Opinion Top of the Ticket

Twinkies' demise proves the stupidity of U.S. labor relations

The Great American Twinkie Crisis illuminates what is wrong with the relationship between management and labor in this country. Hostess, the company that since the 1930s has provided our nation with snacks that are nearly indestructible, now threatens to go out of business and leave us bereft of Ding Dongs, Sno Balls, Ho Ho’s, CupCakes, Wonder Bread and a variety of other baked goods that are probably not good for us but, at least to a kid’s palate, taste so good.

The company blames a nationwide strike by the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers International Union for the imminent death of its brand. In response, the workers say management has failed to innovate -- the company's products have not changed in decades or adapted to new tastes and new concerns about nutrition and so have failed to keep pace with the market.

A bankruptcy judge briefly kept hope alive for fans of the sugary guilty pleasures by urging the bakers and the bosses to try to work out a resolution through private mediation that might have kept the Twinkies rolling out of the ovens (or wherever they come from). Sadly, the latest reports are that the mediation broke down and that the company will proceed with liquidation. That means 18,500 people will lose their jobs.

PHOTOS: Top of the Ticket cartoons

Two questions come to mind. First, did the workers understand how close to ruin the company was when they decided to go on strike? Second, did the owners bother to listen to employees' concerns about improving the product line or did they just let the brand drift into financial crisis?

And here's a third question: When will employers and workers stop acting like adversaries and learn that they are on the same side?

I am reminded of a newspaper strike I was drawn into back in 2000. Two newspapers were involved. At mine, there were really no serious issues that could not be worked out, but, because the two newspapers negotiated together, we got drafted into the picket lines along with everyone else. The newspaper industry was already starting to falter back then, so, in retrospect, the strike was even more self-destructive than it seemed at the time. But stubbornness prevailed on both sides and the strike dragged on for weeks.

Ultimately, a settlement was reached, but, within a few years, my newspaper had stopped print publication and the other one struggles on with very uncertain prospects. The strike did not cause the troubles, but it certainly did not help. The modest gains that were made were ephemeral. 

I am not at all anti-union. In fact, I believe the fading of labor power has contributed to the stagnation of middle-class incomes over the last 30 years. Far too many American workers now stand alone, forced to accept pay cuts, longer hours, reduced benefits and arrogant disregard from their employers. But strikes are a blunt instrument, a club used to hammer insensitive bosses until they cry uncle. In the 21st century, it seems as though there should be a better way. 

How about this? In any larger company, give employees as big a voice as investors. Give them a place at the table -- the table in the boardroom. Do not treat them as faceless cogs in a machine, treat them as what they are: the essential people who make the product or provide the service and who have good ideas of their own. Spread the rewards of success beyond the CEOs and stockholders. Workers should not have to strike to be given a fair share of company profits; they should have a real stake and a real voice in the success or failure of a company.

I will bet there was a way for Hostess to organize itself that would have brought employees into the process of saving the company. Instead, management and labor went to war and everyone lost.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 'Obama gifts' comment shows Romney is clueless about the real USA
    'Obama gifts' comment shows Romney is clueless about the real USA

    In a postmortem of his campaign, Mitt Romney blamed his loss on President Obama’s "gifts" to key voting groups, thereby demonstrating, one last time, how he does not understand the country he hoped to lead. Meanwhile, Paul Ryan's poor showing in his own hometown indicates how out of touch...

  • Titillation of Petraeus affair comes at a high cost for America
    Titillation of Petraeus affair comes at a high cost for America

    Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower was lucky there was no such thing as email during the Second World War. His romantic relationship with his lovely Irish driver, Kay Summersby, did not come to light for decades and did not keep him from leading the D-Day Invasion, becoming the first supreme commander...

  • The era known as 'the Sixties' really began in 1965
    The era known as 'the Sixties' really began in 1965

    Fifty years ago Thursday, President Lyndon B. Johnson turned on the lights of the National Christmas Tree and proclaimed, “These are the most hopeful times in all the years since Christ was born in Bethlehem.” He continued, “Today — as never before — man has in his...

  • Here's how to determine if that charity is worth your dollars
    Here's how to determine if that charity is worth your dollars

    When my sister and I were children and flew to summer camp together, our mother always asked us to call her once we arrived to let her know we landed safely. When we got older, my sister and I put our own twist on this practice: If my sister was giving me a lift to the airport, she had to...

  • Now more than ever, the issue of campus rape requires critical thinking
    Now more than ever, the issue of campus rape requires critical thinking

    Remember in 1986, when Newsweek supposedly showed that a 40-year-old single woman was “more likely to be killed by a terrorist” than to ever get married? It turned out to be false, the remark of a Newsweek correspondent, who'd meant it merely as a funny aside. And the studies on...

  • Have a full and open debate on rules for LAPD body cameras
    Have a full and open debate on rules for LAPD body cameras

    The Los Angeles Police Department has committed to outfitting all officers on patrol with body cameras starting next year. The effort was launched last year by Police Commission President Steve Soboroff, but it gained momentum after deadly encounters between police and unarmed black men in...

Comments
Loading