We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The LA Times editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content. Learn more

The Seasoning You Never Knew You Needed: Best Bagel Seasonings

  1. Trader Joe's Everything Bagel Seasoning
  2. FreshJax Premium Bagel Seasoning
  3. McCormick Culinary Bagel Seasoning
  4. Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning
  5. Buyer's Guide

There’s nothing more comforting than having a fresh bagel. Some prefer a sweeter bagel, perhaps a bagel with an egg, or even a dash of Tabasco for some spice. A bagel seasoning ups the flavor profile with the most popular being an Everything Seasoning. There are numerous bagel seasoning brands on the market, all with their own unique flavor. We present the best bagel seasoning in 2022 on the market.

Detailing the Best Bagel Seasoning of 2022

Trader Joe's Everything Bagel Seasoning - Top Pick

Trader Joe’s Everything But The Bagel Seasoning Blend is the perfect choice for those seeking a non-GMO, kosher seasoning. With an array of flavors from sea salt to garlic and onion, this one is a crowd favorite. Add it to not only bagels but eggs and rice as well. It's a great alternative to high sodium soy sauce. The only downside is that it only comes in a 2.3 oz bottle.

FreshJax Premium Bagel Seasoning - Runner Up

Certified organic and non-GMO, this concoction by FreshJax is delicious! If you're watching what you eat, you'll love the nutrition facts. 0 calories, 0 fat, and only 44mg of salt. It's also vegan, keto, and paleo diet friendly. Another great benefit is that you're helping out a small family business that gives back to their community with every purchase.

McCormick Culinary Bagel Seasoning - Honorable Mention

The McCormick brand needs no introduction when it comes to creating flavorful spices and seasonings. Their Everything Bagel Seasoning is packed full of flavor thanks to its onion and garlic profile. This seasoning also includes poppy seeds, salt, sesame seeds, and sunflower oil. The McCormick is perfect for restaurants since it comes in a 21 oz container.

Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning - Consider

Badia Everything Bagel seasoning is delicious and flavorful, not to mention certified gluten free and kosher! It comes in a 5.5oz jar. You might need to purchase their bundle pack because it's truly delicious. Not only is it great on a bagel, but salmon and avocado toast are just a few other ideas where you can use this seasoning.

Buyer's Guide

It is hard to beat the taste of a fresh bagel. Others like a sweeter bagel, perhaps one with eggs, or maybe one flavored with Tabasco. The most popular bagel seasoning takes the flavor profile to the next level. It is possible to find several different brands of bagel seasoning, each with a unique flavor. All of this makes it quite difficult to choose the right product. However, if you have a working knowledge of seasonings and their best uses, you can choose the most suitable seasoning.

What is a Homemade Bagel Seasoning Made Of?

The bagel seasoning mix is a favorite and a well-loved seasoning mix for a good reason. To every dish, it adds the perfect amount of salty, nutty, crunchy flavor. In case you’re wondering what goes into homemade bagel seasoning, here is what it is:

  • Dried Garlic Flakes

Try not to make use of granulated garlic or garlic salt. Look out for dried garlic flakes. In most grocery stores, you will find them in the spice section.

  • Dried Onion Flakes

They are also sometimes called dry minced onions. Make sure not to use onion powder here, either. The best bagel seasoning manufacturers steer clear of this.

  • Black Sesame Seeds

Usually, these can be found in the spice section of a grocery store, but you can find them in the Asian section. An Asian food market may also sell them. The taste will not differ if you use more white sesame seeds instead of black sesame seeds.

  • Regular Sesame Seeds

The white seeds are the regular ones. Sesame seeds should be toasted here because it enhances the tastes of the blend.

  • Poppy Seeds

It’s pretty straightforward. You can use anything you like. When it comes to poppy seeds, fresh ones are always better. So, you might want to replace your jar if it’s from the late 90s.

  • Flaked Sea Salt

It is important to point out that this is not regular table salt. Compared to other varieties of salt, sea salt flakes are light and crispy with no rock-like texture. They also have great taste. If you’re a salt snob, you most likely have dumped the regular table salt for this fine sea salt. It is recommended that you use Maldon sea salt to make your dish taste better. They are very cool but coarse forms of sea salt, and it’s like chewing on little rocks.

Every kind of bagel seasoning mix contains the same five ingredients, whether you buy them (or make them yourself): poppy seeds, sesame seeds, onions, garlic, and salt. The flavors of black sesame seeds are richer and smokier than regular sesame seeds. Some blends also include them, which have a slightly nuttier taste. We have seen it used on tacos, eggs, vegetables, chicken strips, sandwiches, and even pizza, as the mix is based on the seasoning mix historically served with bagels.

How to Use Bagel Seasoning

If you love to eat your food well-seasoned, there really are not many restrictions on what you can put your bagel seasoning on. From pizzas to avocados, lovers of bagel seasonings have found various tasteful delights from trying out their favorite seasonings on some of their regular foods. These seasonings can be used on a variety of food items. A good option would be to add them to snacks or on a hard-boiled egg. It might even taste better with scrambled eggs. Such a good breakfast idea, wouldn’t you say?

So, if you are short of ideas, here are a few other things that you can put bagel seasonings on:

  • Avocados and avocado toast
  • Pizza crust
  • Salads
  • Lettuce Wraps & Sandwiches
  • Sushi Bowls
  • Smoked Salmon
  • Roasted Vegetables
  • Popcorn

No matter what you add it on, it’s always going to taste better!

How to Choose Bagel Seasoning

The following are important factors to consider before buying bagel seasoning.

Ingredient

While it is true that bagel seasonings typically contain the same ingredients, it is important that you consider the mix. For example, some people do not really like salty seasoning. Such people should look out for seasonings with little or no salt. Some brands even have salty and non-salty seasonings available.

Keto and Gluten

This factor is an extension of the first factor. Individuals on a strict keto diet or those looking to avoid gluten should check the seasoning label to make sure it is keto-friendly and free of gluten.

Certification

It is also important that the seasoning is certified by the appropriate food agencies. You don’t want to consume something harmful to your health.

Best Bagel Seasoning FAQs

Are poppy seeds necessary for making Bagel Seasonings?

There’s no need to add poppy seeds if you love bagel seasoning but not poppy seeds in general. It has a slightly different taste but is still very tasty! Food should always be enjoyable to eat, and adjusting recipes to your tastes is the best way to do that. I love the taste of this seasoning mix because it is so versatile. It always meets your craving for spicy crunch and can be adjusted to your taste.

You can simply omit poppy seeds from the recipe, or you can substitute chia seeds or another spice of your choice in place of them.

What is the best way to determine whether a seasoning is of high quality?

Different brands have different values. The bulk of brands make a push to offer a different unique selling proposition than their competition. When shopping for bagel seasonings, it is highly recommended that you look for products from established brands that you can trust when it comes to product quality.

Do you know how to find customer reviews on seasonings?

They can be found at retail stores such as Amazon or Etsy. As regards ratings, the review section provides you with hands-on information about the bagel seasoning target from the perspective of real-world users.

bestcovery team.jpg
Our research team searches out the best of everything so that you can confidently pick the perfect products and services for your needs.
Related Content
Go to top