Opinion Readers React
Readers React

America isn't the first power to fail at Mideast conquest

To the editor: The capture by warring Islamic militants of large quantities of weaponry from Iraqi government forces will strike a familiar note to historians familiar with the late 19th century. ("ISIS weapons windfall may alter balance in Iraq, Syria conflicts," June 29)

At the time, Egypt conscripted a force of about 10,000 men, under the command of the hapless English Col. William Hicks, to locate and defeat in Sudan a radical Islamist force led by the Mahdi, a self-styled heir to the prophet Muhammad.

The Mahdi's followers, equipped with swords, spears and antique firearms, killed Hicks and all but a few hundred of the unmotivated Egyptian conscripts. The bounty of arms, including modern rifles, batteries of artillery and boundless rounds of ammunition, helped make possible a brutal Islamist conquest of Sudan, including the fall of the capital city of Khartoum and the slaughter of its inhabitants.

Those doubting that history repeats itself would do well to remember this nearly forgotten episode of Mideast history.

Edward Hansen, San Diego


To the editor: The Middle East has always been partitioned according to its ethnicities, mores and religious preferences. Neither the overlords in London who originally drew today's national lines nor the violent ministrations of the George W. Bush administration have altered the natural inclination of these people. ("Amid Iraq unrest, idea of three autonomous enclaves gains traction," June 30)

Hopefully, Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Burbank), who apparently has a grip on this reality, is voicing a plan that President Obama will hear.

Jacqueline Kerr, Los Feliz

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 'The Interview' pulled: Sony let the bad guys win
    'The Interview' pulled: Sony let the bad guys win

    To the editor: While I understand concern for public safety, to allow anyone or any country to dictate through threat is a huge mistake. Giving in to bullies hurts all of us, and as we all know, it opens the door to more of the same. ("Sony scraps 'The Interview' release; North Korea blamed for...

  • John Yoo's tortured logic on torture

    To the editor: I am appalled that The Times provided a forum to John Yoo, who drafted the Bush administration memos that enabled torture. He is unrepentant in his defense of the torture memo that allowed the pain, degradation and humiliation of human beings, many of whom were ultimately found...

  • Why graduating 'on time' doesn't guarantee success

    To the editor: As someone who is taking more than four years to graduate, I absolutely believe that four-year graduation rates don't provide a complete picture of success. A student who achieves his or her diploma in 48 months is in no way more likely to achieve at life than someone who takes...

  • In defense of Amazon's customer service

    To the editor: I was surprised to read David Lazarus' column on the difficulty of reaching a live customer-service worker at a company like Amazon after having just exclaimed to my husband how amazed I was at an interaction I had with it. ("Firms' don't-call-us policies speak volumes," Dec. 15)

  • Don't let the religious zealots win their war against intelligence
    Don't let the religious zealots win their war against intelligence

    To the editor: How many more times do I have to open the newspaper to read that students have been massacred? This is an atrocious genocide upon the defenseless around the world, conducted by ignorant cowards, often religious zealots and misogynists. If we're not careful, they'll win this war...

  • FDIC couldn't cover a big bank bailout without taxpayer support

    To the editor: In response to a letter from California Bankers Assn. chief Rodney Brown about my concern with Congress repealing an important financial reform, it should escape no one that the public is still on the hook when the largest banks face their next financial crisis. ("How easing...