-
Click here to listen to this article - Share via
See more from the L.A. Times in Google Search. Set us as preferred
When I laid out an initial set of best picture Oscar power rankings, the “You Can See Everything” memes were flying. But the documentary hadn’t yet opened in theaters and no one had yet shown up on my doorstep on Halloween dressed as Elizabeth Holmes, wide-eyed and unblinking, asking for candy. After emptying my bowl, I turned off the porch light. I didn’t sleep particularly well that night.
“You Can See Everything” has scared up a staggering box office both here and abroad and is poised to become the first documentary to earn an Oscar nomination for best picture. Can it go the distance and actually win? Crazy talk, you say. Why would I deceive you? There’s no reason for me to do that.
Falling out of the rankings since Oct. 12: “Tender Loving Care,” “Club Kid”
10. ‘I Play Rocky’ (unranked)
Hollywood loves to celebrate its own scrappy mythmaking. And underdog stories don’t get any scrappier than the making of the 1977 best picture winner, “Rocky.” The title comes from Sylvester Stallone’s repeated insistence that he portray the working-class fighter in the film that he wrote for himself. The studio wanted a star — Ryan O’Neal or Burt Reynolds, among others — and offered Stallone $360,000 for the script if he would just walk away. Stallone refused, and the rest is history. Peter Farrelly’s endearing crowd-pleaser rehashes familiar ground, coasting down memory lane, trading on our love for “Rocky,” the movie and the character. But all that good, plus Anthony Ippolito’s charming lead turn, could be enough to jab voters into submission.
9. ‘All of a Sudden’ (8)
This 196-minute movie unfolds at, let’s just say, a leisurely pace, and includes a near-20-minute scene in which a character lays out the flaws of late-stage capitalism using a whiteboard. And it’s riveting. Or at least engaging. It’s certainly audacious, this drama about a hardworking director of a Parisian nursing home and the way a chance friendship changes her life. The Oscars’ best picture field now routinely includes two international movies, and Ryûsuke Hamaguchi’s dreamlike meditation on mortality and human connection feels like a sure bet to make the cut. Virginie Efira and Tao Okamoto shared the best actress prize at Cannes and merit attention from Oscar voters as well.
8. ‘The Debut’ (7)
Spoiler alert: One awards-season shoo-in is Julianne Moore winning every lead actress prize for her bravura work in this delightful Jesse Eisenberg comedy. Moore plays Mona, a meek, thoroughly unseen wife and mother who impulsively decides to audition for a community theater musical despite having no experience. The movie earned a huge response at its Telluride premiere, though there were some quibbles about the surprising, surreal turns the story takes. C’mon. Isn’t that precisely what we want from a film? With Moore, co-star Paul Giamatti, Eisenberg’s screenplay and original song (Eisenberg wrote several numbers for the film’s fictional musical) assured spots, a best picture nod feels undeniable.
7. ‘The Invite’ (6)
Olivia Wilde’s dinner-party dramedy boasts a killer quartet — Wilde and Seth Rogen as longtime marrieds nursing resentments, Penélope Cruz and Edward Norton playing their upstairs neighbors — and expert direction from Wilde, who navigates the movie’s tonal shifts with authority. It’s wickedly funny and unsentimental and pulls off a bittersweet ending that’s ambiguous enough to keep you talking long after the film ends. One of the year’s most satisfying pleasures.
6. ‘Project Hail Mary’ (5)
Speaking of endings, how many did “Project Hail Mary” have? Two? Three? I lost count. And it doesn’t matter. This was the upbeat end-of-the-world movie that audiences needed at a time when the possibility of human extinction feels uncomfortably real. In a year full of Spielberg knockoffs (and an uneven movie from the man himself), this will be the one left standing.
5. ‘Wild Horse Nine’ (4)
Martin McDonagh’s melancholy irreverence plays well with Oscar voters. His last two movies, “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri” and “The Banshees of Inisherin,” earned best picture nominations and a combined 16 nods. “Wild Horse Nine,” a biting buddy dramedy about two mismatched CIA assassins (John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell), should continue the filmmaker’s success and may even catapult Malkovich to a long-overdue Oscar. At the very least, it gave him his best role in decades.
4. ‘Dune: Part Three’ (2)
Can Denis Villeneuve’s third and final “Dune” movie, which hasn’t screened widely for press, take the “Lord of the Rings” trilogy path to a best picture victory? If there’s resistance to giving Christopher Nolan back-to-back best picture winners, one possible threat might come from a movie occupying the same lane, an auteur-driven epic lauded by critics and embraced by audiences. The second (and superior) “Dune” won just two Oscars, compared to the six taken by 2021’s “Dune: Part One.” Perhaps voters were playing the long game, though the movie’s late release date (Dec. 18) doesn’t offer much of a ramp for takeoff.
3. ‘La Bola Negra’ (3)
The filmmakers, Javier Calvo and Javier Ambrossi, are talented and charismatic, former romantic partners who still work together because that’s how Europeans roll. Los Javis (they even have a fun nickname) won the directing prize at Cannes, the first of several festivals that their movie conquered, culminating in that audience award at Toronto. With its three interconnected stories that follow queer men through nearly a century of Spanish history, “La Bola Negra” has an epic feel and emotional payoff that could carry it far. Netflix is all in, giving it an exclusive 46-day theatrical window, the longest it has afforded any movie. It’s a huge hit in Spain and has done well in its platform release here. We’ll see if that helps put it into the cultural conversation in a way that has eluded other Netflix contenders.
2. ‘You Can See Everything’ (unranked)
Maybe I’m intoxicated by the buzz surrounding this movie, which has not abated a month into its release. The boundary-breaking chronicle of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes’ fall from grace, co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, might end up netting just two Oscar nominations, picture and documentary. And even the latter isn’t assured, since some documentary branch voters recoil at any doc using reenactments.
But here’s a more likely scenario: One (or all?) of the major critics groups — Los Angeles, New York and the National Society — give a certain someone (still not spoiling this!) supporting actress honors, propelling her to an Oscar nomination. Film editors recognize the seamless storytelling in this 174-minute movie. And despite not being eligible for Directors Guild honors, Fielder and Oppenheim net a spot among the Oscar nominees. It’s a long road to the Oscars and the backlash is bound to hit sometime. But “You Can See Everything” speaks to our current times in a way that offers voters a clear alternative to the movie that has been the presumed winner since July.
1. ‘The Odyssey’ (1)
Maybe you saw it when it was in theaters, contributing to its $1.75-billion box office. Maybe you’re still trying to see it in Imax 70mm, the way God (i.e., Christopher Nolan) intended. Maybe you agree with translator Emily Wilson, who thinks Nolan’s movie “lacks psychological, emotional, political and ethical depth” and that its writing is “abysmal.” Whichever side you’re on, “The Odyssey” is going to sweep through the Oscar nominations, owing to its craft and thrilling showmanship, its stellar acting and that moment when Odysseus’ dog recognizes his long-absent master and wags his tail before heading off to Elysian Fields. It’s still the solid front-runner.