Grading City Hall: How is L.A.'s city controller doing so far?

Opinion L.A.

Opinion Opinion L.A.

Missing from SOTU: 'grand bargain,' Buffett Rule -- and King Canute

One way of measuring a president’s agenda is by what he highlights in his State of the Union address. Another is by noticing what got left out.

President Obama recycled a long list of old but unattained goals in his speech Tuesday: a higher federal minimum wage, early childhood education, immigration reform, tax reform, infrastructure spending, gun control, legislation to close the wage gap between men and women, and closing the detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. All were in last year’s State of the Union address too.

What didn’t make the cut? At least three items:

A “grand bargain”: For three years, Obama pursued a big fiscal deal that would have traded higher taxes (a Democratic goal) for cuts in long-term spending on Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security (a Republican goal). But with the federal deficit slowly shrinking, members of Congress in both parties are even less enthusiastic about tackling that kind of difficult compromise than before. Obama didn’t even try to sell them on it this time. It’s over.

The Buffett Rule: In 2012, Obama called on Congress to impose a minimum income tax of 30% on anyone making more than $1 million a year, inspired by billionaire Warren Buffett’s observation that his secretary paid a higher percentage of her income in taxes than he did. (The secretary, Debbie Bosanek, even got to sit in the gallery with Michelle Obama that year.) In 2013, Obama renewed the call, at least by implication. This year? Gone. Sorry, Warren.

King Canute: In a different vein, an early draft of this year’s speech would have had the president denounce wage stagnation, stalled social mobility and income inequality, and then declare: “Our job is to reverse these tides.” But that sounded uncomfortably close to the story of King Canute, the 11th century Danish ruler of England who famously commanded the tide to stop. (It didn’t.) Historians say Canute wasn’t mad; he was trying to show his courtiers that the king’s power had limits. That’s true about Obama’s sway over income inequality too, but that probably wasn’t the point the president wanted to stress. In the final version of the speech, Obama said he hoped, instead, to “reverse these trends,”  a much blander phrase — to the disappointment of columnists and historians alike.


State of the Union: Obama's era of limits

Time to retire the State of the Union shout-out

How the Democrats can win back the House and keep the Senate -- in 6 steps

Follow Doyle McManus on Twitter @doylemcmanus and Google+

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • State of the Union: Obama's ambitions, lack of tools to achieve them

    State of the Union: Obama's ambitions, lack of tools to achieve them

    WASHINGTON — President Obama’s sixth speech on the state of the union will spotlight many issues, but more than anything may illuminate the vast gap between his policy ambitions and the tools he has to achieve them.

  • Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Given all the other critical things people are saying about Donald Trump, you might think he would (as it were) brush off the jokes about his hair.

  • Watts riots, 50 years later: What has L.A. learned, and done?

    Watts riots, 50 years later: What has L.A. learned, and done?

    We look to anniversaries of momentous events — the beginning of World War I (100 years, last July), the end of the Civil War (150 years, in April), the voting rights march from Selma to Montgomery, Ala., (50 years, in March) — to note the passage of time, to measure the progress of the generations,...

  • How to kill the summer job

    How to kill the summer job

    I had a lot of summer jobs. I was a foot messenger in New York for a couple of summers. I worked as a receptionist and mail room flunky. Before my junior year of high school, I briefly sold ice cream snacks — sort of yuppie bonbons — on the street for a company called Love Bites. The uniform was...

  • No Export-Import Bank? No problem.

    No Export-Import Bank? No problem.

    July was supposed to be a particularly bad month for the U.S. economy. On June 30, the U.S. Export-Import Bank's charter officially expired. For the previous 81 years, this little-known New Deal relic handed out hundreds of billions of dollars in taxpayer-backed financing to benefit a select few...

  • L.A. needs these sensible gun-control measures

    L.A. needs these sensible gun-control measures

    Last week, it was a movie theater in Lafayette, La. The week before, it was two military centers in Chattanooga, Tenn. Before that it was the Emanuel AME church in Charleston, S.C. The mass shootings are like a steady drumbeat, and intermingled with them are the daily smaller-scale killings in...