Column: Where the Republicans running to replace Newsom in the recall say they stand on the issues
All the major candidates trying to oust Gov. Gavin Newsom and replace him are Republicans, but some wear different stripes. There’s a variety to choose from.
Sorry, can’t help you much on the best-known GOP aspirant: Caitlyn Jenner, the Olympic Gold medal-winning decathlete, reality television star and probably the most prominent transgender candidate in American history. She’s a recluse on public policy and has failed to tell us much about what she’d do as governor.
“We’re running out of water. I am a big advocate of fire protection, OK?” she answered pesky reporters pressing for specifics at a July 9 news conference, her first of the campaign. Aides stopped the Q&A after 12 minutes.
Days later, Jenner flew to Australia to compete in a reality TV show.
Back to Elder and Faulconer: One example of how they differ is on racial discrimination.
“It is bull— that racism remains a major problem in America,” Elder, who would be California’s first Black governor, told me.
Sure, he said, there used to be racism in employment and housing, “but not now.”
“The big problem” for Black communities, Elder continued, “is the absence of fathers in the home.”
But what about mistreatment of Black men by white police, as illustrated in the George Floyd killing?
“Police are more reluctant to pull the trigger on Black people than whites,” he contended.
I asked the 69-year-old syndicated talk show host, who grew up in Los Angeles’ Pico-Union and South Central neighborhoods and became a lawyer, whether he had ever felt racial discrimination.
“There’s nobody my age who hasn’t felt something. Nothing significant,” Elder replied.
The radio commentator has been insisting for many years that America is not systemically racist.
By contrast, when Faulconer was mayor, San Diego created a new city department aimed at ending systemic racism and assuring fair distribution of government funds for such things as parks, libraries and contracts.
“Establishing an Office of Race and Equity is an important step forward … to eliminate the historic inequities and barriers that have existed for so long,” the mayor said.
He called on San Diego to “help our nation acknowledge and act on the systemic racism that has held too many Americans back from their true potential.”
Faulconer recently emailed me: “I reject the notion that America is fundamentally racist.” But, he said, “We have much work to do when it comes to eliminating inequities and barriers.”
Racism is a sensitive subject that doesn’t get debated a lot in campaigns for high office. But it’s an important factor when politicians create public policy and divvy up tax dollars. Examples: police funding and use of force, affirmative action in public education and employment, and allocation of school money.
I called Rancho Santa Fe businessman John Cox, another Republican candidate in the Sept. 14 recall election, and asked him how seriously he considers racism.
Cox answered that Black and Latino children living in low-income communities receive second-rate public educations compared with white students whose parents can afford private schooling.
“Look at Black and brown communities in California, and they’re behind the eight ball. They’re being given short shrift,” he said.
Cox added: “I’m an advocate of school choice.”
School choice usually means taxpayer-funded vouchers that parents can spend at private institutions, a concept California voters have previously rejected.
On gun control, Faulconer differs from other candidates. He’s OK with California’s tight restrictions and doesn’t want to weaken or strengthen them.
Elder sounds like the National Rifle Assn., contending: “All they do is tie the hands of law-abiding citizens.”
Republican candidate Doug Ose, a former congressman from the Sacramento suburbs, has been urging people to arm themselves for self-protection, noting that the Newsom administration has been releasing state prisoners early.
Cox says the state should focus less on banning guns and more on identifying potential killers, treating any mental illnesses.
Abortion is no longer a burning issue in California. But a candidate’s position is often a litmus test for voters.
Faulconer supports abortion rights, labeling himself pro-choice.
Elder believes abortion law should be left up to each state. It was until the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark 1973 Roe vs. Wade decision that legalized abortion nationally. Elder thinks it was a bad decision.
“I believe abortion is murder,” he said.
Cox told me: “I’m pro-life, but not talking about it. I’d rather talk about water, about electricity. I’m not trying to change the abortion law.”
“My personal story,” Cox continued, “is my mother said she was raped by my real father. She had me and may have aborted me if it were legal [in 1955]. I had the right to life.”
On water, all the candidates are for more storage and desalinating. No controversy.
Bullet train? Derail it, they say.
“Put the dollars into local roads,” Faulconer asserts.
Jenner: Use the money to build former President Trump’s border wall.
One caveat in all this: What Elder says may not matter. He waited until the last minute before Friday’s deadline to file official paperwork. So, he didn’t make the secretary of state’s tentative list of candidates that was announced Saturday night.
Elder’s camp said it expects him to be included on the final certified list to be released Wednesday.
If not, it would be worse than Newsom’s team not acting in time to get the governor identified on the recall ballot as a Democrat.
No party has a monopoly on screw-ups.
The view from Sacramento
For reporting and exclusive analysis from bureau chief John Myers, get our California Politics newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.