Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Poorly trained 'assistant physicians' aren't the answer

To the editor: Can an untrained doctor deliver top-quality primary care after 30 days of supervision in an established practice? I had firsthand experience with partially trained internists while an Army physician during the Vietnam War. I saw some disastrous results. ("Not enough primary-care doctors? Try Missouri's prescription," Op-Ed, Aug. 7)

The idea of assistant physicians as health practitioners supervised by a physician miles away frightens me.

We have a shortage of primary-care physicians because they are burdened by an excess of technology (overreliance on tests, billing complexities and poorly designed electronic health records) and inadequate reimbursements. Much of this burden can be attributed to unwanted and unneeded government and insurer regulations.

As with our education system that is failing students, our healthcare system is failing physicians. Assistant physicians are not the answer.

Jerome P. Helman, MD, Venice


To the editor: As medical director of an inner-city community health center, I understand the difficulty of hiring qualified primary-care providers. However, Arthur L. Caplan's understanding of medical education is flawed.

Since medical students' clinical time is focused on hospital patients while primary care is an outpatient specialty, even the best graduating medical student is not ready for the complexity of primary-care patients with a mere 30 days' supervision.

The consequence of intervention without adequate education on the part of the medical provider has the strong possibility of leading to an outcome worse for the patient than if the intervention had not occurred.

If Caplan really believes that "fairly good primary care" is good enough, I urge him to transfer his own care to a Missouri assistant physician. If he's reluctant, perhaps it's because he remembers that, above all, a physician's duty is to "first, do no harm."

Deborah Lerner, MD, Los Angeles

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Not enough primary-care doctors? Try Missouri's prescription.
    Not enough primary-care doctors? Try Missouri's prescription.

    Everyone agrees that the United States does not have enough primary-care physicians. There are huge swaths of the nation, especially rural and inner-city areas, that lack any primary-care physicians. The Department of Health and Human Services estimates that the shortage is at least 16,000...

  • GOP's moderate women prevent an abortion disaster
    GOP's moderate women prevent an abortion disaster

    To the editor: What sweet irony. The GOP, in an attempt to alter the perception that it's waging a war on women, has symbolically included more women in its ranks. Who knew that these new House members would traitorously revolt and demonstrate respect for women by blocking an abortion bill that...

  • China's birthrate during the year of the sheep

    To the editor: Why is it a bad sign that China may be about to experience a decline in birth rate due to a superstition about babies being born in the year of the sheep? ("For China's birthrate, this may be a bad sign," Jan. 19)

  • Cuba has plenty of reasons to mistrust the U.S.

    To the editor: To say that U.S.-Cuba relations went south after the "confiscation of private property" egregiously overlooks the important fact that we sought to overthrow Fidel Castro's regime through a CIA-sponsored military operation in 1961. Remember the Bay of Pigs? ("U.S.-Cuba talks focus...

  • Electoral College widens America's partisan divide

    To the editor: Amen to George Skelton's criticisms of the Electoral College. I'll add another: The winner-takes-all aspect of the current system is why there aren't more purple states. ("Winner-take-all electoral system is a loser for democracy," Jan. 21)

  • Boko Haram's excuse: God made me do it

    To the editor: It seems this God fellow is responsible for a lot of killing around the world. ("Leader of Boko Haram says God told him to carry out massacre," Jan. 21)

  • College divestment campaigns may alienate alumni

    To the editor: One potential impact that I think this article overlooked is the loss of financial support from alumni like myself and scores of other donors. ("More colleges under pressure to divest, though effect is debatable," Jan. 21)

  • Did 'Selma' go too far in its portrayal of LBJ?
    Did 'Selma' go too far in its portrayal of LBJ?

    To the editor: Art represents transcendent truth and should not be held responsible for specific facts, a point that Rep. John Lewis makes in his piece on the movie "Selma." On the surface this is understood. The transcending truth of "Selma" is the heroic struggle of Martin Luther King Jr....