Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Better teachers, but how exactly?

To the editor: While L.A. Unified School District Supt. John Deasy celebrates expanded powers to fire teachers, Jack Schneider's Op-Ed article (“Firing teachers won't fix education” Opinion, June 12) lays out the real picture. Given that half of new teachers flee the field within the first five years, the notion that more punitive action will miraculously produce “effective teachers” is delusional.

Where campuses are so stripped of resources that students, teachers and principals make due in overcrowded conditions, should we be shocked that a child molester operates unnoticed for years? Are teachers blatantly devalued when, after seven years without a raise and significant income loss from furlough days, a paltry 2% is reluctantly offered two years after Proposition 30's new funding?

The refusal to invest in teachers, as opposed to driving them out, will sadly and certainly continue to erode the quality of our schools.

Wendy Blais, North Hills


To the editor: “Firing teachers won't fix education,” says the headline on the article by Jack Schneider, a professor of education at College of the Holly Cross.

“Firing teachers who are ineffective, not qualified and have little concern for their students, will fix education,” says Jack Buss the taxpayer.

Jack Buss, Banning


To the editor: Schneider is spot-on in his analysis of how to produce the best teachers.

The mistaken notion of removing tenure protections, seniority-based layoffs and teacher dismissal procedures is based on a narrative (promoted aggressively by advocates of privatized education) that the system is awash in bad teachers. This is dangerously false, and the popularly proposed remedies will make teachers worse, not better.

Schneider's proposals for evaluations based less on test scores, more collaboration, more professional development based on best practices, and more coaching and mentoring programs are the right solution. The foolish effort to “fire our way” into a better teacher corps will prove to be a disaster.

Carl K. Allender, Glendale


To the editor: Performance as the basis of job retention is standard practice in the business world. So it should be in public schools. The practice of tenure in public schools has taken precedent only in the absence of adequate performance reviews.

For 19 years of my 40-year career, I taught in a major Los Angeles-area school district. My performance review — and I am sure those of my colleagues — consisted of nothing more than an end-of-the-year checklist.

Too few administrators have a solid grasp of what exemplifies good teaching. In addition, administrators do not have the time to perform the multiple observations and conferences to produce a valid performance review.

Performance reviews can be effectively used only when administrators learn, practice and implement appropriate procedures.

Mark Stephen Mrotek, Carson

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Making it easier to fire teachers won't get you better ones
    Making it easier to fire teachers won't get you better ones

    Tuesday's ruling by Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu, which held that California's contract with teachers violates the state's constitutional guarantee to an equitable education, is certain to set off legal battles across the nation. Explaining his ruling, Treu wrote that inequities in teaching...

  • An irreverent debate on sainthood for Serra
    An irreverent debate on sainthood for Serra

    When Pope Francis announced two weeks ago that he expected to canonize Father Junipero Serra later this year, readers reacted by reflecting seriously on California's pre-Gold Rush history and Serra's controversial efforts to convert Indians to Catholicism as the founder of nine 18th century...

  • Overpopulation is killing the world's biodiversity

    To the editor: Your editorial highlights a critical issue that's frequently left out of the conversation: We can't effectively tackle climate change without looking at our runaway population growth and overconsumption. And it's not just the climate that's suffering from infinite growth on our...

  • Now the Republicans clamor for compromise?

    To the editor: When President Obama was first elected and Democrats also had control of Congress, Republicans were complimented for "standing on principle" when they opposed the economic stimulus and healthcare reform. Now that Republicans have control of Congress, Jonah Goldberg accuses...

  • Mormon Church still wants to discriminate against LGBT people

    To the editor: The Mormon Church offers to support adding "sexual orientation" to various non-discrimination laws. But rather than simply changing its policy or admitting that its prior opposition to gays was wrong, it requires a quid pro quo. ("Mormon Church tries to balance gay rights...

  • Don't dismiss the anti-abortion crowd as 'ideologues'

    To the editor: A letter writer suggests that distinguishing potential from actual persons makes an important point about abortion. Actually it contributes little or nothing. ("GOP's moderate women prevent an abortion disaster," Readers React, Jan. 24)

  • Obama hatred grows tedious

    To the editor: The Times prints a letter to the editor from a reader who finds equivalency between the rule of Islamic State and President Obama's action on the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.

  • Motorists shouldn't need Waze to drive safely
    Motorists shouldn't need Waze to drive safely

    To the editor: I find it very unsettling to read that the Waze traffic app is beloved by so many because "people may drive better if they know a police officer is around"; "most users drive more carefully when they believe law enforcement is nearby"; "it's a warning to slow down and avoid a...