It's his second home, in a midrise condominium complex filled with people like him--Baby Boomers in homes-away-from-home. Normally, Laginess lives in Chicago, where he works as a vice president for Juno Lighting Group. At age 55, Laginess divides his time between two homes--enjoying golf, sun and mountains in Palm Springs and a paycheck and friends in Chicago.
- Second thoughts on boomers' second homes
- Seasonal jobs help with holiday expenses
- Investors' gains have a likely downside at year-end
- Protectionism in congress may spark inflation pressures
- Togetherness cracks when it comes to the nest egg
- The savings game
- The Leckey file
- Getting started
- Spending smart
- Can they do that?
- Taking stock
- Competition putting squeeze on more investment fees
- On TV
- The week ahead
But Gary Engelhardt, a Syracuse University economics professor, says the notion of these waves of buyers is largely a myth. And he warns people to beware of investing based on hype that seems questionable.
In research done in conjunction with the Mortgage Bankers Association and the Radian Group credit risk management company, Engelhardt found that only a small proportion of older Americans have second residences, and there is no greater tendency by Baby Boomers than the previous generation to indulge in second homes. And there is actually more movement between suburbs by empty-nesters than into urban playgrounds.
Only a tiny fraction of suburban empty-nesters are moving to the city, Engelhardt said.
"Suburbanites like the suburbs," he said.
Engelhardt scoured government data from the 2004 Health and Retirement Study, the 2005 Current Population Survey and 2000 Census to measure mobility by early Baby Boomers--people born between 1946 and 1955. The surveys do not yet capture activities by younger Boomers, so Engelhardt can't be sure what they will do.
But other research shows younger Boomers, and the Generation X group behind them, may be more financially stressed than today's fiftysomethings as they prepare for retirement living. In particular, the growing tendency of employers to stop providing traditional pensions--with guaranteed monthly payments--is expected to weigh heavily on future retirees. Expected cuts in Social Security and Medicare could add pressure.
So Engelhardt said people now in their 40s may end up with less ability to treat themselves to second homes than people nearing retirement or already in it.
What he knows is that the data debunk the perception that recent empty-nesters are shunning the suburbs and indulging in second homes.
Engelhardt found that roughly 80 percent of the moves suburbanites made in their 50s were to a home in another suburb. Only 11 percent moved into central cities. Meanwhile, just over 52 percent of city dwellers who moved went out to the suburbs.
New condo developments in cities have major competition from suburban retirement housing, he said. "These are different retirement communities. There is no boccie ball or bingo. Instead people are attracted by golf courses, green spaces and wooded areas."
Rather than empty-nesters flocking to urban areas, the movement into the city "is not even strong enough to stem the flow out of the cities," Engelhardt said.
Movement into the nation's 10 largest metropolitan areas--Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, Detroit, Houston, Los Angeles, New York, Orange County, Calif., Philadelphia and Phoenix--has been stronger than in smaller cities, he said. But even in the stronger environment "this is not very good news for real estate developers putting up condo projects, or individuals buying condos in anticipation of substantial capital gains."
Based on supply and demand, Engelhardt suggests that investors who are discouraged by softening prices now may not encounter markedly better conditions later.
Mark Nash, a Chicago real estate broker and author of "1,001 Tips for Buying or Selling a Home," said he has been trying to prepare people for a slower market. He is encouraging them to think of a condo in the city, or a second home, as a place to enjoy, not an investment.
Still, he has difficulty connecting Engelhardt's findings to his own experiences with empty-nesters. He says they frequently comment: "We don't want the two-story colonial in the suburbs. We want to walk to work downtown and be close to restaurants, the opera, Cubs and Bear games."
Karl Case, a real estate economics professor at Wellesley College, said he hears the same thing in the Boston area.