Endorsements
The Los Angeles Times endorsements in the March 3 election
Opinion Editorial

Cruel and inhuman conditions for immigrants

It is cruel and inhumane to keep prison inmates in solitary confinement for indefinite periods or to put them there for arbitrary reasons. Studies indicate that inmates subjected to prolonged isolation are at risk for mental illness and suicide. That's led human rights groups and the United Nations' special rapporteur on torture, among others, to conclude that solitary confinement should be abolished, with very few exceptions.

Yet its use is widespread, not only in state and federal prisons but in immigration detention facilities. About 1% of immigrants detained by the U.S. government at any given time are confined to small cells, by themselves, and are allowed out for only one hour a day — even though they pose no danger to others, according to a report released this year by the National Immigrant Justice Center. That's especially disturbing when you consider that immigration detainees aren't serving criminal sentences but are being held to ensure that they appear for their civil deportation cases.

Now the Department of Homeland Security has unveiled new rules aimed at curbing the use of solitary confinement. The changes, if implemented properly, could help protect detainees' health and ensure that their ability to fight their legal cases isn't undermined because their telephone access is limited to one hour a day.

Among the most important changes is a requirement that all immigration detention centers, including local jails and private facilities that contract with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, report to federal officials when a detainee is isolated. The new rules also call for the facilities to justify in writing to federal officials why any immigrant has been in solitary confinement for longer than two weeks. The old rules required the facilities to report such cases only after one month.

The new policy explicitly forbids placing immigrants in solitary confinement against their will because of personal characteristics, such as gender identity or sexual orientation, and adds reporting safeguards for vulnerable populations, including the disabled, those with mental health issues and victims of sexual abuse. That provision is key because transgender detainees are often placed in solitary confinement for prolonged periods by jail officials who argue that it's for the detainees' protection, even though it can cause more harm than good, human rights groups argue.

The Department of Homeland Security's decision to revamp its policy is welcome. Now if only Congress would enact stricter guidelines, like those contained in the Senate immigration reform bill that limit the use of solitary confinement in immigration detention to 15 days.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Prisons and American values
    Prisons and American values

    Our treatment of prisoners expresses our values, and mistreatment such as that alleged by California hunger strikers should not be tolerated.

  • Congress should hear out Netanyahu
    Congress should hear out Netanyahu

    When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu addresses Congress on Tuesday about the dangers posed by Iran's nuclear program, he will have to overcome the deafening political static created by the circumstances of his invitation. Not only did House Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) invite...

  • The Times' endorsements for Tuesday's election
    The Times' endorsements for Tuesday's election

    Don't sit this election out. It's true that there's no high-profile mayor's race or marijuana ballot measure, but Tuesday's election could lead to one of the most significant changes to local government in years. If Charter Amendments 1 and 2 pass, city and school board elections will move,...

  • Who killed at CPAC, the GOP's red meat 2016 auditions?
    Who killed at CPAC, the GOP's red meat 2016 auditions?

    The fervent Republicans who throng the Conservative Political Action Conference every year aren't representative of the American electorate. They aren't even representative of the GOP electorate. For four of the last five years, their straw poll for president has chosen Rand Paul or Ron Paul....

  • The Obama administration is seeking the right deal with Iran
    The Obama administration is seeking the right deal with Iran

    The negotiating endgame with Iran is upon us. What terms are acceptable?

  • How Abraham Lincoln said that black lives matter
    How Abraham Lincoln said that black lives matter

    A decade and a half into the 21st century, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 is under fire, and white-on-black violence brings the cry that black lives matter. As we approach the 150th anniversary of the assassination of President Lincoln, we would do well to reconsider his most famous...

  • Translating trust in Iraq, one Arabic greeting at a time
    Translating trust in Iraq, one Arabic greeting at a time

    The United States has sent its most potent weapon to Iraq to battle Islamic State. She's a 5-foot-6-inch, 60-year-old grandmother. When I served as a military advisor to Iraqi security forces in 2011, Um Safa was our cavalry battalion's chief interpreter. She accompanied the commander to...

  • California's public unions have too much clout and compensation
    California's public unions have too much clout and compensation

    Mayor Eric Garcetti, a pro-labor Democrat, has tried to restore ties with Los Angeles' public employee unions after most of them backed his opponent in the 2013 mayoral race. Nevertheless, the mayor is sticking with the hard line he has taken in contract talks: asking city workers to accept a...

Comments
Loading