Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion Editorial

Unlicensed drivers and impounded cars

Last April, the Los Angeles Police Department adopted a new approach to the problem of unlicensed drivers, many of whom are barred from ever obtaining a license because of their immigration status. Under the rule, known as Special Order 7, police officers are authorized to impound the cars of unlicensed drivers (as they always have been), but those drivers who have no prior violations and can provide proof of insurance may retrieve their cars as soon as they pay the impound fees, rather than waiting 30 days. Police Chief Charlie Beck said the change was designed to relieve the unfair burden that impounds placed on people living in the country illegally.

That policy, however, didn't sit well with the union that represents police officers and a conservative watchdog group, both of which filed a lawsuit challenging the rule. Now, a Los Angeles judge has found in their favor, ruling that Special Order 7 is illegal because it is preempted by state law.

This page supported the LAPD policy as both reasonable and practical, and we're dismayed that the judge struck it down. But it was never a perfect solution. A far more sensible approach to dealing with the problem would be to enact legislation that allows immigrants, regardless of their residency status, to apply for and receive driver's licenses. A driver's license doesn't confer legal residency; it merely tells law enforcement authorities that the person behind the wheel of that car has passed a written exam and a driving test and is qualified to be on the road. Granting licenses to noncitizens would also help address the unfair reality, as documented in 2010 by the the Center for Investigative Reporting, that most of the drivers losing their cars at checkpoints for not having a license were sober immigrants who were driving perfectly well.

AB 60, introduced by Assemblyman Luis Alejo (D-Watsonville), would provide driver's licenses regardless of citizenship status. Some critics will argue that such a law will only reward lawbreaking. But that ignores the fact that undocumented immigrants are already here and are already behind the wheel. Wouldn't we all benefit if those drivers are trained, capable and insured?

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Reining in immigration scammers

    Reining in immigration scammers

    In California, Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez (D-San Diego) and Assemblyman Kevin de Leon (D-Los Angeles), with the help of the California Bar Assn., have introduced legislation to protect immigrants from unscrupulous lawyers who commit fraud.

  • The Bible's case for immigration reform

    The Bible's case for immigration reform

    Showing compassion to foreigners and strangers is central to biblical morality, and evangelical Christians have joined the fight to pass commonsense reform.

  • Obama's trump card on immigration

    Obama's trump card on immigration

    The president can push ahead on reform without Congress.

  • I've got the perfect job for Donald Trump right here

    I've got the perfect job for Donald Trump right here

    In a few days, the queen of England -- “Elizabeth the Second, by the grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" and so forth -- becomes the longest-reigning monarch in the even longer history of that sceptered isle.

  • Can Californians' privacy be protected in a wired world?

    Can Californians' privacy be protected in a wired world?

    State lawmakers have been trying for four years to provide Californians with more protection against warrantless snooping into their Internet-connected lives. The Legislature is about to take up the issue again, voting on a bill, SB 178, that would require state and local law enforcement agencies...

  • Do you think like an economist?

    Do you think like an economist?

    Let's see if you think like an economist.

  • Living on $2 a day in America

    Living on $2 a day in America

    When we first met Ashley, she was 19 and a new mom, living with her mother, brother, uncle and cousin in one of Baltimore's public housing developments. Everyone in the home was out of work; no one was on welfare. The unit was furnished with only a three-legged table propped up against a wall,...

  • U.S. patience with Myanmar should only go so far

    U.S. patience with Myanmar should only go so far

    When the United States reestablished full diplomatic relations with Myanmar in 2012, the Obama administration was optimistic that the once-isolated Southeast Asian country, also known as Burma, was moving steadily along a path toward democracy. The ruling junta had recently turned over much of...