Skip to content
Crowe in command on British warship
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World" is extremely long, meticulous and quite possibly great.
Director Peter Weir's epic throws you smack on the deck of a British warship in the middle of the ocean in 1805, capturing with ecstatic detail exactly what such an experience might have been like. From the very young boys living a life that should surely belong only to men, to the basic horror of brain surgery performed with a spoon, Weir (Witness) creates a world that is at once spectacular and unfailingly believable.
Whether you also find it punishingly dull at times depends on your tastes. "Master and Commander," adapted by Weir and co-writer John Collee from Patrick O'Brian's historical novels, has a considerable built-in audience eager to see how well their beloved books translate to the screen. But if your idea of a good time isn't watching a bunch of snappily attired men shout importantly on the deck of a ship as waves crash all around them, or you're troubled by a movie that features not a single notable female character, save the ones outfitted with sails and hulls, this likely is not for you.
On the other hand, we can all probably agree on the supreme being that is Russell Crowe, who even slightly plumped up here is still pulsing with mischievous, commanding charm. As "Lucky" Jack Aubrey, captain of the HMS Surprise, Crowe plays a sea captain filled with ambitious pride. He is desperate to pursue and overtake the superior French ship that attacks his own in the opening sequence, while torn between obligation to the nearly 200 men (and boys) under his stewardship. In breathing life into this role, it doesn't hurt that Crowe is one of the few actors alive who can make a ruffled shirt look like a perfectly masculine garment.
Aubrey's friendship with the ship's doctor, Stephen Maturin (Paul Bettany, Crowe's "A Beautiful Mind" co-star), is what prevents Master and Commander from being nothing more than a staggering series of very special effects.
Their complex rapport is like a decidedly less homoerotic version of what George Clooney and Mark Wahlberg shared in "A Perfect Storm." Also unlike the obvious and distracting visual effects of that film, Master and Commander is jam-packed with computer-generated images that actually look real.
The joy "Master and Commander" lies both in its roaring action and its emotional intricacies, a rare and great thing indeed for such a big-budget work. And when those not predisposed to its genre can't quite figure out what is going on during all the thunderous, epic battling, there is always the divine pleasure of Crowe and Bettany to lure you back into the story.