As Costa Mesa mulls issues of surveillance, privacy, CMPD expands its drone force
- Share via
In Costa Mesa, where residents and elected officials have recently debated the use of Flock license plate reader cameras and have raised issues about privacy and surveillance, local officers have been testing and expanding their use of drone technology.
A snapshot of Costa Mesa Police Department’s use of unmanned aerial recording devices was shared with city officials Tuesday, as officers proposed a two-year agreement for the purchase of one Skydio X-10 drone and three docking stations from Axon Enterprise, Inc.
Capt. Carlos Diaz said the additions, estimated to cost roughly $300,000, would be covered by a state organized retail theft grant and supplement a local drone policing program operating since 2019 and consisting of nine units and 24 qualified pilots.
Diaz said the department logged 459 flights during fiscal year 2025-26 and, prior to that, launched a two-month “Drone as First Responder” pilot program that allowed personnel to remotely deploy devices rather than using them in person.
CMPD plans to use a nearly $1.04-million federal funding allocation from Rep. Dave Min (D-Irvine) to develop a Real-Time Information Center that will serve as a data-driven hub inside the police station, and drones will be a part of those operations, according to Diaz.
“It’s improved awareness, efficiency and response to urgent calls for service,” the captain said of drone technology. “Flight operations allow incident commanders such as watch commanders and field supervisors to view events in real time, enabling rapid and effective response from field personnel.”
Lt. Nick Wilson, who oversees CMPD’s drone program, said the units are not being used for routine patrols, random or discretionary surveillance or immigration enforcement.
“It just doesn’t randomly fly looking at things or looking for crimes. It’s always responsive, based on calls for service,” Wilson told the council, clarifying all drone use complies with state and federal statutes.
Despite that assurance, and promise of a web portal that would let people search local activity, the expansion of a surveillance program developed without public input raised concerns among some residents Tuesday, including those who’d come to speak against the city’s use of Flock license plate reader cameras.
Despite the protests of ‘DeFlockers,’ who rallied outside City Hall Tuesday , Costa Mesa officials voted to keep 46 surveillance cameras aimed at city streets.
One commenter, who identified herself only as “Rachel,” urged officials to postpone a vote on the drone services agreement to allow more time for research and public outreach.
“I’m beyond angry that after hearing so many concerns from your community about mass surveillance and privacy, we are considering bringing more AI-powered mass surveillance to Costa Mesa,” she said. “I’m even more concerned that Costa Mesa didn’t do any public outreach before placing this on the agenda or, apparently, before doing a pilot program.”
Melissa Courtemanche wondered why police surveillance programs aren’t subjected to the same level of community engagement as public works projects.
“The discrepancy between the public outreach for parks and bike lanes and this doesn’t seem comparable at all,” she said. “I don’t even know that I object to drones. But this, it feels not quite on the up and up. It feels a lot like the Flock stuff.”
The city has recently debated over the implications of CMPD’s use of the license plate reader cameras under a contract with Atlanta-based Flock Safety, first installed on city streets in 2023 with funding from then-City Manager Lori Ann Farrell Harrison’s discretionary budget and subsequently renewed for three years in 2024 without a public hearing.
Officials in July directed City Atty. Kimberly Hall Barlow to bring back a series of amendments regarding data retention and sharing, along with other key provisions, before the contract’s expiration or renewal in April. Barlow said those edits would likely come to a Nov. 17 council meeting.
Opinions on the dais about the use and expansion of drones were split, with some expressing the need to trust local police and others seeking legal advice ahead of a contract.
“This is not mass surveillance,” said Councilmember Loren Gameros, making a motion to authorize the agreement. “This is being utilized on a case-by-case basis so we can empower our police department to protect you, us, our city and to help work with other police departments that are trying to do the same thing.”
Councilmember Jeff Pettis agreed.
“I trust my police department to enforce the law, and I’m actually getting sick of the message being put out there — it’s this constant drumbeat of, ‘Hey, these guys are all out to get us,’” he said. “The police department is here to keep my city safe, and we need to give them all the tools at their disposal to do that.”
One seat over, his council colleague Arlis Reynolds proposed a substitute motion, suggesting the city hold a townhall forum on modern policing and allow residents to weigh in on policies regarding Flock cameras, drones and data security and retention while discussing the future budget implications of expanded drone use.
The move was seconded by Councilmember Andrea Marr but found no other backers. Ultimately, the council voted 5-2 (Marr and Reynolds opposed) to authorize the Axon agreement, advising Barlow to explore adding language about evidence retention, sharing and a possible escape clause from the agreement.