Brooke: She recently collaborated with Make Up Forever to create a long-wear classic red lipstick for Madonna called Aqua Rouge #8 ($24, sephora.com). She also likes Nars velvet matte lip pencils in Forbidden Red and Cruella ($24, narscosmetics.com).
Dubroff: Nars velvet matte lip pencil in Dragon Girl ($24, narscosmetics.com), Tom Ford Narcotic Rouge lip color from his new Jasmine Rouge lip collection or Cherry Lush for a deeper red (each $48, bergdorfgood
Dubroff: Lancôme Hypnose Custom Volume mascara ($26, lancome-usa.com), Maybelline Lash Discovery mini brush for bottom lashes ($7.99, ulta.com).
Brooke: Volume Effet Faux Cils ($30, yslbeautyus.com), DiorShow mascara ($25, shop.nordstrom.com), Shu Uemura eyelash curler ($20, shuuemura-usa.com).
Strong: L'Oreal Voluminous in Carbon Black ($7.49, ulta.com).
Festive false lashes
Brooke: Farfallina false eyelashes, which she created ($29, shuuemura-usa.com).
Dubroff: Instead of strip lashes, which can pop off on the corners, she prefers individual or cluster lashes in multi-length packages, such as Eyelure ($5.99, ulta.com).
Strong: Miss Adoro #600 and #747 short or medium ($2.72, missadoro.com). "A huge mistake people make is to use [lashes] that are too long or too thick," he says.