Faced with a deciding seventh game of the World Series, he had his 23-game winner, a former Cy Young Award recipient, primed and ready with three days' rest.
But the manager, Walter Alston, figured he had a better option. And so too did the 23-game winner himself, Don Drysdale
On the eve of the last game of the 1965 World Series, Drysdale and catcher John Roseboro pulled Alston aside to tell him, "You've got to pitch the left-hander."
That would be Sandy Koufax.
"Drysdale was willing to give up Game 7 for the benefit of the team," recalled Jeff Torborg, the team's backup catcher at the time, from his Florida home. "Don said he would go to the bullpen and be available. That showed me what a team leader he was. These guys normally never asked out of the rotation. You couldn't peel them off the mound."
Drysdale wasn't needed that day. Koufax, on two days' rest with an aching left elbow that ultimately would end his career a year hence at age 30, would pitch a three-hit shutout in a 2-0 victory over the Minnesota Twins, striking out 10.
Koufax and Drysdale, two future Hall of Fame members, were a pair of aces who gave Alston a lot of winning hands.
"We were very fortunate to have two giants of the game on the same team," Torborg said. "They had different styles and different personalities, but they were both unbelievable."
Koufax was a comet, streaking across the major league landscape, a burst of brilliance too quickly extinguished.
Don't look for his name in a significant spot on the list of career pitching leaders. Plagued by wildness early in his career and by arthritis at the end, Koufax wasn't around long. But over a five-season span beginning in 1962, he may have been the best to plant cleats on a major league mound.
Koufax led the league in earned-run average in each of those seasons. Over the last four, he had records of 25-5, 19-5, 26-8 and 27-9, struck out more than 300 batters in three of the last four seasons with a high of 382, had an ERA under 2.00 in three of those seasons, won three Cy Youngs and a most valuable player award, and led the Dodgers to two World Series championships. Koufax also pitched no-hitters in four consecutive years, including a perfect game in 1965.
He had a rising fastball that often left hitters flailing like 5-year-olds in a tee-ball game, and a curve that dropped as if it were falling off a shelf.
Toward the end, however, the strain on Koufax's arm was so bad, "it would swell to three or four times its normal size after a game, leaving Sandy unable to even bend it," Torborg said.
Despite that, Koufax refused to come out of games early, even if the Dodgers were comfortably ahead. In those final four seasons, he had 89 complete games, including 27 in each of his last two years, numbers hard to fathom in this era of pitch counts when a quality start means six innings.
Koufax retired with a 165-87 record and a 2.76 ERA.
While the left-hander spun his magic by overwhelming hitters, Drysdale, a right-hander, mixed in the element of intimidation. He stood 6 feet 6 with a menacing glare for any hitter who dared to invade his space, which, in Drysdale's mind, was the inside part of the plate.
"Sooner or later, you have to say it's my ball and half the plate is mine. Only I never let on which half of the plate I wanted," Drysdale said in his autobiography, "Once a Bum, Always a Dodger."