Scar removal creams assist in the process of skin healing after injury. With varying scar types, skin types, and healing abilities, there is no one-size-fits-all solution for scar treatment.
Mild scars usually fade on their own, appearing lighter over time. Eventually, they become almost invisible. Severe, deep injuries can cause scars that require medical attention and specialized treatment. Scars that range between mild and severe are typically where scar removal creams have the most impact. The cream is effective by limiting collagen regrowth, which causes changes in skin texture and pigmentation.
Scar removal creams differ in many ways. Below, we outline the important things to consider when choosing an effective cream. This scar removal cream buying guide will help you choose the best formula for your skin.
Things to Consider When Buying Scar Removal Cream
Scar Type
Skin injuries vary in type, size, and depth, so not all scars respond the same to scar removal cream application. Scar removal creams are most effective for the following types of scars:
Hypertrophic scars: Hypertrophic scars are red raised marks that occur on the original injury and do not extend beyond the original wound site. Hypertrophic scars are caused by cuts, burns, acne, or piercings.
Keloid scars: Keloid scars are smooth, raised marks that extend over and past the original wound site. These can result from piercings, severe acne, and accidents. Keloid scars feel harder than the surrounding undamaged skin.
Scar contractures: These scars are often caused by burns. They result from the healing process and have a thick, tight appearance.
Silicone-based vs. Water-based Formulas
Scar removal creams can either be silicone-based or water-based.
If you are prone to pigmented or raised scars, silicone-based formulas are highly recommended. They prevent textured scars from developing by creating a barrier over the skin. This barrier limits the moisture loss that can cause collagen overproduction and helps to smooth and flatten the scar area.
Water-based formulas do not work as effectively to prevent moisture loss. Therefore, this means they take longer to heal a scar. They can also be irritating to sensitive skin, which makes them a poor choice for children.
Ingredients
Check the full list of ingredients to ensure the cream does not contain anything you are allergic to or sensitive to. Once you have ruled out sensitivities, you want to consider the active ingredients in the scar removal cream. The active ingredients contribute to the strengthening and healing of the skin. Specific ingredients to look out for include:
Vitamin A
Vitamin A stimulates cell renewal to fade scars and smooth the skin.
Vitamin C
Vitamin C is effective for fading scar marks.
Vitamin E
This vitamin is an antioxidant that encourages cellular regeneration and wound healing. It prevents free radical damage and is important for healing newly obtained scars.
Glycerin or Allantoin
Both these compounds seal moisture into the skin for efficient scar healing.
Other ingredients that are effective at reducing the appearance of scars include onion extract, aloe vera, and green tea.
Manufacturer
Make sure you go for a recognized brand. Look for identifiable contact information and the required product approval. If it is difficult to find information about the manufacturer or the product other than its listing on third-party retail sites, it is best to practice caution. And keep in mind that products that make unrealistic claims that seem too good to be true probably are.
Formula
Scar removal cream viscosity can play a role in its effectiveness. Thin creams are not necessarily able to form a barrier over the skin that can assist with the healing process. On the other hand, creams that are too thick do not allow the skin to breathe efficiently. Choose a cream or a gel that applies easily without being too heavy.
Drying Time
Consider the drying time of the cream when choosing the best option. Ideally, you want a cream that won’t take too long to dry so that you can get dressed after applying it. However, it is not advisable to choose a cream that contains alcohol to assist in faster drying— this can irritate your skin and may cause a burning sensation when applied to sensitive wound areas.
Water-based creams dry in as quickly as a minute. Silicone-based scar removal formulas can take three to five minutes to set.
Price
Scar removal cream pricing can range from $10 to $50. There are effective creams across all price ranges, so before assuming that the most expensive is the best, consider the ingredients and the type of scar you are treating. Typically, more expensive scar removal creams will contain three or more active ingredients. It is always a good idea to consult a dermatologist for the most effective treatment of more serious scars.
Scar Removal Cream FAQ
Q:
Will a scar removal cream take a scar away completely?
A:
Scar removal creams can significantly smooth the skin and lighten the appearance of scars. Scar creams are not an overnight solution and work better for certain scar types and skin types. Although they make a noticeable difference, deeper scars would need to be treated medically to completely remove all signs of the wound.
Q:
How often should you apply scar removal cream?
A:
Creams may be different according to the active ingredients in the specific formula. Follow the package instructions. Creams generally recommend applications once or twice daily— keep in mind that applying the cream more often than recommended will not give you faster results.
Q:
How long does scar removal cream take to work?
A:
Results require consistent application and patience. The scar removal cream can start showing results between two and six months but the healing process will largely be affected by your age, skin type, and scar type.
Q:
When can you start using scar removal cream after an injury?
A:
Don’t start applying scar removal cream if your injury is not yet healed. Trying to reduce the appearance of a scar before the skin has healed completely can make it worse.