Advertisement

A new NFL season means a new game of quarterback musical chairs

Robert Griffin III will be the Browns' fifth starting quarterback in the team's last six NFL season openers.
(David Richard / Associated Press)
Share

After the “Monday Night Football” theme music stops on Sept. 12, the NFL’s latest game of quarterback musical chairs will be complete.

The Rams will trot out Case Keenum, who backed up Nick Foles at the start of last season and is now a placeholder for No. 1 pick Jared Goff. The 49ers will go with Blaine Gabbert over Colin Kaepernick, though either option could provide more headaches than upside.

The game will be a microcosm of today’s NFL, where quarterback stability is badly needed but seldom found. Nine teams could start a different quarterback in Week 1 than they did in the 2015 opener. Twelve teams did so at the start of last season.

Advertisement

Just 12 of the league’s 32 franchises — including six of the last nine Super Bowl winners — have started the same quarterback in the last five openers.

When the Browns roll out Robert Griffin III against the Eagles in Week 1, they’ll have had five different quarterbacks start the last six seasons. The Browns hope Griffin breathes life into an offense that ranked 30th in yards per game last year, and hasn’t had a steady quarterback situation since Bill Clinton took office.

“What’s always the answer to everything when somebody’s not happy with their football team?” said Phil Simms, a Super Bowl-winning quarterback with the Giants and now a CBS commentator. “You either change the coach or you change the quarterback. That’s what you’re going to do to change the culture.”

The reasons for this season’s quarterback turnover are wide-ranging: injuries, not-quite-ready rookies and something called “Deflategate.”

In New England, Tom Brady will begin serving his four-game suspension for deflating footballs, which puts Jimmy Garoppolo in a shaky spotlight.

Longtime Cowboys signal caller Tony Romo has a broken bone in his back, lining up fourth-round pick Dak Prescott for a Week 1 start.

Advertisement

Vikings quarterback Teddy Bridgewater suffered a dislocated knee and torn ACL on Tuesday, which led to a trade for Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Sam Bradford. That also means the Eagles will trot out a new starter, either Chase Daniel or Carson Wentz, the second pick of the draft. Wentz only played in the first preseason game and suffered a fractured rib.

If Wentz does not start, then all three quarterbacks drafted in the first round — Goff, Wentz and the Broncos’ Paxton Lynch — will begin their careers as backups. .

By sitting Goff, the Rams will snap a trend of No. 1 picks starting right away. The last five quarterbacks selected first overall — Matthew Stafford, Bradford, Cam Newton, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston — all played in Week 1. But all of those teams were coming off seasons of two wins or worse, while the Rams went 7-9 in 2015 and are not hitting the restart button.

After the Rams fell to the Vikings in their preseason finale Thursday, Jeff Fisher didn’t only solidify Keenum as his starter but also said Sean Mannion, a second-year quarterback from Oregon State, will back up Keenum.

“We saw last year the two coaches that started rookie quarterbacks; you think there are growing pains with that, but those coaches got fired,” said Bill Cowher, the former Steelers head coach and now a CBS commentator, referring to Tampa Bay’s Lovie Smith starting Winston and Tennessee’s Ken Whisenhunt starting Marcus Mariota. “I think when you look at it right now there’s a lot of pressure to win.”

Advertisement

After starting seven games for the Super Bowl champion Denver Broncos last season, Brock Osweiler will experience the pressure of being “the man” with the Houston Texans.

“Look, there are so many different head coaches every year and different coordinators, you might as well have new quarterbacks,” said Jon Gruden, who will be in the “Monday Night Football” booth when the 49ers and Rams square off. “It’s an incredible league right now the way that it churns out new talent at quarterback, offensive coordinator and head coach. You don’t get very long to establish yourself.”

Or before you’re replaced.

ALSO

What we learned from the Rams’ 27-25 exhibition loss to the Minnesota Vikings

Patriots’ Rob Ninkovich suspended four games by NFL because of PED use

Colin Kaepernick kneels during national anthem while former Green Beret Nate Boyer stands beside him

Advertisement
Advertisement