We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The LA Times newsroom or editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content. Learn more

Review: Best Baking Mats

Whether you are a beginner or a professional baker, a baking mat is something that you will use a lot in your kitchen. It acts as a layer between your baked goods and the pan, preventing sticking and overly-browned bottoms. Not only are your delicious treats likely ruined when they stick to the pan, but it makes quite the mess to clean up. Reusable baking mats like these make your clean up a breeze and help minimize waste — such as wasted baked goods, aluminium foil, or parchment paper. You can get loads of use out of one baking mat, and you can even use them for non-baking purposes too.

We reviewed various baking mats and have created a list of the best baking mats in 2021. We want you to enjoy baking in your kitchen, not dreading the clean up process. These versatile mats are a great addition to any kitchen, so read our buyer's guide as well to learn more about what to look for in the best baking mats.

Best Baking Mat

Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat

The French are known for some of the most delicious baked goods and desserts in the world. Silpat has been a partner in the bakeries of numerous chefs in France for many years. This mat allows you to turn your pan into a non-stick pan without parchment paper or sprays. The mat can be used in any pan with dimensions of 13x18 inches. The mat is made up of fiberglass mesh and high-quality silicone, which provides even heat distribution to ensure that all parts of the food bake consistently. This baking mat is most widely used by top chefs all over the world. It is safe to be used in the freezer, microwave, and the oven in temperatures ranging from –40 degrees to close to 500 degrees.

  • The food-grade silicone distributes heat evenly
  • This product is highly durable
  • It can make any sticky surface into non-stick
  • The size will determine the color of the mat

Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat

These silicone mats provide even heat distribution so that the food doesn’t burn in any spot. They last for up to 3,000 uses if taken care of properly, which means that you can bake a great deal of items without worrying about replacing the baking mat. You can make cookies, roasted vegetables, and even macrons on these mats with ease. In addition, the mats are easy to clean with warm, soapy water or in the dishwasher for a hands-free cleanup. For convenient storage, they also roll up.

  • The mat can stand at a temperature up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
  • These mats can be rolled to store them in your kitchen cabinet
  • The border color of the mat can become faint after washing

Amazon Basics Silicone Food Safe Baking Mat

These non-stick mats by Amazon Basics come in a pack of three different sizes, perfect for a variety of pans. The silicone is highly durable, withstanding temperatures as high as 480 degrees. They are also easy to clean. Watch cookies slide off the mats with ease with perfectly crisp edges. Because this pack includes mats of various sizes, you can use them for much more than just baking, such as cooking pizza, roasting veggies, or baking bread. Foods like melted cheese or jam can make a real mess on standard baking sheets, but these baking mats can withstand any mess.

  • Can withstand oven temperature up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Made of highly durable material
  • Matss do not cover all pan sizes

Zulay Kitchen Silicone Baking Mat

These Zulay baking mats allow one to bake delicious food with a splash of color. The silicone transfers no plastic taste to your food — it is the perfect non-stick surface for your baking needs. Forget about oiling the pan or using aluminum foil, these baking mats are ideal for all types of mixtures, from pastries to brownies to cookies and more. Unlike others on the list that can reach 500 degrees, these Zulay mats can withstand temperatures only up to around 400 degrees Fahrenheit. They can be washed by hand or in the dishwasher. With a pack of two mats, you can make multiple batches of baked goods at one time.

  • These mats help to spread the heat evenly
  • They come in many colors to choose from
  • May melt if used in temperatures higher than 400 degrees Fahrenheit

KPKitchen Round & Square Silicone Baking Mat

This pack of baking mats is the perfect time saver for any of your baking needs. Forget about cutting parchment paper to the correct size of your pan since this set includes two half pan mats, one quarter pan mat, one round mat, and one square mat. These mats can be used over and over again. Use them to bake goods in the oven or freeze items in temperatures rangings from -40 to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. These mats have a non-stick surface which helps save you time when it is time to clean.

  • Easy to clean
  • Made from 100% silicone
  • Environmentally-friendly
  • Some reviews have complained of some sticking

Buyer's Guide

Many baking mats are available online, but one should keep an eye out while buying the best baking mats that are functional, durable, and easy to use. You don’t want to buy a mat made of low-quality materials and waste your money buying them again and again. Many find baking to be a fun activity and your kitchen deserves the best tools to make your hobbies, like baking, more enjoyable. We have created this guide to make it easier for you to choose the best baking mats. Take a look at the features to look for and helpful tips to keep in mind.

What are the key considerations to make while buying the best baking mats?

Easy to clean

The mat should be easy to clean. It should be easily cleaned by hand or with the help of a dishwasher. All the products mentioned in the list above can be washed in the dishwasher. This decreases your work when you can just throw the mat in the dishwasher and do other things.

Non-stick

The mat should be non-stick. The non-stick property of the mat allows one to bake without worrying about your goods burning or sticking to the pan. If you are a beginner, there is a high chance that your food may not be cooked properly, so using a silicone mat can give you some peace of mind that it won't stick to the pan. If you have a mat that makes any surface into a non-stick surface, you have less to worry about.

Durability

You should make sure that the mat that you are buying is durable. High-quality baking mats can be used numerous times in the oven without losing shape or form. This durability also helps you get the most out of your money.

Consistent result

The baking mat should be able to provide consistent and convenient results. It shouldn’t work well a few times, only for your food to stick on the fourth use. Make sure to check the reviews before buying one.

Baking mats can also help you achieve consistent, evenly-baked items. The heat distribution helps cook every item to perfection, and you want to make sure that your new purchase can consistently bake your items evenly.

What are features to look for in the best baking mats?

Plastic-free taste

The baking mat should never transfer a plastic taste to your food. Some mats are not entirely made up of silicone, hence they give off an unplesant odor or taste and ruin your food. This can have severe effects on your health as well. Check the product’s manufacturing details thoroughly before buying it. 100% silicone will give you the best, most reliable results.

Even heat distribution

The even heat distribution of the mats should be given the highest priority. If the heat is not evenly distributed, then your baking will suffer. The food would remain uncooked at some places and burned at others. To bake with professional-like results, buy the baking mats that have been proven to spread out the heat evenly across the baking pans.

Easy to store

Some of the baking mats can be rolled while others cannot. We suggest prioritizing the ones that can roll but it is ultimately a pesonal choice.

Versatility

Baking mats should be versatile in that they can be used in multiple settings, whether that is in the oven, the microwave, or the freezer. Each product will be able to handle different situations, so be aware when selecting a product. Some are only suitable for oven use, some can only withstand temperatures as high as 400 degrees Fahrenheit whereas some can withstand 480 degrees Fahrenheit, and others may not be dishwasher safe. If you get the most versatile mats out there, they will help you in making a variety of dishes, not just baked goods.

What are the benefits of baking mats?

Eco-friendly

The baking mat is highly eco-friendly. In today’s world, where there is constant waste, buying something eco-friendly is a great initiative to take up. Since these mats can be used many times over, it makes them highly environmentally-friendly. If you use aluminum foil or parchment paper sheets, you have to discard them after every use. Baking mats help cut down on waste and unnecessary spending.

Saves time

Baking mats help you save time in the kitchen. You don't have to worry about cutting the perfect size of foil or parchment, uneven baking, and very minimal clean up.

Easy to clean

The baking mats are easy to clean because they are non-stick. The non-stick properties of these mats make them easy to wash, especially when they can be thrown in the dishwasher.

Professional baking

These mats can even make a beginner feel like a professional baker. With even heat distribution, you get consistent results every time and the food won't cling to the pan. All of these things make these mats ideal for baking, whether that be professionally or at home.

What is the price range for baking mats?

The baking mats range from $2 to $40. The expensive ones are made of 100% silicone and don’t add a taste of plastic to the food. On the other hand, the cheap ones are not pure silicone and can seep toxic materials in your food. Buying a baking mat depends on your budget, but we would recommend buying mid-range to expensive ones. The cheap ones are not worth the low price with their poor materials and sub-par results.

Baking Mat FAQ

Q: Are baking mats an alternative to aluminum sheets?

A: Yes, baking mats are a great alternative to aluminum sheets or foil. Aluminum sheets require measuring and cutting, whereas the baking mats are reusable and are ready for your pan. Be sure to measure your pans first before purchasing silicone baking mats.

Q: Are baking mats durable?

A: Yes, they are incredibly durable. They can be used countless times without breaking down and can withstand high heat from the oven as well as the dishwasher.

Q: Are baking mats non-stick?

A: Yes, the high-quality baking mats are non-stick. The non-stick properties makes it easy to clean and prevents your baked goods from getting burned onto the pan or the baking mat. Keep the mat clean to prevent new food from sticking to the old food.

Q: Which size of baking mat should I buy?

A: You should check the dimensions of your baking tray or pan you use most often. Then, look for the baking mats with the exact measurements. You can also buy packs of varying sizes to fit your other trays.

bestcovery team.jpg
Our research team searches out the best of everything so that you can confidently pick the perfect products and services for your needs.
Related Content
Go to top