial infections, not viral illnesses.