Jim Newton: What we have is a failure to communicate

In the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, public safety leaders in Southern California concluded that the need for a unified emergency communications system was so grave that they had to build it in such a way as to avoid the traditional pitfalls for huge, multi-agency projects: sloppiness, recriminations and politics. Ten years later, they are on the verge of commissioning such a system, but their efforts are beset by sloppiness, recriminations and politics.

The huge undertaking goes by the ungainly acronym LA-RICS, short for the unwieldy full name: The Los Angeles Regional Interoperable Communications System. Once built, it is supposed to supply a wireless voice and data system that will link all of Los Angeles County's first responders — 50 law enforcement agencies and 31 fire departments.

In theory, a common communications system would not only protect the region in the event of a terrorist attack or major natural disaster but could smooth responses to more routine crises. The LA-RICS website notes that the response to a 2002 shooting at Los Angeles International Airport was hampered by the different communications systems employed by airport police and those used by local and federal agencies with units at or near the airport. LA-RICS could solve that.

But building a system that bridges so many agencies employing so many different technologies has proved to be a significant challenge. To address it, the governments involved formed a joint powers authority and appointed as its leaders police and fire chiefs, city managers and others believed to have the expertise to know what they wanted without distracting political connections. The agency put out a request for proposals in which it described the system it was seeking and the qualifications it was looking for in bidders. Two companies, Raytheon and Motorola, ended up submitting comprehensive proposals; after exhaustive study, the agency's staff recommended entering into negotiations with Raytheon, and the board agreed.

That should have been almost the end of it, but it hasn't been. Stunned not to receive the nod, Motorola is fighting back aggressively, and the agency board is now riven with dissension about how to proceed. Motorola maintains that the process has been flawed; Raytheon complains that it won fair and square. Officials close to the negotiations credit Raytheon with submitting a significantly less expensive alternative, and they complain that Motorola appears to be trying to win through politics what it failed to win with its bid. Motorola counters that the agency staff is biased against it, and it wants dual negotiations that would include itself as well as Raytheon. Close to $1 billion is at stake. The threat of litigation hovers.

Raytheon supporters are agitated by some of Motorola's connections, especially those of one of its prominent representatives. Matt Knabe of Englander, Knabe and Allen is a well-regarded local lobbyist, and he happens to be the son of County Supervisor Don Knabe. Because of the structure of the joint powers authority, the Board of Supervisors has little direct control. But late last month, as Motorola stepped up its criticism of the process, the senior Knabe intervened in one of the few ways possible for a supervisor: He sought to block approval of a contract extension with the management consultant firm, DeltaWrx, that is negotiating with Raytheon. Motorola supporters have accused DeltaWrx of being biased against Motorola, and when an extension of the firm's contract came to the county supervisors for their approval, Knabe pulled it off the calendar, saying the proposal needed more study.

Knabe's spokeswoman, Cheryl Burnett, said the supervisor wanted more time to review the contract renewal; she said he received it on May 23 and was asked to approve it just two days later. "He feels like it's being rushed," she said.

Don Knabe previously has taken action on matters involving his son's clients. He maintains there's no legal or ethical conflict because his son no longer lives at home, and that he has no bias in favor of his son's clients. But Raytheon supporters regard his meddling in the DeltaWrx contract as problematic.

Motorola has its own reasons to complain. It objects to the way the proposals have been graded and questions Raytheon's ability to do the work. Late last month, the lead negotiator of LA-RICS sheepishly acknowledged that the agency mistakenly gave excerpts of the Motorola proposal to Raytheon. Motorola pounced on the mistake and used it to reinforce its insistence that the agency enter into dual negotiations with the two companies rather than focus exclusively on Raytheon.

The board of the joint powers authority was scheduled to conclude its negotiations with Raytheon this month. Amid all the recent controversy, the project's future is suddenly in doubt. So, if the first responders of Los Angeles County are unable to talk to one another during a fire, an earthquake or a terrorist attack, we'll know what to blame: sloppiness, recriminations and politics.


Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Psst ... wanna buy a parking spot?
    Psst ... wanna buy a parking spot?

    In Los Angeles, parking your car on the street can be almost as stressful as driving it in traffic. Day after day, motorists repeat the same drill in the congested neighborhoods of the city: They weave up and down the streets, eyes peeled for an empty spot or a driver sitting in a parked car. (Is...

  • In L.A., thirsting for a decent bar culture
    In L.A., thirsting for a decent bar culture

    London has pubs. Munich has beer halls. Houston has outdoor honky-tonks. Denver has brewpubs. The drinking scene in Los Angeles is less easy to characterize. Like so much else in this city, it's diffuse, fragmented and characterized by extremes: There are achingly cool lounges like the Standard...

  • Gentrifying L.A. without displacing the poor: Lessons from S.F.'s Tenderloin
    Gentrifying L.A. without displacing the poor: Lessons from S.F.'s Tenderloin

    Los Angeles may be replacing New York City as the gentrification capital of the United States. The national media seem positively obsessed with the transformation of once little-known communities like Highland Park; gentrification battles in Boyle Heights, Pico-Union and Echo Park hearken back...

  • L.A. transit officials should support affordable housing near rail lines
    L.A. transit officials should support affordable housing near rail lines

    The Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Agency is considering expanding its mission to include the development of affordable housing along transit lines. Metro, which operates the subways, light-rail lines and most of the region's buses, owns about 50 properties along its lines that could be...

  • L.A.'s minimum wage plan doesn't make sense
    L.A.'s minimum wage plan doesn't make sense

    Confronting unyielding poverty rates and economic inequality, Los Angeles city and county political leaders are debating whether hiking the minimum wage is a good idea. My firm, Beacon Economics, analyzed the effects of a jump from the current $9 state minimum wage to $13.25 within the city by...

  • L.A. needs a smarter street-cleaning program now
    L.A. needs a smarter street-cleaning program now

    Los Angeles has a trash problem. Streets, alleys and vacant lots are so littered with debris and garbage that a recent internal city report warned that some neighborhoods look unsafe and ungoverned. Only one-third of city streets are regularly swept. There's a backlog of 400 abandoned waste sites...

  • L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution
    L.A.'s freeway-adjacent residents need more protection from pollution

    A growing body of research shows that living next to a freeway can significantly increase the risk of asthma, heart disease, pre-term births, reduced lung function in children and premature death. Yet Los Angeles continues to approve residential developments next to freeways without imposing strong...

  • Most of us could do more to make it a truly charitable-giving season
    Most of us could do more to make it a truly charitable-giving season

    With the charitable-giving season in full swing, and nonprofits in the throes of their end-of-year asks, it feels like the right time to highlight a Scrooge-like fact: Greater Los Angeles is not as generous as it used to be and not as generous as it could be.