Freyer says that Edgar Baitzel, also a German native, chatted with him about doing a production of "The Threepenny Opera" by German dramatist Bertolt Brecht and composer Kurt Weill -- a logical choice for Freyer, who was a Brecht meisterschüler (master student) and has staged work for the Berliner Ensemble, founded by Brecht and his wife, Helene Weigel, in 1949.
Freyer resisted; he considered himself not only done with stage work but also finished with Wagner. "I had done 'Tristan und Isolde.' That was enough," he exclaims, referring to a 1994 production in Brussels.
But then, Freyer says, he and Baitzel, who had overseen productions of the complete works of Wagner in 1983 as assistant manager of the Bavarian State Opera in Munich, Germany, started talking of gesamtkunstwerk, the blending of disciplines. "I thought, I can make a painting with the story," Freyer says. "I think I can do the gesamtkunstwerk. I tried to find a way of painting with theater, and with music."
L.A. Opera's dream of presenting the "Ring" predates Baitzel and Freyer. In 2000, the company announced plans to mount a "Ring" cycle staged by German director Peter Mussbach in collaboration with Industrial Light & Magic, George Lucas' special-effects team, but the post-Sept. 11 economic slowdown scuttled plans for a high-tech "Ring," whose budget estimates had gone as high as $60 million.
At that point, Freyer was not on the "Ring" radar -- but in the next few years he established himself as a force at L.A. Opera with two notable productions: in 2002, a controversial, abstract staging of Bach's B-minor Mass that led to boos in the audience and angry letters to The Times and, the next year, a well-received production of Berlioz's "Damnation of Faust," featuring giant masks, flying effects and the Los Angeles Children's Chorus appearing as 54 angels' heads popping up through holes in the stage.
In new territory
Says Domingo of the Bach production: "It was my first season as an artistic director, and I wanted to program works that hadn't been seen here before. The Mass wasn't even an opera. I thought it was a fantastic production, but perhaps some audience members thought it was eccentric to see a sacred oratorio in an opera house, no matter how interesting the staging."
(Of people who bring such preconceptions with them into the theater, Freyer says cheerfully: "Not my problem.")
Still, adds Domingo, "Any resistance to Freyer's style was swept away with his production of 'Damnation of Faust.' Although he is one of the great theatrical geniuses of our time, his work was little known in the United States. We knew he would be able to give us a breathtaking 'Ring' that would fit in with what I see as L.A. Opera's vision . . . innovative, imaginative and thought-provoking."
Capturing the drama
For his part, L.A. Opera music director James Conlon -- who counts among his credits nine Wagner-heavy years as chief conductor of the Cologne Opera in Germany -- is confident that Freyer is capable of creating the "timeless, placeless place" in which the "Ring," Conlon believes, must exist.
"I think the power of myth always goes beyond the mundane," the conductor says. "The biggest cliché of the last few decades has been to reduce the subject to a specific.
"I've seen Marxist 'Rings,' Freudian 'Rings,' Jungian 'Rings,' 'Rings' in tuxedos -- all the things that in the '50s and '60s were considered rebellious are clichés now," Conlon continues. " 'The Ring' is Freudian and it's Jungian and it's Marxist and it's Keynesian and Buddhist and Christian -- it's all of those things, but not one of those things."
Another of Conlon's "Ring" requirements: that the visuals not upstage the opera. Although he does not name names, he says that film or stage directors who occasionally drop in to stage an opera often forget that. "In the case of Achim Freyer, he has lived with opera as a part of his culture -- he's not someone who's 'dropping in' on 'The Ring,' " Conlon says. "The drama is in the music."
Freyer agrees -- but among his many dreams is to stage a "Ring" without music, with actors speaking Wagner's text to emphasize its poetry. He'd also like to stage Dante's "Divine Comedy" someday and has his eye on mounting "Les Chants de Maldoror" (The Songs of Maldoror), a poetic French novel about an evil misanthrope consisting of six cantos written between 1868 and 1869 by the Comte de Lautréamont. The work has been cited as an inspiration by Surrealist painters including Salvador Dalí and Marcel Duchamp.
"I have only dreams," Freyer says -- not a wistful suggestion that there are many things in life he can only dream of but instead an assertion that there's no room for anything less than dream-worthy in his life.
While in Los Angeles, despite the demands of "Ring," Freyer plans to continue another of his dreams: his painting.
His 1970 watercolor "Seestück" (Seascape) is on view at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art through April 19 in the exhibition "Art of Two Germanys/Cold War Culture." And L.A.'s Ace Gallery plans a show of his work in 2010 in conjunction with Ring Festival L.A.
"It is completely separate, but it is the same person," Freyer says of himself as director and as visual artist in his quirky, gesamtkunstwerk-y way. "I do 'The Ring,' and I paint."
And despite his initial reservations, "The Ring" now holds a place among his dreams.
"When I hear a work for realization, it's like I am pregnant, and I must give birth -- I know, the image is very feminine," he says. "The piece is so strong and so hard and so philosophical and so political that I must tell it on the stage."