Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Better than Kozinski's firing squads: Let the prisoners decide

To the editor: Have prisoners been asked what they think of the death penalty? I would not be surprised if a significant portion of those with very long sentences would prefer death to "suffering many levels of hell," as Alex Kozinski, chief judge of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, puts it. ("Judge Alex Kozinski on bringing back firing squads: No, I wasn't kidding," Op-Ed, July 30)

We should poll the entire prison population to find out how many would prefer death, who they are and which method would they prefer. And then we should respectfully permit them to die in the manner they choose. This would alleviate much unnecessary suffering as well as save money.

Unless, of course, making prisoners suffer the torments of hell is what the penal system is all about, despite our claims to the contrary

Chuck Almdale, North Hills


To the editor: Kozinski's response to the question of why most other Western countries have abolished the death penalty — that "most of these countries have in their recent past abused it," referring specifically to the horrific 20th Century histories of Germany and Romania — is either disingenuous or ignorant.

There are at least 98 countries (including virtually all of Western Europe) that have abolished the death penalty entirely and an additional 42 countries that have either abolished it in practice or retained it only for military crimes or extraordinary circumstances (and not for "ordinary" crimes like murder). Judge Kozinski defames most of these 140 countries collectively by his careless statement.

In any event, the U.S. modern history of both arbitrary and racially discriminatory imposition of the death penalty counts as abuse in my book. The Innocence Project counts at least 18 people exonerated through DNA who had served time on death row.

It is long past time for the U.S. to join most of the Western world in abolishing the death penalty.

Kay Virginia Webster, Agoura Hills

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Judge Alex Kozinski on bringing back firing squads: No, I wasn't kidding
    Judge Alex Kozinski on bringing back firing squads: No, I wasn't kidding

    Google "Alex Kozinski firing squad" and nearly 20,000 mentions turn up. But those are just a few words plucked from a detailed dissent by the chief judge of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, arguing, in essence, that Americans are hypocrites about the death penalty: We support it but don't...

  • Gov. Brown strikes a blow for climate science
    Gov. Brown strikes a blow for climate science

    To the editor: The reverberating power of one single state finally doing the right thing to address the most critical and urgent threat to humanity cannot be underestimated. Gov. Jerry Brown has thrown down the gauntlet, challenging other politicians of conscience to follow. Even Pope Francis will...

  • Extending Prop. 30 taxes wouldn't address systemic problems

    To the editor: George Skelton is right when he says California's current tax structure is too volatile and in desperate need of an overhaul. Extending temporary tax increases has become all too common in Sacramento, and it doesn't surprise me that some government officials would like to extend...

  • More female firefighters: Don't force it, Mayor Garcetti

    To the editor: Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti wants more of the city's firefighters to be women, a difficult goal made clear by the fact that the four women in this year's training class have been eliminated. ("Second straight LAFD recruit class is all male after women exit," April 29)

  • Chipotle made the right call on GMO food

    To the editor: The attack on Chipotle for making a business decision to remove genetically modified components from food they serve is questionable. ("Chipotle's junk science on GMOs," op-ed, April 29)

  • Having a green lawn is un-Californian

    To the editor: Thanks to The Times for its front-page article on ripping out laws. ("Amid drought, the West is no place for a lawn, as Nevada has learned," May 1)

  • Baltimore unrest: For these readers, issues of race and violence are personal
    Baltimore unrest: For these readers, issues of race and violence are personal

    Most of the letters sent to us on the uprising in Baltimore have come from readers far removed from the action who have spoken largely in abstractions, advocating principles rather than offering personal experience: Violence is unacceptable, policing needs to change, and racism in America must...

  • Do-it-yourself drought busting

    To the editor: Conspicuously missing from the analysis and advice provided by 10 water experts was a suggestion that all residents and businesses in California can together capture millions of gallons of what little rain falls by setting up collection systems on their properties. ("Shorter showers?...