Advertisement

Clean transit, poor oversight

collage of white vans and trucks between layers of torn paper court documents with a green lightning bolt in the center
(Los Angeles Times illustration; Photos courtesy of the California Air Resources Board and CALSTART)

See more from the L.A. Times in Google Search. Set us as preferred

California’s clean truck and bus incentive program was designed to expand the zero-emission vehicle market and improve air quality in heavily polluted communities.

But the $1-billion program has been roiled by allegations of fraud, waste and poor oversight.

Although state officials insist California’s clean truck and bus subsidy program has helped reduce air pollution and planet-warming gases, a Times investigation found that those claims rely heavily on assumptions and estimates, instead of actual data.

Advertisement

Some state-funded trucks and buses were rarely driven due to issues with vehicle performance and maintenance. In at least one case, California paid nearly $1 million in public funds for “vehicles that did not exist,” according to court records.

A premier California green transportation initiative is roiled by accusations of fraud, waste and poor oversight. Officials insist it is managed effectively.

Nikola Corp.’s former CEO was indicted for fraud. His company’s vehicles were the most heavily subsidized in California’s $1-billion clean truck incentive program on average.

If you have participated in California’s clean truck and bus subsidy program, known as HVIP, and would be open to sharing your story, we would like to hear from you.

VIDEO | 01:59
Accusations of fraud and waste roil California’s EV truck and bus voucher program
Cars on a Los Angeles highway
VIDEO | 01:23
Missing data from California’s EV truck and bus voucher program
Empty lot of city buses

California clean-air officials said they were disappointed by Los Angeles Times reporting on the state’s Clean Bus and Truck Voucher Project.

About this investigation

Project leads and reporters: Tony Briscoe and Sandhya Kambhampati

Editors: Monte Morin, Hanna Sender and Scott Kraft

Copy editors: Dave Bennett

Data and graphics lead: Sandhya Kambhampati

Graphics: Sandhya Kambhampati and Lorena Iñiguez Elebee

Design lead: Jim Cooke

Photo editors: Marc Martin and Kelvin Kuo

Photography: Tomas Ovalle, Christina House, Allen J. Schaben and Genaro Molina

Audience editor: Defne Karabatur

Video: Lara Hochuli

Toward a more sustainable California

Get Boiling Point, our newsletter exploring climate change, energy and the environment, and become part of the conversation — and the solution.

Advertisement