OpinionOpinion L.A.

The silly George Zimmerman-O.J. Simpson comparison

Reading the 250-plus reader letters so far on the George Zimmerman trial hasn't exactly been an uplifting experience. This isn't to say the letters lacked insight; on the contrary, most were earnest and well reasoned. The problem was the subject matter: Not even the most talented of writers could put a positive spin on the needless death of Trayvon Martin, the unarmed teenager who was shot and killed by Zimmerman last year in Florida following a brief altercation between the two.

But even among this depressing lot was a subset of letters that especially stung. Roughly 10 of the submissions offered on observation similar to this letter's (whose writer's name I'll withhold):

"It is interesting to note the outrage over the Zimmerman verdict as compared to the lack of outrage over the O.J. Simpson verdict. Racism must only be a one-way street."

If you'll recall, Simpson was accused of killing his white wife and her white friend.

Where to start giving the lie to this comparison?

If memory serves, the outrage over Simpson's acquittal had more to do with money than race -- that one wealthy celebrity was able to buy a get-out-of-jail-free card. Sure, Simpson's lawyers played the race card, but their audacity and deftness in doing so was an outgrowth of their client's ability to afford their talents.

What was upsetting was the feeling that Simpson got away with murder, not the murder of two white people.

And as a colleague reminded me, many African Americans were upset that other, less wealthy blacks endured far harsher punishments for much less serious crimes than the one Simpson was accused of committing.

But with regard to race, there's a key difference between the two trials: Simpson claimed complete innocence in his ex-wife's murder, whereas the question in the Zimmerman case was whether the defendant was justified in killing Martin. The entire trial was, in essence, about whether Martin was responsible for his own death, and Zimmerman's lawyers pushed more than a few racial buttons to make their case. Zimmerman's defense team presented a cutout of a swaggering, hoodie-wearing Martin, giving a visual reminder of just how menacing the teenager appeared in the dark. The prosecution's key witness, Rachel Jeantel, was not-so-subtly shamed by Zimmerman's lawyers for speaking in a way that makes some white people wince.

In short, it was never implied in the Simpson trial that his wife was behaving in a way that all but required her death; Zimmerman's defense was to convince jurors that they too would find Martin suspicious enough to get out of their car and pursue him.

Not surprisingly, many African Americans (and others) are upset not just at the verdict but at the process that punished no one for shooting and killing an unarmed black teenager.


God and intolerance

Immigration reform: It's alive!

President Obama is absolutely not the 'race-baiter in chief'

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Zimmerman verdict: Readers on all sides find little to like
    Zimmerman verdict: Readers on all sides find little to like

    The reader reaction to George Zimmerman's acquittal Saturday on all charges in the shooting death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin doesn't fall in line with fears last week that violent uprisings would result from such a verdict. So far, most readers have been contemplative, measured and...

  • On race, President Obama can unite us
    On race, President Obama can unite us

    Critics were quick to call President Obama a “race-baiter” after he addressed the nation Friday about Trayvon Martin’s killing and what it’s like for young black males in this country who, he said, “are painted with a broad brush.”

  • Violent protests don't honor Trayvon Martin
    Violent protests don't honor Trayvon Martin

    It was hard to watch Monday night’s peaceful demonstration in Los Angeles against the George Zimmerman verdict turn violent in the hands of rogue protesters.

  • How to honor Trayvon Martin
    How to honor Trayvon Martin

    In the wake of the George Zimmerman verdict, which acquitted him in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin, activists took to the streets across the nation to stand up for civil rights. For many, this was a black-and-white case. A neighborhood patrolman was spooked by a black 17-year-old...

  • President Obama is absolutely not the 'race-baiter in chief'
    President Obama is absolutely not the 'race-baiter in chief'

    President Obama joined the national conversation on race Friday, addressing the death of Trayvon Martin, the slain Florida teenager whose main offense seems to have been his skin color. After a week of protests in the wake of shooter George Zimmerman’s acquittal, some of which...

  • Boycotting the football industrial complex
    Boycotting the football industrial complex

    A few years ago, I began to feel guilty about watching football. What started it were the revelations about brain damage we now know the game caused in many retired players. But there was plenty more — the cynical commercialization of the sport, its cultish celebration of violence and...

  • The Beatles' cry of freedom: 'Money,' 50 years later
    The Beatles' cry of freedom: 'Money,' 50 years later

    In early 1964 a friend called me up and asked if I wanted to hear the new Beatles album, "With the Beatles." It had come out in Britain a couple of months before, but no one I knew had heard it, or for that matter heard of it. My friend's father, an airplane pilot, had brought it...

  • Football is America's war game
    Football is America's war game

    The NFL will be visiting London this year. Three regular-season games are set for Wembley Stadium, where the NFL has touched down annually since 2007. It's not surprising that the NFL wants to expand into new territories. Under the logic of capitalism, nothing stays still: You expand or...