OpinionOpinion L.A.

U.S. 'advisors' will look like American boots on the ground to ISIS

IraqBarack ObamaVietnamWars and InterventionsIslamic StateU.S. Military
300 U.S. advisors aren't boots on the ground in Iraq? Try telling that to ISIS

Three hundred Spartans once held off the Persian hordes at Thermopylae. Can 300 Americans hold off the ISIS hordes in Iraq?

President Obama obviously hopes so. He announced Thursday that up to 300 U.S. military advisors would be sent to Iraq to help fend off the threat posed by fighters of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria.

Which certainly falls under under the “We gotta do something!” rule of foreign policy.

But does it pass the common-sense test? Not really.

First, it puts Americans in harm’s way. And as a child of the ’60s and Vietnam, I long ago lost my enthusiasm for putting American lives on the line to fight someone else’s war.

And two, just exactly what kind of advice can these Americans offer that will make a difference? I mean, if the Iraqi army doesn’t know how to fight by now, how is hearing it from the Americans likely to change things?

Not to mention that the word “advisors” conjures bad memories for plenty of folks here (see Vietnam, above).

And then there’s this, from Obama in his news conference Thursday: “There’s no military solution inside of Iraq, certainly not one that’s led by the United States.”

So why the advisors?

No one wants American boots back on the ground in Iraq. Especially when it’s clear that things are going from bad to worse. But just because it’s only 300 Americans, and just because you call them advisors, that doesn’t mean they aren’t boots on the ground — and targets.

Put another way: What if it’s your son who’s one of the 300? You feeling OK about him going to Iraq?

As my colleagues Kathleen Hennessey and Christi Parsons reported Thursday: “Obama has said he wants to use the crisis to force long-delayed political reforms in Iraq. Washington has been piling pressure on Iraq’s Shiite-led government to enact changes that could appease the Sunni minority and stave off a wider civil war.”

That’s Iraq’s real problem: Politically, it’s a mess. Its government is reaping the whirlwind of misguided policies and priorities.

It’s a shame that more violence and bloodshed appear to be Iraq’s fate. But Iraq’s problems are Iraq’s.

Putting 300 Americans in harm’s way isn’t likely to change that.

Follow Paul Whitefield on Twitter @PaulWhitefield1

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
IraqBarack ObamaVietnamWars and InterventionsIslamic StateU.S. Military
  • What 'war on women'?
    What 'war on women'?

    On Friday, the White House announced its “It's On Us” initiative aimed at combating sexual assaults on college campuses. I'm all in favor of combating sexual assault, but the first priority in combating a problem is understanding it.

  • Ashley Swearengin for state controller
    Ashley Swearengin for state controller

    Californians have been breathing a bit easier in recent months as the state government's finances have turned — slowly, like an ocean freighter — from disaster to solvency. But the work is hardly done, and diligence is called for to ensure the budget doesn't drift off...

  • Let's make a climate deal, California
    Let's make a climate deal, California

    It has been almost 25 years since the United States joined much of the world in Rio de Janeiro and tentatively agreed to do something to reduce the pollutants associated with global warming and other climate disruption. Since then, though, the U.S. has been a laggard in taking major action....

  • Why single out L.A. hotel workers for a wage boost?
    Why single out L.A. hotel workers for a wage boost?

    The Los Angeles City Council is, again, trying to rush through a proposal to establish a special $15.37-an-hour minimum wage just for hotel workers. A committee hearing has been scheduled for Tuesday and a full council vote is expected the following day, even though three reports from...

  • What about those other greenhouse gases?
    What about those other greenhouse gases?

    The U.N. Climate Summit that starts Tuesday is a precursor to the Paris climate conference scheduled for next year. No treaty will come out of the summit in New York, which is more of a brainstorming and cheerleading session.

  • The ugly surprise of out-of-network doctors and 'balance billing'
    The ugly surprise of out-of-network doctors and 'balance billing'

    The New York Times' Elisabeth Rosenthal offered an important lesson in healthcare economics over the weekend that's a must-read for anyone about to undergo a major medical procedure.