Tap to enable a layout that focuses on the article.
Advertisement

Why I’m not taking down my César Chávez photo

César Chávez mural at Santa Ana College
Daniella Marcial, right, a first-year accounting major, studies as maintenance workers cover a mural honoring César Chávez in the César Chávez Cove at the César Chávez Business and Computer Center at Santa Ana College in Santa Ana.
(Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times)
0:00 0:00

This is read by an automated voice. Please report any issues or inconsistencies here.

See more from the L.A. Times in Google Search. Set us as preferred

The framed photo of César Chávez and Dolores Huerta sits in my personal office on a bookshelf crammed with volumes about California and the American West.

The two are at a 1973 United Farm Workers convention, presiding over the union they co-founded. After years of victories in the name of campesinos, the group and its charismatic leaders seem ready for what’s next.

A UFW banner emblazoned with the group’s famous black Aztec eagle logo hangs in the center of the picture, making Chávez and Huerta look like equals.

Advertisement

But they’re not.

He’s speaking from a podium, looking down and appearing cast in darkness due to Chávez blue vest melding into his black hair and brown skin. She’s by his side clasping her hands, wearing a colorful blouse that pales in radiance to Huerta’s hopeful face as she looks at the crowd before them.

It’s the only picture of historical figures that I display at home, and it’s in a place where I’m guaranteed to look at it. It has long served as my secular version of a prayer card, a daily reminder to fight for the good in the world and a reminder that giants before me faced challenges far more daunting than mine. It was also a testament to teamwork — when I acquired the photo a few years ago, it called to me in a way a solo Chávez never would have because I always knew el movimento was more than just one man.

Their portrait can never mean just those things ever again after the New York Times reported last week Chávez sexually assaulted two teenage girls in the 1970s and Huerta in the 1960s.

Advertisement

Your morning catch-up: An outcry to erase Cesar Chavez’s name, year-round mosquitoes in L.A. and more big stories

Places left and right — colleges, cities, classrooms, even states that mark Chávez’s birthday as a holiday — are now deleting his name and image from the public sphere. It’s not going to be a quick, easy task even if the cancellation is starting to take place with startling speed: Chávez’s presence is as ubiquitous in Mexican American life as the Virgin of Guadalupe.

Just this weekend, a friend acknowledged that he and his wife had just started reading a book about him to their 5-year-old daughter, a book they now plan to trash.

I thought of doing the same to my photo of Chávez and Huerta. But I’ve decided not to.

I don’t fault folks for wanting to scrub any hint of Chávez from their daily lives and neither does the Cesar Chavez Foundation, the nonprofit headed by his descendants that recently announced in a statement, “We support and respect whatever decision[s]” may come in the weeks and months to come. Communities are entitled to decide whom they should and shouldn’t publicly honor.

But to eradicate Chávez’s civic presence so fast — to tear down his statues, relabel streets and parks named in his honor, paint over his image on old and new murals, to throw away artwork that has adorned homes and offices for decades — doesn’t remove the fact that millions largely saw him as a champion of the downtrodden until last week. It can’t rescind the positive influence Chávez had on generations of Latinos and non-Latinos who saw in him the hopes of a people and now must reconcile their memories with his horrible deeds.

Historians, educators, activists and politicians for far too long elevated Chávez above Huerta in the name of a simplistic narrative that should’ve never been constructed. The public at large bought into those efforts with little skepticism in the understandable desire to have Latinos star in the American story. It’s a culpability we should all interrogate, not immediately purge.

That’s why not only am I keeping up my photo of Chávez and Huerta, I’m going to put it in a more prominent place from where I can’t look away.

Advertisement
The statue at Cesar E. Chavez Memorial Park in San Fernando is being covered.
Workers for the city of San Fernando cover the statue at Cesar E. Chavez Memorial Park on Thursday.
(Kayla Bartkowski / Los Angeles Times)

It will serve as a memory of a tragic, tremendous moment in the history of Latinos in the United States, where we should be focusing our attention on a presidential administration that wants most of us gone but instead must deal with the fallout from the downfall of one of our own. It will challenge me anew to look past the big names of the past and highlight those whose stories aren’t nearly as known by the mainstream.

Seeing Huerta next to her abuser will forever remind me about how the now-95-year-old sacrificed her own mental health and safety in the name of something bigger than the two of them — a choice no one should ever have to make but one that she nevertheless did.

The photo will stand as the manifestation of the old newspaper adage that if your mom tells you she loves you, go check it out. No one should ever be above skepticism no matter how sanctified and righteous they may seem — that’s why the New York Times investigation crashed into the Chicano collective sense of self like a meteor. No one could’ve imagined that Chávez could’ve possibly done things so monstrous, but maybe we shouldn’t have built him up so much while he was alive and after his death in the first place.

My framed Chávez-Huerta memento will make me think of how the stories of sexual abuse survivors are still not heard enough or even believed. Even now, some Chávez defenders are casting doubt on the claims of Huerta and the three other women named in the New York Times story, questioning their motivations to come forward after decades of silence and decrying how their decision to do so has permanently tarnished the reputation of one the few nationally known Chicano heroes. In Huerta’s case, critics just don’t buy how someone who carried Chávez’s torch decades after his death could all of a sudden supposedly turn on him.

L.A. Board of Education, which had just approved a pro-Chávez resolution, is likely to reverse course Tuesday, to honor the broader farmworkers’ movement and show support for assault survivors.

But as a Catholic who has long covered the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal, I know that every sexual assault survivor has their own journey of recovery. I also know that we must always seek the truth instead of living a lie.

Advertisement

And turning Chávez into a historical footnote is a lie. He long served as a moral exemplar; he should now serve as a cautionary tale known to all.

Erasing historic figures from the public sphere is an exercise in power going back to the pharaohs, a way rulers ensured future generations couldn’t learn about their enemies. The push to nix Chávez comes from the trend in recent years by progressive activists to remove monuments that hail problematic figures under the pretense that someone’s sins trump any good they might have done no matter how influential they were.

Again, all communities have that right to reexamine the past. But we can’t and shouldn’t disappear the full story of Chávez, as painful as it is. It’s the easy way out — and remedying wrongs is never easy.

If the photo in my book shelf was only of Chávez, I’d still keep it up. The good he did was really good — the bad he committed was as terrible as it gets.

Somewhere in between stands the story of us.

Insights

L.A. Times Insights delivers AI-generated analysis on Voices content to offer all points of view. Insights does not appear on any news articles.

Viewpoint
This article generally aligns with a Center point of view. Learn more about this AI-generated analysis

Perspectives

The following AI-generated content is powered by Perplexity. The Los Angeles Times editorial staff does not create or edit the content.

Ideas expressed in the piece

  • The author is choosing to keep the framed photograph of César Chávez and Dolores Huerta in a more prominent place rather than remove it, despite recent allegations that Chávez sexually assaulted Huerta and two teenage girls. The decision reflects a belief that hastily erasing Chávez from public life oversimplifies a complex historical moment and prevents society from grappling with difficult truths. The author argues that while Chávez committed terrible acts, the good he accomplished for farmworkers was genuinely significant and cannot be rescinded by his misconduct. This perspective holds that displaying the photo serves multiple purposes: it honors Huerta’s sacrifice and leadership, which were overshadowed by public elevation of Chávez above his co-founder; it challenges viewers to recognize that historical figures deserve scrutiny rather than sanctification; and it reminds people that the farmworker movement’s achievements belong to thousands of people, not one individual. The author contends that the rapid removal of Chávez’s name, images and statues from public spaces represents an “easy way out” that mirrors historical erasure tactics used by authoritarian rulers and prevents future generations from learning important lessons. According to the author, keeping the photo also acknowledges that sexual assault survivors like Huerta have complex journeys of recovery and that their delayed disclosure should not delegitimize their experiences.

Different views on the topic

  • Communities and institutions across the country are taking swift action to remove Chávez’s presence from public spaces, with colleges, cities, classrooms and states canceling celebrations, taking down statues, renaming streets and parks, and removing his image from murals[1][2]. The Cesar Chavez Foundation, headed by Chávez’s descendants, has stated that it “supports and respects whatever decision[s]” communities make regarding how to honor or distance themselves from Chávez[1]. Some Chávez defenders are questioning the credibility of the allegations, expressing skepticism about why Huerta and other women waited decades before coming forward and suggesting their motivations for disclosure are suspect[1]. These critics argue that the decision to publicize these allegations has unfairly tarnished the reputation of one of the few nationally recognized Chicano leaders[1]. The rationale behind removing Chávez’s public commemoration reflects a broader progressive movement to reassess monuments and public honors for figures whose personal conduct contradicts the values they publicly championed[1]. This perspective prioritizes protecting communities from daily reminders of individuals who committed severe misconduct, with some people choosing to discard books, artwork and other items featuring Chávez rather than preserve them[1].

Sign up for Essential California

The most important California stories and recommendations in your inbox every morning.

Advertisement
Advertisement