His 9-to-5five: Mortgage company founder Did he propose? Not really. Instead, Guiney gave Gardinier a promise ring. But the couple's relationship fizzled not long after the show aired. So what happened? Guiney found love with soap opera actress Rebecca Budig but broke things off after five years of marriage. P.S. Finalist Meredith Phillips became "The Bachelorette" in Season 2.
Craig Sjodin / ABC via Getty Images
Copyright © 2018, Los Angeles Times