Supreme Court sends Missouri execution case back to appeals court

Courts and the Judiciary
Missouri inmate Russell Bucklew won't die Wednesday after all as Supreme Court sends case back to lower court
Missouri inmate's on-again, off-again execution is off for an indefinite period

The U.S. Supreme Court stayed a condemned Missouri inmate's execution Wednesday evening, sending the case back to the U.S. 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, and Missouri officials told those who had planned to witness it to go home.

The high court granted the stay for Russell Bucklew “pending the disposition of petitioner’s appeal. We leave for further consideration in the lower courts whether an evidentiary hearing is necessary.”

Bucklew's death warrant expires at midnight in Missouri, but state officials called off the execution after the Supreme Court issued its order about 6 p.m. Witnesses were not told how soon to return, just that it would not be soon, a state witness told the Los Angeles Times.

A spokesman for the Missouri attorney general's office said no further litigation was expected Wednesday.

Bucklew's attorneys had argued that state officials failed to demonstrate they could humanely execute the inmate, who suffers from a chronic, lifelong illness, cavernous hemangioma, which causes tumors in his head, neck and throat that can easily rupture and bleed.

His attorneys also questioned why Missouri officials refused to disclose information about lethal-injection procedures.

Missouri is among several states that changed lethal-injection drugs and suppliers as manufacturers pulled back in the face of international protests. Now they and some other states rely on a single drug, the barbiturate pentobarbital, made by compounding pharmacies not subject to Food and Drug Administration oversight.

One of Bucklew's attorneys, Cheryl Pilate, told The Times that they were “extremely pleased and relieved” by the court's decision.

“What this means is that the appeals court will hear Mr. Bucklew's claims under the 8th Amendment that he faced a great likelihood of a prolonged and tortuous execution because of the unique and severe medical condition,” Pilate said in a statement.

Bucklew, 45, was convicted of a rampage in Cape Girardeau County in 1996 that included fatally shooting Michael Sanders, his ex-girlfriend’s new boyfriend, in front of Sanders’ 6-year-old son, then kidnapping his ex-girlfriend and raping her before he was captured. A trooper was wounded during the chase.

He would have been the first inmate put to death since Oklahoma botched the execution of Clayton Lockett, 38, last month, provoking outrage and leading that state's governor to stay the next scheduled execution as well as order a review of Oklahoma’s lethal-injection procedure.

The Missouri attorney general and governor had defended their state's method of lethal injection.

On Tuesday, Bucklew’s execution had been on again, off again. A three-judge panel of the 8th Circuit imposed a stay. Then the full 8th Circuit lifted the stay. Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon denied Bucklew’s request for clemency. Then U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. imposed another stay.

Bucklew, who came within less than two hours of execution, was held within 50 feet of the death chamber.

A prison spokesman said Bucklew would remain at the prison Wednesday night. He refused to say for security reasons when Bucklew would be returned to the prison in Petosi, where he has been confined.

Among the witnesses sent home Wednesday night were the victim’s two sons, his sister, her husband, an uncle and a cousin, Bucklew’s two brothers, a doctor, a nurse, one of his attorneys, investigators who handled the case and Republican state Rep. Paul Fitzwater.

Fitzwater told The Times that he had awaited the execution in a small room with other state witnesses, apart from Sanders' and Bucklew's witnesses. When officials notified them that the execution had been stayed, he said, some witnesses were disappointed. “We waited all day long for this to happen.”

Corrections officials did not tell witnesses how soon they might be brought back, he said.

“It could be 30 days or six months,” Fitzwater said, noting the appeals court has to reconsider the case and the state attorney general has to set a new execution date.

Fitzwater, who leads a legislative committee on corrections, said it would have been the first execution he witnessed. He said he had asked to “see for myself” after receiving numerous phone calls from constituents inquiring about the state's lethal-injection procedure.

Earlier this year, Fitzwater - a staunch supporter of capital punishment - proposed switching to firing squads. The proposal drew widespread ridicule and did not pass. In hindsight, he said he would not propose it again.

He left the prison Wednesday concerned about what the U.S. Supreme Court's decision meant for death penalty advocates nationwide.

“This is a setback here in the state of Missouri and across the country. I know people here want to keep the death penalty. They got the wind knocked out of their sails here today.”

Seth Klamann reported from Bonne Terre and Molly Hennessy-Fiske from Houston.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Courts and the Judiciary
  • White House intruder arrested after entering front doors
    White House intruder arrested after entering front doors

    An intruder scaled a White House fence and made it all the way into the building Friday evening before he was caught and wrestled to the ground by security officers, the Secret Service said. President Obama and his family had already left for Camp David when the incident occurred.

  • Man who killed daughter and grandchildren had violent past
    Man who killed daughter and grandchildren had violent past

    Don Spirit, a Florida grandfather who fatally shot his daughter Sarah Lorraine Spirit and six grandchildren before killing himself, had a long history of domestic violence — at one point pushing his pregnant daughter against a refrigerator and assaulting and threatening his former...

  • Rain pounds Texas: A sign the drought is ending?
    Rain pounds Texas: A sign the drought is ending?

    In Texas, where the governor once urged the public to pray for rain, this week’s torrential storms might finally be a sign of lasting relief for the state plagued by years of drought. Or maybe not.

  • For many in Congress, a first test on issues of war
    For many in Congress, a first test on issues of war

    Lawmakers' votes this week on whether or not to train and equip Syrian opposition forces in the fight against Islamic State were arguably the most consequential after nearly two years in which Congress is likely to set a new low for productivity.

  • Egyptian militant admits links to 1998 U.S. embassy bombings

    A longtime Egyptian militant with ties to Al Qaeda and Osama bin Laden admitted in federal court Friday that he had links to the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings in Africa, a surprise guilty plea that the judge sharply questioned because it reduces his prison time from a potential life sentence to...

  • Four takeaways from the vote in Congress to arm Syrian rebels
    Four takeaways from the vote in Congress to arm Syrian rebels

    What was supposed to be a no-drama final session of Congress before the campaign season turned into anything but as President Obama's new strategy to combat the threat from Islamic State resulted in a wrenching vote that is likely to reverberate through the midterm election and...