Opinion Editorial

Unlicensed drivers and impounded cars

Last April, the Los Angeles Police Department adopted a new approach to the problem of unlicensed drivers, many of whom are barred from ever obtaining a license because of their immigration status. Under the rule, known as Special Order 7, police officers are authorized to impound the cars of unlicensed drivers (as they always have been), but those drivers who have no prior violations and can provide proof of insurance may retrieve their cars as soon as they pay the impound fees, rather than waiting 30 days. Police Chief Charlie Beck said the change was designed to relieve the unfair burden that impounds placed on people living in the country illegally.

That policy, however, didn't sit well with the union that represents police officers and a conservative watchdog group, both of which filed a lawsuit challenging the rule. Now, a Los Angeles judge has found in their favor, ruling that Special Order 7 is illegal because it is preempted by state law.

This page supported the LAPD policy as both reasonable and practical, and we're dismayed that the judge struck it down. But it was never a perfect solution. A far more sensible approach to dealing with the problem would be to enact legislation that allows immigrants, regardless of their residency status, to apply for and receive driver's licenses. A driver's license doesn't confer legal residency; it merely tells law enforcement authorities that the person behind the wheel of that car has passed a written exam and a driving test and is qualified to be on the road. Granting licenses to noncitizens would also help address the unfair reality, as documented in 2010 by the the Center for Investigative Reporting, that most of the drivers losing their cars at checkpoints for not having a license were sober immigrants who were driving perfectly well.

AB 60, introduced by Assemblyman Luis Alejo (D-Watsonville), would provide driver's licenses regardless of citizenship status. Some critics will argue that such a law will only reward lawbreaking. But that ignores the fact that undocumented immigrants are already here and are already behind the wheel. Wouldn't we all benefit if those drivers are trained, capable and insured?

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Obama's trump card on immigration
    Obama's trump card on immigration

    The president can push ahead on reform without Congress.

  • Continue -- but gradually reduce -- federal risk in terrorism insurance
    Continue -- but gradually reduce -- federal risk in terrorism insurance

    The terrorists who turned the World Trade Center into rubble struck a devastating blow to the U.S. economy too, and few sectors felt it as acutely as the insurance industry. Afterward, insurers balked at providing any coverage for damage caused by further acts of terrorism, making it harder...

  • In Haiti, only the face of power has changed
    In Haiti, only the face of power has changed

    Almost five years since the devastating earthquake that rocked Haiti, the country remains adrift, and in recent weeks, even more than usual. In town after town, as well as in the capital, Port-au-Prince, large, angry crowds have gathered regularly to express their dissatisfaction with Haiti's...

  • Immigrant driver's license policy makes sense
    Immigrant driver's license policy makes sense

    Beginning Jan. 1, immigrants who are here illegally will be able to take another small step out of the shadows by applying for California driver's licenses. It took years to enact this controversial policy, but ultimately granting licenses to qualified drivers, regardless of their legal status,...

  • California's egg-laying hens to get their breathing room
    California's egg-laying hens to get their breathing room

    Next month, all of California's 15 million egg-laying hens must be freed from the cramped, restrictive battery cages that have long been used on most egg farms. In the future, they will have enough space to stand up, lie down, turn around, and spread their wings without touching another bird.

  • A tax system tilted toward the rich
    A tax system tilted toward the rich

    Congress managed to pass a tax bill in December — a great relief to tax professionals like myself. But what our legislators didn't do was address the fundamentally unfair way the United States taxes people who work for a living compared with people who live off of the earnings of their...

Comments
Loading