Advertisement

Would a DiCaprio or a Del Toro by any other name be as successful?

Leonardo DiCaprio and Benicio del Toro at a fan event
Leonardo DiCaprio and Benicio del Toro at an event promoting their new movie “One Battle After Another.”
(Eloisa Sanchez / Getty Images)
0:00 0:00

This is read by an automated voice. Please report any issues or inconsistencies here.

See more from the L.A. Times in Google Search. Set us as preferred

Oscar winner Leonardo DiCaprio shared a story from his childhood recently that caught a lot of attention. Apparently, when he was starting out as a child actor, an agent wanted his stage name to be Lenny Williams because “Leonardo DiCaprio” was “too ethnic”: “They’re never gonna hire you,” the agent allegedly told DiCaprio … before he became a household name.

In a conversation on the podcast “New Heights,” the actor said his father put an end to the nonsense about a name change. Though in fairness to the agent, Ramon Antonio Gerardo Estevez changed his name to Martin Sheen and did OK with that, and George Michael was born Georgios Kyriacos Panayiotou. In fact, Benicio del Toro, DiCaprio’s co-star in the upcoming film “One Battle After Another,” said one of his early agents wanted him to be “Benny Del.”

Their early days of trying to make it sound just like a fable....

Once upon a time, an inspiring young actor with bushy red hair and a toothy gapped smile decided to move from Cliffside Park, N.J., to La La Land. After days of fast food, he was looking forward to something authentic. That’s when, while driving down Somestreet Boulevard, he stumbled across a brightly painted food truck with a neon sign that flashed “The Mystic Taco.”

Advertisement

Intrigued, he parked and made his way to the truck.

“What do you recommend?” he asked the woman taking orders, in an obvious flirtatious manner. Slightly annoyed, the woman replies, “that depends on what you want,” in that tone a bartender uses when they flirt for the tips and not the digits.

“I want to make it in show business,” the young actor said, committed to making this awkward for both of them.

“The No. 5,” the cashier said with a blank face. “It’s our most popular dish.”

The menu listed two tacos and a fortune told.

“Do you have anything plant based?”

The cashier nods, turns her head slightly to her right and yells “No. 5, no guts.”

Technically that was true, but it still sounded like an insult to him.

Included with his vegan tacos meal was a teaspoon of street corn and a toy pocket compass. Smiling at the whimsy of it all, the actor flipped it open and saw it looked as if it had been bedazzled by a 3-year-old holding two glue guns. The mirror on the lid looked like it came from Barbie’s Dreamhouse. The needle spun wildly as if the Earth’s magnetic field were spinning out of sync with the planet.

Sensing the actor’s trepidation, the woman assured him that if he looked at it before every audition, the needle would point him in the right direction.

And so he took his tacos and trinket and tried to make it in show business.

When the actor went to his first audition, he opened the compass. The needle stopped spinning and pointed straight ahead. The actor looked up across from him and noticed another man there had brown curly hair. Panicked he was wrong for the role, the young actor abruptly left the room where the audition was being held and headed to the nearest salon to change his hair from red to brown. At his next audition, the actor again opened the compass, and this time it pointed to a man with big muscles and skinny jeans, and so the actor left the audition, joined a gym and went shopping at H&M.

He did this for a week.

Whenever the young actor went to an audition, he would open the compass, the needle would point straight ahead, and the actor learned what he needed to change next. But then weeks turned into a month and still the young actor had yet to audition much less land a role. He changed his name, closed the gap in his smile, got a nose job and a Brazilian butt lift — which made getting into the skinny jeans challenging — and yet each time he opened the compass, the needle pointed to someone else he needed to be.

Advertisement

A year later the actor was on his way to yet another audition when he noticed the Mystic Taco food truck parked on the other side of Somestreet Boulevard. He made a U-turn, got out and marched toward the front of the line. He struggled to take the compass out of his now-tight pocket.

“This thing does not work,” he yelled at the woman who sold him the No. 5 with no guts.

“Sure it does,” she said defensively.

The actor then explained that each time he opened the compass at an audition, it would direct him toward someone else he’s supposed to be. The woman let out a disapproving sigh, the way a mixologist responds to an order for Jagerbombs.

“The needle wasn’t pointing at other people,” she said. “It was pointing toward the mirror. That’s because the key to making it in show business or anywhere else is to be yourself.”

What a relief that our two real-life actors had the good sense to remain Leonardo DiCaprio and Benicio del Toro. Lenny and Benny wouldn’t be able to look at themselves in the mirror.

YouTube: @LZGrandersonShow

Insights

L.A. Times Insights delivers AI-generated analysis on Voices content to offer all points of view. Insights does not appear on any news articles.

Perspectives

The following AI-generated content is powered by Perplexity. The Los Angeles Times editorial staff does not create or edit the content.

Ideas expressed in the piece

  • The author celebrates the decision by Leonardo DiCaprio and Benicio del Toro to maintain their authentic names despite industry pressure, suggesting this choice reflects their integrity and self-respect. Through an allegorical tale about a mystical compass, the author argues that the fundamental key to success in show business lies in remaining true to oneself rather than constantly adapting to external expectations.

  • The narrative emphasizes that attempting to transform oneself to meet perceived industry standards is ultimately self-defeating, as illustrated through the fictional actor who continuously changes his appearance and identity based on what he observes at auditions. The author contends that authenticity serves as the true compass for success, positioning the pressure to change ethnic-sounding names as misguided industry gatekeeping.

  • The author concludes with a pointed assertion that had these actors adopted the suggested stage names “Lenny and Benny,” they would be unable to maintain their self-respect, implying that compromising one’s identity for career advancement represents a fundamental betrayal of personal values and authenticity.

Different views on the topic

  • The entertainment industry has a well-established tradition of successful name changes that contradicts the author’s emphasis on authenticity as the sole path to success. Many prominent figures have adopted stage names for strategic career reasons, with Whoopi Goldberg changing from Caryn Elaine Johnson to reflect her bubbly personality, and Jamie Foxx adopting his stage name from Eric Marlon Bishop specifically to increase opportunities at comedy open mics[1].

  • Musical artists frequently demonstrate that name changes can be essential for creating a distinct brand and artistic persona, with Bruno Mars transforming from Peter Gene Hernandez and Lady Gaga evolving from Stefani Germanotta[1]. These changes represent calculated decisions that demonstrate how artists craft their identities to align with their creative vision and career aspirations, proving that a name constitutes a significant part of a star’s persona[1].

  • The practical considerations behind name changes often involve legitimate marketing and accessibility concerns rather than mere capitulation to prejudice. The reasons for celebrities adopting different names vary considerably, from names being too difficult to pronounce to artists simply wanting a fresh start[1]. This suggests that the agent’s concerns about marketability, while potentially problematic in their cultural implications, may have reflected genuine industry realities about audience accessibility and commercial appeal.

A cure for the common opinion

Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.

Advertisement