Jake Gyllenhaal, Jennifer Lawrence tie for No. 1 on soft weekend

Despite the arrival of four new films in theaters this weekend, moviegoers weren’t interested in heading to the box office.

For the fourth consecutive weekend, ticket sales were down compared with the same period in 2011, as none of the fresh arrivals at the cinema was able to top $15 million. Two spots tied for No. 1: the Jake Gyllenhaal cop drama “End of Watch” and the Jennifer Lawrence horror vehicle “House at the End of the Street,” which each raked in a decent $13 million a piece. Meanwhile, Clint Eastwood’s new baseball drama, “Trouble With the Curve,” didn’t hit a home run with audiences, as the film collected a so-so $12.7 million.

The big weekend loser, however, was “Dredd 3D,” the science-fiction action film based on a British comic strip that was only able to muster up $6.3 million in sales. The film barely performed better than “The Master,” Paul Thomas Anderson’s drama that played this weekend in only 788 theaters, while “Dredd” screened in roughly 2,500 locations. After debuting with record-breaking numbers in only five cinemas last weekend, the film about a Scientology-esque cult leader took in an impressive $5 million upon its nationwide expansion.

Still, business overall was slow, and receipts dropped 25% this weekend when stacked up with the same three-day period last year.

“End of Watch” received the most positive critical reviews of any of the weekend’s new wide releases, and audiences liked it best as well. Those who saw the film assigned it an average grade of A-, according to market research firm CinemaScore. (Eastwood’s “Curve” received a B+ grade, while both “Dredd 3D” and “House at the End of the Street” each earned a B.)

The film stars Gyllenhaal and Michael Peña as Los Angeles Police Department officers who form a close bond as they work the streets of South-Central L.A. together. The film was financed by Emmett/Furla Films and Exclusive Media, but Open Road Films acquired North American distribution rights for about $2 million.

The movie is the latest of Gyllenhaal’s low-to-mid-budget films to perform modestly at the domestic box office. Last year, the 31-year-old’s sci-fi thriller “Source Code” grossed a decent $54.7 million at the U.S. box office, but his romantic drama “Love and Other Drugs” took in a more disappointing $32.4 million in 2010.

“House at the End of the Street,” is the first film that Jennifer Lawrence has appeared in since the release of the blockbuster “The Hunger Games” in March. The actress, who rose to fame after her Oscar-nominated turn in 2010’s “Winter’s Bone,” recently began generating awards buzz again after her upcoming dramedy “Silver Linings Playbook” debuted to rave reviews at the Toronto International Film Festival this month.

However, the 22-year-old won’t experience that same level of success with “House at the End of the Street,” in which she stars as a girl who moves to an eerie new neighborhood with her mother. The film was expected to debut with about $18 million, but couldn’t rake in enough young females to defeat “End of Watch.” (“House” appealed to a 61% female crowd, and 70% of the audience was under the age of 25.)

The movie, produced by FilmNation Entertainment and A Bigger Boat for $10 million, was acquired by Relativity Media last year for about $2.5 million. The film is the studio’s first release since April, when its Edgar Allan Poe thriller “The Raven” tanked in theaters.

“Trouble With the Curve” is the first movie that 82-year-old Eastwood has acted in -- but not directed -- in nearly two decades. In his new movie, the actor plays a baseball scout who must work on his troubled relationship with his daughter (Amy Adams) when he starts losing his vision.

Eastwood’s latest movie will need to benefit from strong word-of-mouth if it is to become a hit -- something the actor-director hasn’t seen in a few years. Both of his most recent directorial efforts, last year’s “J. Edgar” and the 2010 tsunami drama “Hereafter,” underwhelmed at the box office with under $40 million in sales. Four years ago, his role as a grumpy old man in “Gran Torino” resonated with audiences and took in an impressive $148.1 million. His latest curmudgeonly turn will not replicate that feat.

“Dredd 3D” generated positive fan hype at Comic Con in July, but that buzz didn’t carry over to the film’s opening weekend. The few who did turn up to see the movie about a law enforcer tasked with bringing order to a futuristic post-apocalyptic world were mostly older males.

The movie, adapted from the same “Judge Dredd” comic that spawned the 1995 Sylvester Stallone flop, was produced by IM Global for roughly $40 million. While domestic distributor Lionsgate put only a small amount toward that production cost, the studio still spent around $25 million to advertise the film.

[Updated, 10:44 a.m. Sept. 23: In limited release, “The Perks of Being a Wallflower” did excellent business. The film, based on writer-director Stephen Chbosky’s bestselling 1999 novel, debuted in four theaters and grossed $244,000. The film, which stars “Harry Potter” actress Emma Watson and up-and-comers Logan Lerman and Ezra Miller, centers on a group of teenagers trying to fit in at high school. The film brought in a 70% female crowd, and 60% were under the age of 25.

Meanwhile, “Ted” crossed the $200 million milestone at the international box office this weekend. The film featuring a foul-mouthed talking teddy bear has raked in $202.8 million abroad thus far, and the movie has yet to open in 12 foreign countries including Hong Kong and Korea. Combined with the film’s domestic ticket sales, the movie has grossed $419.8 million worldwide, making it the third-highest grossing comedy of all time globally behind the two “Hangover” films.

Here are the top 10 movies at the domestic box office, according to studio estimates and Hollywood.com:

1. “End of Watch” (Open Road/Emmett/Furla/Exclusive): Opened with $13 million.

1. “House at the End of the Street” (Relativity/FilmNation/A Bigger Boat): Opened with $13 million.

3. “Trouble With the Curve” (Warner Bros.): Opened with $12.7 million.

4. “Finding Nemo 3-D” (Disney): $9.4 million on its second weekend, down 43%. Domestic total: $30 million. $1.3 million overseas in 12 foreign markets. International total: $7.9 million.

5. “Resident Evil: Retribution” (Sony): $6.7 million on its second weekend, down 68%. Domestic total: $33.5 million. $30.5 million overseas in 73 foreign markets. International total: $103.4 million.

6. “Dredd 3-D” (Lionsgate/IM Global): Opened with $6.3 million.

7. “The Master” (Weinstein Co.): Opened with $5 million in wide release. Domestic total: $6.1 million.

8. “The Possession” (Lionsgate/Ghost House): $2.6 million on its fourth weekend, down 54%. Domestic total: $45.3 million.

9. “Lawless” (Weinstein Co./Yucaipa/Revolt): $2.3 million on its fourth weekend, down 47%. Domestic total: $34.5 million.

10. “ParaNorman” (Focus/Laika): $2.3 million on its sixth weekend, down 26%. Domestic total: $52.6 million. $3 million overseas in 39 foreign markets. International total: $29.2 million.]

ALSO:

‘House’ to top ‘Dredd,’ ‘End of Watch,’ Eastwood’s ‘Curve’

Movie review: Good cops on mean streets in ‘End of Watch’

Review: ‘House at the End of the Street’ is more angst than chills

Follow @AmyKinLA