Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Don't blame Israel for the path Gazans have taken

To the editor: It is a sad situation that the Palestinians and their sympathizers refuse to confront the underlying cause of their continued misery. ("Israel can't win this or any future conflicts by bombing Gaza," Op-Ed, July 15)

The Gaza Strip has the enviable position of being situated next to two large economies, those of Israel and Egypt. This geographic position, along with its beautiful Mediterranean coast, makes Gaza an ideal location for attracting industry, investment capital and tourism to turn it into a Hong Kong of the Middle East.

When Israel unilaterally disengaged in 2005 and handed Gaza over to the Palestinians, these people were given the opportunity of a lifetime: to build a great economy. Instead, shortly after Israel's disengagement, they chose Hamas to lead them. Rather than focusing almost exclusively on raising the standard of living of their people by pursuing economic cooperation and trade with Israel, Hamas chose to throw rockets at its perceived enemy.

Instead of the usual practice by Palestinians of blaming Israel, in this case for defending its citizens from the relentless rain of Hamas' rockets, Op-Ed article writer Ibrahim Sharqieh should point his finger at the choices that the Palestinians made and the hateful path of misery that they put themselves on.

Joseph Azizi, Beverly Hills


To the editor: Sharqieh misses the key point in the conflict in Gaza and how to end it.

He notes that the war will go on and on until Gazans have open borders and "dignity" in their lives. Fair enough. However, what he and his fellow apologists fail to mention is that Israel has demonstrated many times its interest in peaceful borders, but conditioned on recognition by Hamas and others of Israel's right to exist.

Egypt and Jordan figured it out years ago when they each signed peace treaties with Israel. But since the 1990s, the Arab extremists in the Middle East have consistently missed the opportunity to make peace. In the meantime, Israel has every right to defend itself.

Only when Hamas, Hezbollah and their "colleagues" stop perpetuating hate will the blood on both sides finally stop flowing.

Gary Wartik, Camarillo


To the editor: Our country's unshakable support for Israel should be reexamined as we witness a state with a powerful military force attacking a defenseless and imprisoned population in the Gaza Strip.

The rockets being fired from Gaza are largely ineffective contraptions that have produced one causality. They are being fired in desperation and despair by people whose economy and infrastructure have been destroyed by Israel, and who cannot lead normal lives.

No American would ever permit another country to treat us in the same manner as Israel treats the Palestinians.

Joseph Tillotson, Redondo Beach


To the editor: Sharqieh restates the obvious problems, known for decades, but he's very short on concrete solutions to the conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians. And by doing so, he doesn't contribute much; in fact, he doesn't move the ball an inch.

How the age-old dynamics can be changed is missing from the analysis, particularly when each battle digs the hole deeper.

But let's start with this: the group Hamas' long-overdue recognition of the state of Israel.

Anita C. Singer, Laguna Woods

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Israel can't win this or any future conflicts by bombing Gaza
    Israel can't win this or any future conflicts by bombing Gaza

    A popular colloquial definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. Israel launched military campaigns in 2008 and 2012, purportedly to eliminate Hamas' rocket-launching capabilities from the Gaza Strip. Obviously, the campaigns failed: Hamas...

  • Has the fuss over 'The Interview' been good for Sony's bottom line?
    Has the fuss over 'The Interview' been good for Sony's bottom line?

    To the editor: Though the digital release of "The Interview" simultaneously with its showing in theaters may be a game changer, the more important question to Sony Pictures is how the accompanying publicity will affect the bottom line. ("More a cause than a must-see, 'The Interview' finally...

  • Dissing the naugthy and praising the nice in 2014

    To the editor: I took heart in reading your Christmas editorial saluting those who have been nice and dissing the "naughty." I salute the unknown couple who drove around Detroit handing $100 bills of their own money to those whom they deemed needy. ("Who's been naughty and nice in 2014,"...

  • Easing Americans' debt burden wouldn't be painless

    To the editor: Nicole Gelinas rightly maligns the toxic influence of the megabanks on the American economy, but she shies away from the broader implications of her argument. What would a less leveraged America look like? ("The real reason for Washington's derivatives gift to banks," Op-Ed, Dec....

  • Why buy "cage-free" when you can go egg-free?

    To the editor: Thank you for reminding readers that California voters decisively backed Proposition 2 in 2008 in order to improve the lives of millions of hens. The key word here is "improve." ("California's egg-laying hens to get their breathing room," Editorial, Dec. 26)

  • Outrage over Roman Polanski's escape from justice

    To the editor: Roman Polanski's attorney Alan Dershowitz says that his client's "liberty interests and the integrity of the justice system are at stake." ("Roman Polanski loses bid for dismissal of sexual assault conviction," Dec. 24)

  • Fabian Nuñez's connections help his son but deny a grieving family justice
    Fabian Nuñez's connections help his son but deny a grieving family justice

    To the editor: This breathtaking story by Christopher Goffard reminds us of the limitless power and influence held by unscrupulous political people and weak, vicious boys with money, grudges and knives. Under the guise of candor and being a devoted parent, former state Assembly Speaker Fabian...

  • Atheism, agnosticism and belief: Thoughts on going with or without God
    Atheism, agnosticism and belief: Thoughts on going with or without God

    The Times' front-page article Monday on Ryan Bell, a former Seventh-day Adventist minister nearing the end of his "year without God," prompted dozens of readers to ruminate on religion, spirituality, atheism and agnosticism. The handful of letters published on Christmas Day — some...