Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

On the California gnatcatcher and development

To the editor: As the senior authors of the paper on the California gnatcatcher denigrated by Occidental College biologist John McCormack, we wish to make clear that, contrary to his implications, no one other than the authors had any say in the analyses, interpretation or writing of the paper. We stand behind our peer-reviewed conclusion, published in the top-ranking American ornithological journal, that the California population of gnatcatcher does not represent a genetically distinct subspecies. ("The shoddy science behind developers' push to delist the California gnatcatcher," July 2)

McCormick invokes argument from authority in his defense of subspecies status for this charismatic bird. Apparently he knows of a "magic bullet" technique that will verify the subspecies where prior attempts using plumage, size and shape, mitochondrial DNA and nuclear DNA have all failed.

McCormack fails to mention the larger issue: the exploitation of the subspecies category for political, rather than scientific, purposes. We support environmentalists' wishes to preserve tracts of coastal-sage scrub, but they have alternatives to using shoddy taxonom.

Robert Zink, St. Paul, Minn.

George Barrowclough, New York

Zink is a professor of biology at the University of Minnesota; Barrowclough is the associate curator of ornithology at the American Museum of Natural History in New York.

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion 

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • We can't fight homelessness without providing homes

    To the editor: Without an adequate supply of affordable housing, we will not end homelessness in our city. ("L.A. spends $100 million a year on homelessness, city report finds," April 16)

  • Father Serra looms large in California's history

    To the editor: Without Father Junipero Serra, California has no history. I have just helped a grandchild work through the fourth grade, and I am more respectful of the accomplishments of Serra than ever before. ("Time to retire the Father Serra statue in Washington?," editorial, April 17)

  • GOP and Obamacare: what could have been

    To the editor: Early on in the healthcare debate, Republicans squandered a grand opportunity to take due credit for a major part of the Affordable Care Act: the individual mandate. ("Obamacare repeal falls off Republicans' to-do list as law takes hold," April 18)

  • Teachers should acknowledge problems with tenure

    To the editor: One letter writer, a teacher, said she's "really ticked off" that some people think tenure makes teachers lazy. ("Tenure isn't Easy Street for teachers," Readers React, April 17)

  • Make California's water hogs pay
    Make California's water hogs pay

    To the editor: I hope you received lots of outraged letters about the jaw-droppingly selfish customer who asked whom he should sue for the decrease in his property's value when his landscaping dies. Meanwhile, the Desert Water Agency general manager who serves this customer, David Luker, had the...

  • Turkey's sensitivity over the Armenian genocide

    To the editor: The genocide of the Armenians 100 years ago is a well-known historical catastrophe. ("On Armenian genocide, go ahead and offend Turkey," op-ed, April 15)