Where am I?: View from Bedloe's Island

A great North American city lies across the water. We're looking at it from a former smallpox quarantine station that was known, for much of the 20th century, as Bedloe's Island. So is this:


1. Where am I?
A. Chicago, seen from Beaver Island, Ill.
B. Manhattan, seen from Liberty Island, New York.
C. San Francisco, seen from Angel Island, California.
D. Vancouver, seen from Vancouver Island, British Columbia.