We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The LA Times newsroom or editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content. Learn more

Review: Best Toasters

Looking for a new toaster? Here are the best two- and four-slice options based on performance, features, and value. All the best toasters in 2021 that are on this list will have a toast shade adjustment knob so any style or thickness of bread can be toasted to your satisfaction. To keep you safe, they’ll be wrapped in a heat-resistant shell so you won't burn yourself when touching the toaster, and all have a removable crumb tray for ease of cleaning out the bits and pieces of toasted bread falling to the bottom.

Two-slice toasters are the most popular types of toasters available. The concept has always been to be able to put in a couple of slices of bread, push the handle down, and in a few minutes - voila - you'll have perfectly toasted bread. Two slice toasters range from options that are only capable of toasting thin slices of bread, to a multi-function unit accommodating bagels, artisan breads, and muffins.

Four-slice toasters are perfect for the household which wants toast and wants a lot of it. These appliances are bigger, take up more space, and use more electricity than their two-slice cousins. However, the convenience to make twice as much toast in the same amount of time outweighs these disadvantages, making them just as viable as two-slice toasters over the long run.

Each of these toasters will evenly brown the bread, regardless of the setting; after all, first and foremost, the best toasters must make the best toast.

Comparing the Best Toaster

Elite Gourmet ECT4829B Maxi-Matic 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster

This bread toaster is great for just about anything you like to toast – good old bread, bagels, and everything in between. Armed with two extra-large 35mm slots and 850W of raw heating power, it ensures your toast is ready in time and is well done. Intuitive analog controls on the front including three buttons and a rotary knob give you up to 6 browning levels, reheat and defrost functions and a cancel button that stops whatever operation you are doing on the toaster in real-time. This toaster is available in three colors to match your kitchen countertop décor, features a crumb tray for easy cleaning, and is space-saving. It also comes at a budget-friendly price and you also get free bamboo tong clips on each purchase.

Cuisinart 4-Slice Toaster

If you’re looking for a machine with a lot of features and innovations, then the Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster might be right for you. This toaster has no levers, and will automatically lower whatever bread product you want into the slot, raising it when finished. One side of this toaster has an advanced bagel feature, meaning your bagels will come out just as perfect as your toast. This toaster has a backlit LCD screen for displaying toaster functions, and even has an audible alert which sounds off when toasting is completed. If you want everything to be automatic, then this appliance might be for you. It comes with a three year warranty.

Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster

The Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster is a computer-controlled toasting wonder. This feature-packed unit has wide slots to toast virtually any bread product. The pre-programmed functions are defrost, reheat, bagels, or cancel. After that, the toaster automatically does the rest. The “lift-and-look” feature allows you to inspect the toast at any point during the toasting process while never breaking the original cycle. If you aren’t quite satisfied with how browned the bread is, simply hit the “A Bit More” button (yes, it's really labeled like that), and the cycle will continue for about 10 more seconds. Although there are five browning control settings, the toaster actually allows limitless variables between the one to five settings. The illuminated LED panel gives you a full, lighted view of all the functions, and it also comes protected by a one year warranty.

Hamilton Beach Extra Wide 2 Slot Toaster

If you want the best bang-for-the-buck toaster here, get the Hamilton Beach 22623 2-Slice Toaster. It's the lowest price toaster on this list, yet it makes toast as good as any of them. There’s nothing real fancy here, although you get a wide handle to lower the bread, bagels, waffles, or whatever product you can fit into the wide slots. The reality is that for virtually anyone who wants well-toasted bread, they’ll get it with this unit, for an affordable price in an easy-to-use package.

Twinzee Wide Slot Toaster

This bread toaster is great for just about anything you like to toast – good old bread, bagels, and everything in between. Armed with two extra-large 35mm slots and 850W of raw heating power, it ensures your toast is ready in time and is well done. Intuitive analog controls on the front including three buttons and a rotary knob give you up to 6 browning levels, reheat and defrost functions and a cancel button that stops whatever operation you are doing on the toaster in real-time. This toaster is available in three colors to match your kitchen countertop décor, features a crumb tray for easy cleaning, and is space-saving. It also comes at a budget-friendly price and you also get free bamboo tong clips on each purchase.

West Bend Egg and Muffin Toaster

Although the West Bend Egg and Muffin Toaster’s main claim to fame is making great toast, this reasonably-priced toaster is capable of making a complete breakfast while your bread is heated. While you’re toasting, an attached side pod will hard-boil up to eight eggs, or you can choose to make them scrambled or poached. With all of these extra features, this appliance uses 1,200 watts, twice that of most other options. If you’re trying to lower your energy bill, you may want to reconsider this one. However, as far as features, function, and toast quality, this two-slice toaster is second to none. It comes with a stow-away power cord as well.

Buyer's Guide

Best Toaster Buyer's Guide

Nothing beats a good batch of French toast for breakfast. They are tasty, they provide energy, and they are easy to make, especially if you have the best toaster. Thinking about buying a new toaster? Well, you are in the right place. If you are still using your slow toaster that takes forever to make toast—then maybe it is time for an upgrade. Modern toasters have more features, and they are much more energy-efficient compared to ancient ones.

If you are looking to get a new toaster for faster preparation and more features, then you are in for a treat. This section of the article will fill you in on the details. You will learn everything you need to know about buying a modern toaster for your home or office — so you can make the best morning or evening toast. Cheers!

What is a Toaster?

A toaster is a kitchen appliance that can make toast easier than using an oven or pan. You can use it for cooking waffles, bagels, English muffins, Pop-Tarts, baguettes, and slices of bread. Some toaster ovens can also be used for broiling burger patties, steaks, and you can even bake cookies! Sounds pretty good, right?

Why Do You Need a Toaster?

Because you need to eat to live, you are going to need a toaster to eat! Here are some of the reasons why you need a toaster in your home:

Toasters are versatile

Having a toaster or toaster oven in your home will allow you to cook almost anything. Some people even cook salmon in oven toasters, and they taste pretty good. We tested a lot of different toasters and experimented with a lot of recipes. It turns out toaster ovens are more versatile than we thought.

For preparing breakfast easily

If you are running late for work or school, you can quickly whip up a healthy breakfast with a toaster. Modern toasters will literally take seconds to toast a slice of bread, allowing you to prepare a good meal for your family every morning.

For making different types of toast

Modern toasters are more versatile with the type of toast you want to make. Some people want their bread crisped, and some prefer lightly-toasted bread. With modern toasters, you can change the configuration and make the toast of your choice!

Toasting Tips

If you are using an oven to make toast, it will take around 10 minutes to get the perfect toast. The secret to making the perfect brown toast on a modern toaster takes only one to four minutes. The secret is using medium settings to get that perfect toast and leave stripes of the grill on your bread. Yum! With toaster ovens, you can also make grilled cheese sandwiches, burgers, and more. The secret is to use medium settings for anything you cook to bring out the most flavor, especially meat.

Types of Toaster

There are different types of toasters, but in this article, we will only show you the two most common types.

Pop-Up Toasters

If all you need is morning toast, a pop-up toaster is the perfect option for you. You can use it to make toasted bagels and bread quickly. It is space-saving and efficient. It is ideal for people who are always on the move. Even if these toasters are modern, you can still get them in retro finishes. Some options are more contemporary, and it all depends on your taste and home aesthetic.

Toaster Ovens

Toaster ovens are the more versatile type of toasters. These options are excellent for cooking toast, pizza, burgers, sandwiches, and a lot more. They may take more space on your countertop, but they are more useful if you love preparing various recipes for you and your family.

Things to Consider Before Buying a Toaster</h3>

Size

The size is essential, especially if you have limited space in your kitchen for gadgets. If you are trying to save space, you can get a pop-up toaster. If space is not an issue, you can get them both!

Features

Features matter when buying a toaster, especially if you want to make different types of toast. Most modern toasters have different features, such as temperature and timer settings.

Quality

The quality of a toaster is another essential factor to consider. You want something that can last. Toasters are meant for daily use, and it would be a bummer if your toaster breaks only after a few months.

Cooking time

If you are always on-the-go or running late for your daily activities, make sure you get a toaster that can make toast fast. Don’t worry, there are options that can make perfectly toasted bread slices in a minute or less.

Warranty

Having a warranty is a sign of a good product. If the manufacturer includes a warranty, it means that they have faith in the durability of their products, and they would be happy to replace it if it breaks.

Price Ranges

Toaster prices range from $30 to $500. It depends on the size, features, brand, and quality. Anything under $100 should be good enough for casual toast lovers, but some people want to go for the premium models and willing to spend more.

How we Choose the best Toasters

To make sure that our recommendations are the best, we test dozens of toasters for ourselves. We also ask other people who have been using a certain brand of toaster for a while now to see their honest opinions.

FAQ

Can you use toasters for bagels and waffles?

Yes! Some pop-up slice toasters have bigger slots for bagels, waffles, Pop-Tarts, and other thin slices of bread. If you have a toaster oven, you can cook more meals.

How long does it take to make the perfect toast?

The secret to making the perfect toast is using medium heat settings and set the toaster’s timer for 2 to 4 minutes. Depending on the toaster, you are going to need to experiment with the time.

Bestcovery Staff
Our research team searches out the best of everything so that you can confidently pick the perfect products and services for your needs.
Related Content
Go to top