OpinionOpinion L.A.

No separation of church and state, please; we're British

Minority GroupsRoman CatholicismFeminismPoliticsAnglicanismSame-Sex MarriageParliament
In England, there's no wall of separation between church and state
The Church of England's decision on female bishop is welcomed by the prime minister

“It’s worse in England” is a comment I find myself making fairly often, usually when a fellow American journalist complains about restrictions on the press imposed by the Obama administration or a federal court. But I’d make the same observation to Catholics, evangelicals and others who claim that religious freedom is under siege in this country (a sentiment that has abated a bit with the Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby decision).

Even American politicians who condemn the Hobby Lobby decision take pains to make clear that they don’t want to meddle in the internal policies of churches and other purely religious institutions. There has been relatively little criticism of the Obama administration’s policy of exempting churches from the contraception mandate.

Likewise, even the most feminist American politicians would be reluctant to argue publicly that the Roman Catholic Church should ordain women as priests and bishops, let alone that laws against sex discrimination in hiring be applied to the church.

Now for the compare and contrast with England: This week the Synod of the Church of England approved the ordination of women as bishops. (Women have been ordained as priests since 1994.) Among the prominent figures praising the move were Prime Minister David Cameron and Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg.

Cameron said that the vote was “a great day for the church” — a sentiment he’s free to express as a member of the church — but he added that it was also a victory “for equality" generally. Clegg is not a believer (he has been described variously as an atheist and an agnostic), and he has advocated stripping the Church of England of its status as an established church. Nevertheless, he hailed the vote as “a watershed moment for the Church of England and a huge step forward in making our society fairer.”

Clegg added: “Allowing women to become bishops is another long-overdue step toward gender equality in senior positions.”

Well, yes. Like the office of deputy prime minister, a bishopric is a “senior position.” But it’s a position in a religious institution shaped by theological principles. The synod decided that those principles didn’t stand in the way of breaking with tradition and ordaining women as bishops; Anglicans on the other side of the debate argued (as Roman Catholics do) that by Jesus’ ordinance, only men can be successors to the all-male Apostles. But it seems odd that a politician who is a nonbeliever would take sides in an internal theological debate.

But in England there’s no 1st Amendment or “wall of separation” between church and state. That’s why the synod’s action must be approved by a committee of the British Parliament. In the past, Parliament has legislated on revisions in the Book of Common Prayer and whether the Church of England may perform same-sex marriages. Government also plays a role in religious schools that would be considered intrusive in this country.

American evangelicals and Catholics who cry wolf about threats to religious liberty posed by civil gay marriage or a contraceptive mandate for health insurance plans should look across the pond and count their blessings.

Follow Michael McGough on Twitter @MichaelMcGough3

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Minority GroupsRoman CatholicismFeminismPoliticsAnglicanismSame-Sex MarriageParliament
  • What's so offensive about Esquire's praise of 42-year-old women?
    What's so offensive about Esquire's praise of 42-year-old women?

    Tom Junod set the social web aflame with his article praising 42-year-old women. Never did one think that Esquire, a men’s magazine that’s stayed above the lad mag fray, could enrage so many people. But that it did, with people accusing Junod of sexism.

  • Is Obama's Islamic State escalation justified?
    Is Obama's Islamic State escalation justified?

    In his address to the nation almost two weeks ago, President Obama promised to use force against the armies of Islamic State "wherever they are," and he specifically mentioned Syria. But Monday night's airstrikes in that country came sooner and with more force than expected,...

  • Seal Beach can't simply trap and kill its way out of a coyote problem
    Seal Beach can't simply trap and kill its way out of a coyote problem

    At the point at which coyotes are following people into their houses, and killing dozens of pets within a small town in a short period of time, yes, it’s time to do something. Normally, trapping and euthanizing coyotes is a bad idea, for several reasons. But in Seal Beach, things have...

  • Are toll lanes elitist or progressive?
    Are toll lanes elitist or progressive?

    Allowing motorists to speed to work past clogged lanes of traffic, if they’re willing to pay thousands of dollars a year, could be seen as a way to raise money for other transit projects that benefit the public widely, or as the opposite: using the funds that all Californians pay...

  • New Afghan government; same old problems
    New Afghan government; same old problems

    President Obama called Kabul on Sunday to congratulate Afghan presidential contenders Ashraf Ghani and Abdullah Abdullah for finally accepting a power-sharing deal to resolve a months-long dispute over who won in an election deeply marred by fraud. "Signing this political...

  • What 'war on women'?
    What 'war on women'?

    On Friday, the White House announced its “It's On Us” initiative aimed at combating sexual assaults on college campuses. I'm all in favor of combating sexual assault, but the first priority in combating a problem is understanding it.

  • Let's make a climate deal, California
    Let's make a climate deal, California

    It has been almost 25 years since the United States joined much of the world in Rio de Janeiro and tentatively agreed to do something to reduce the pollutants associated with global warming and other climate disruption. Since then, though, the U.S. has been a laggard in taking major action....

  • Ashley Swearengin for state controller
    Ashley Swearengin for state controller

    Californians have been breathing a bit easier in recent months as the state government's finances have turned — slowly, like an ocean freighter — from disaster to solvency. But the work is hardly done, and diligence is called for to ensure the budget doesn't drift off...