There is no such confusion in the Santa Monica home of Jesse Bornstein. Rather than a traditional two-story house, the architect's "split-plane" design calls for half-flights of stairs to separate three levels: the main living and dining areas, the children's bedrooms and family room, and the master suite and sitting room. The open stairwell serves as the house's spine, cleverly keeping the interiors free-flowing yet divided into distinct rooms.
"It's breaking down the box and breaking preconceived notions of what a house should be like," Bornstein says. "It really obscures the conventional notion of floor plates stacked one on top of another."
The house is a case study for anyone coping with the challenges of urban living. Here's a look at five common design dilemmas and how this one house addresses them all:
1 Walk into enough modern houses these days and you'll probably come upon the open-floor plan taken to an extreme: a vast, wall-less space that feels more like a convention hall than a home. Try to relax with a good book in the study, and you can't escape the din of "CSI" at the other end of the house. Host a simple dinner party and you find there's no hiding clutter when living, dining and sleeping areas flow together in a door-less layout.
Bornstein's split-plane design solves those dilemmas. Center stringer stairs -- steps with a single support beam underneath and no riser, for a more open look -- guide visitors into the home's entry and up through its core. "There's the same sort of formula and language going on," Bornstein says, adding that using the same style of stairs from the sidewalk to the top floor makes traveling through the entire property an orderly and logical procession.
The ground floor consists of two kids' bedrooms and a family room, all set in the back half of the property. Climb half a flight of stairs to the front half of the house, and you find the heart of the home: the kitchen, dining area and living room. Climb another half-flight of stairs, back toward the rear of the house, and you come upon a quiet sitting room, a small meditation area and the master suite.
The result is a layout where stairs play the psychological role of walls, separating spaces yet allowing natural light, air and people to flow freely. Standing in the kitchen, Bornstein can monitor the kids as they play in the family room downstairs yet still feel as though he's in a different domain. Walk toward the master suite and a narrowing staircase provides a clue that you're transitioning from public to private space.
When Bornstein and wife Shaun want more division, pocket doors slide out to partition virtually every room in the house. If company comes over, for example, the couple can close off the ground floor and lead guests up to the main living and dining areas without worrying if the family room is tidy. Bornstein says the partitions are open 90% of the time, but in the rare instances when they are closed, white translucent glass allows natural light to pass through.
"The kids love this multilevel thing as much as the adults do, perhaps more," says Bornstein, who took the split-plane idea even further: Above the bathroom sandwiched between two bedrooms for daughters Olivia, 9, and Kalia, 11, he created a bonus play area that the girls can reach from ladders in either bedroom. "We have our sitting room above the kitchen," Bornstein says, "and they have their loft space as well."
2 Walk through Bornstein's house for the first time, and the biggest surprise is just how much room unfolds before your eyes. Given the structure's modest presence from the street, you don't expect 4,655 square feet of living space on the 8,000-square-foot lot, an illusion helped by shed roofs that follow the grade of the land, helping the house to feel naturally scaled to the site.
The multiple levels are a large factor in the feeling of spaciousness, but smaller gestures contribute as well. The sitting room on the top floor could have been enclosed in drywall or left totally open as a mezzanine overlooking the kitchen. Instead, Bornstein chose a happy medium: a large pass-through lets natural light and fresh air into the space. Stand up and you can see the kids having breakfast at the counter below; sit down and you're ensconced in a quiet, cozy reading nook.
So many built-in cabinets and shelves have been placed unobtrusively at every level of the house, you'll actually witness that California rarity: unused storage.
"It's a luxury to have this space," says Shaun Bornstein, a former aerospace engineer who manages her husband's architectural practice. She motions to bamboo bookcases, some still empty, lining the top-floor sitting room. "I feel like I can breathe."
Space also was a factor for Resa and Tom Nikol, who commissioned Bornstein to double the size of their 1950s Mar Vista home. The result, they say, is a distinctly modern yet livable space for them and their kids, 9 and 12.
"The outside is subtle but architecturally beautiful," says Tom, creative director for the print advertising group at Sony Pictures Television, who wanted the house to sing, not scream. "It's not overbuilt in terms of its presence from the street."
3 Glass walls and titanic sliding doors are tempting, but some homeowners discover all too late that a wide view isn't necessarily a good view. When the daily panorama is a power-line-filled sky, the neighbor brushing his teeth or the stares of passing motorists, all that glass quickly becomes a curse.
The trick, of course, is controlling the view: connecting to the landscape without feeling overly exposed to the outside world. In the Bornsteins' house, every room connects to nature -- from the glassed-in family room looking out to a ring of timber bamboo, to the master bathroom, where tops of those towering Bambusa oldhamii sway in the windows.