Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Kansas' experiment with business-friendly, supply-side tax policy

To the editor: I usually find Michael Hiltzik's columns interesting and balanced in their perspective. Given that, I was disappointed to read his "gotcha" piece about Kansas' tax cut. ("How Tea Party tax cuts are turning Kansas into a smoking ruin," July 10)

To say that the disappointing results Kansas had with cutting taxes and attracting new business is an indictment of supply-side concepts is a very narrow reading of the facts. There's no real debate about the fact that companies relocate because of corporate taxes.

If the political leaders in Kansas did something wrong, it was to assume they would be the only state trying this. In fact, its neighbor to the south, Texas, also instituted many business-friendly policies.

You might argue that Gov. Sam Brownback oversold the prospect of business relocation to Kansas, given the advantages that Texas has, but to say Kansas' experiment means tax-based, business-friendly policies don't work does not jive with all of the facts.

Jay Prag, Claremont

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Judith Miller did her job badly, sexism or not

    To the editor: The Judith Miller "no apologies" book tour is playing up sexism, apparently because her disinformation campaign against her critics has had little success so far, and blaming her faulty reporting before the Iraq war on her "sources." ("Judith Miller: Sexism hindered, and helped,...

  • The minimum wage's less-than-racist origins

    To the editor: Jonah Goldberg's analysis of who advocated for minimum wages, and why, is mind-boggling to say the least. ("Martin O'Malley's modern-day know-nothingness," op-ed, April 20)

  • Israeli responsibility for Palestinian misery

    To the editor: Tamar Sternthal from the pro-Israel media watchdog CAMERA says that Israel is not responsible for the suffering of the Palestinians at the Yarmouk refugee camp in Syria or for any Palestinian suffering. ("Don't blame Israel for Palestinian misery at Yarmouk," Readers React, April...

  • Numbers chaperoning words? Not to this poet

    To the editor: Stephen Marche's fanciful essay on the increase of numerical orientation in literature is both historically questionable and oddly limited to "verse" to make his case. ("The act of writing in the age of numbers," op-ed, April 18)

  • Want a lush lawn? Pay more for water, or move out of California
    Want a lush lawn? Pay more for water, or move out of California

    To the editor: I was very disappointed to read about the state appeals court decision invalidating San Juan Capistrano's tiered rate structure. As they tell us in Economics 101, incentives matter. ("Appeals court throws out San Juan Capistrano's tiered water-use rates," April 20)

  • Hospitals shouldn't keep infection outbreaks secret

    To the editor: It is outrageous that hospitals are not required to make public disclosures of infection outbreaks. ("A veil of secrecy shields hospitals where outbreaks occur," April 18)