- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
- | single page
E-mail
Print
Torture is torture
Re “Files detail CIA tactics on captives,” April 17
Just because torture was legal in Nazi Germany did not make it right. Nor did it protect Nazi war criminals from prosecution at the Nuremberg trials.
Just because some fanatical lawyers in the Bush administration decided that torture should be legal does not make it right either.
What happens the next time some despot, here or abroad, decides that torture is legal? Do we let that pass?
We must prosecute these criminals in the Central Intelligence Agency to the fullest extent of the law or we, as a civilized society, will have failed.
Brian Bard
Glendale
As a former political prisoner who was tortured by the Argentine military and adopted as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International, I am very disappointed at President Obama's decision not to allow prosecutions of members of the U.S. government who engaged in torture. His decision puts him on the side of those who argued that Nazi leaders accused of crimes against humanity were only following orders. Even worse, it implies the rationalization that the goal of defeating terrorism justifies any means. This is a flawed point of view. Torture is torture, and it does not matter if it was practiced by a Stalinist operative, an agent of the Gestapo -- or even by a member of an intelligence agency of a democratic country.
Nestor Fantini
Northridge
::
Isn't it amazing how a very few lawyers in the Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department can write secret memos that allow the U.S. government to overturn laws, treaties and conventions?
The Supreme Court justices must be green with envy -- usually nine of them act to issue a ruling, each undergoes Senate confirmation, and they must publish their opinions. Now we know where true power resides.
Lewis Cohen
Riverside
::
Re “Close the torture loophole,” editorial, April 18
I was an intelligence officer in the Navy Reserve trained to debrief naval officers released from POW camps in Vietnam. In order to be familiar with the torture inflicted on our men, we were subjected to torture, including waterboarding and walling.
Granted, waterboarding and walling are no picnic -- but I survived in good order. I learned that the subject thinks that he is drowning but that the action is harmless, and that a Navy doctor was nearby to prevent any subsequent illness or harm.
Re “Files detail CIA tactics on captives,” April 17
Just because torture was legal in Nazi Germany did not make it right. Nor did it protect Nazi war criminals from prosecution at the Nuremberg trials.
Just because some fanatical lawyers in the Bush administration decided that torture should be legal does not make it right either.
What happens the next time some despot, here or abroad, decides that torture is legal? Do we let that pass?
We must prosecute these criminals in the Central Intelligence Agency to the fullest extent of the law or we, as a civilized society, will have failed.
Brian Bard
Glendale
As a former political prisoner who was tortured by the Argentine military and adopted as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International, I am very disappointed at President Obama's decision not to allow prosecutions of members of the U.S. government who engaged in torture. His decision puts him on the side of those who argued that Nazi leaders accused of crimes against humanity were only following orders. Even worse, it implies the rationalization that the goal of defeating terrorism justifies any means. This is a flawed point of view. Torture is torture, and it does not matter if it was practiced by a Stalinist operative, an agent of the Gestapo -- or even by a member of an intelligence agency of a democratic country.
Nestor Fantini
Northridge
::
Isn't it amazing how a very few lawyers in the Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department can write secret memos that allow the U.S. government to overturn laws, treaties and conventions?
The Supreme Court justices must be green with envy -- usually nine of them act to issue a ruling, each undergoes Senate confirmation, and they must publish their opinions. Now we know where true power resides.
Lewis Cohen
Riverside
::
Re “Close the torture loophole,” editorial, April 18
I was an intelligence officer in the Navy Reserve trained to debrief naval officers released from POW camps in Vietnam. In order to be familiar with the torture inflicted on our men, we were subjected to torture, including waterboarding and walling.
Granted, waterboarding and walling are no picnic -- but I survived in good order. I learned that the subject thinks that he is drowning but that the action is harmless, and that a Navy doctor was nearby to prevent any subsequent illness or harm.
Digg
Twitter
Facebook
StumbleUpon