We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The LA Times newsroom or editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content. Learn more

Keep Your Baby Content with the Best Pacifier

Choosing the best pacifier for your infant will probably involve some trial and error. Though they may not be able to express their opinions, babies will let you know when a pacifier works well for them (and when it doesn't). Most parents find that pacifiers are invaluable in the first few months of life. In addition to soothing infants, some experts believe that pacifier use can also reduce the risk of SIDS. Whether you need a pacifier for a newborn, a breastfeeding infant, or an older baby, the products on these lists for the best pacifiers are all top-rated by parents and designed for babies at various stages of development. 

We want to buy the best products for babies. Buying the best pacifiers in 2021 is more complicated and time-consuming. Check this buyer’s guide now.

Compare The Best Pacifiers Of 2021

best flex pacifier

Nuby Natural Flex Pacifiers - Best Pacifier Overall

Nuby’s Natural Flex pacifier is a great choice for your breastfed baby because they’re designed to flex and stretch much like mom’s breast does. The movement of the nipple and the flex encourages the natural suckling reflex which is very soothing for babies. This pacifier also features patented nubs that gently massages the gums in order to provide additional comfort during teething. The orthodontic nipple fits the natural shape of your little one’s mouth and the pacifiers butterfly design minimizing contact with babies face, preventing the development of rashes. It comes in 2 sizes from 0-6 months to 6+ months along with five vibrant colors to choose from.

The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier - Runner Up

The Gumdrop Pacifier from First Years is one of the leading pacifiers chosen by hospitals nationwide. Made with BPA, latex, and phthalate-free materials, this pacifiers one-piece design is made of soft, durable, silicone. The nipple shape closely mimics moms, so there’s less of a chance of baby experiencing nipple confusion and it also promotes healthy oral development. This pacifier also features a butterfly design to minimize contact with your child’s face and reduce the likelihood of irritation. It’s designed for babies between the ages of 0 and 6 months and available in several different colors and fun patterns.

NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers - Honorable Mention

The Nuk Silicone Pacifier features a nipple designed to conform to baby’s mouth, just like mom’s breast does. The orthodontic design allows baby to gently suckle without disrupting the development of their teeth. The pacifier also features the unique Nuk Air System which allows the nipple to adjust on its own, providing a proper fit for baby’s mouth. There are also grooves in the pacifier shield which enable air to flow through it, preventing the development of any irritation on baby’s skin.  As with our other picks, there are several colors and designs to choose from.

Philips AVENT Freeflow Pacifier - Consider

Avent’s Contemporary Free Flow Pacifier features an orthodontic, symmetrical, collapsible nipple that conforms to baby’s mouth the same mom’s breast does, thereby preventing nipple confusion. Made of soft, odorless silicone, this BPA-free pacifier will allow your baby to enjoy the sensation of soothing suckling. The nipple shield is curved and designed with vents that allow for extra airflow, thus reducing the development of irritation. These pacifiers come in an array of colors and designs and they also have a snap-on nipple cover to protect it from germs when not in use.

Natursutten BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier - Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies

The Natursutten Butterfly Pacifier is the only pacifier on the market made completely from natural materials. Instead of silicone or latex, this pacifier is made of natural rubber drawn from the Hevea brasiliensis tree. The design of the nipple mimics the shape of mom’s nipple and comfortably conforms to the shape of baby’s mouth and won't contribute to problems with tooth development down the line. The pacifiers butterfly design creates more space for baby’s nose, thus upping the comfort factor as well as helping expand airflow. The pacifier shield also contains two air vents, which prevents the development of a rash by improving airflow while baby is suckling.

MAM Start Pacifier - Best Pacifier for Newborns

Designed to promote healthy jaw development, the MAM start pacifier has been with a nipple made with the softest silicone for a natural silky feeling. The pacifiers orthodontic nipple also mimics the shape and feel of mom's nipple to prevent any instances of nipple confusion. Additionally, there is no correct up or down as the shape of the nipple is designed so it’s always in baby's mouth correctly. Plus, because of the innovative curved design of this pacifier, it’s easy for little ones to keep the MAM start in their mouths. Moms love these pacifiers come with a convenient case which doubles as a microwave-safe sterilizer and the included pacifier clips can be attached to prevent accidental loss. This pacifier comes in a selection of pleasant pastel colors and sweet designs to match your little bundle of joy.

Munchkin Latch Stage 2 Nipple Pacifier - Best Pacifier for Newborns

Moms and pediatric dentists worked together to design the BPA-free Munckin Latch Pacifier so there’s no worry of nipple confusion or potential disruption of proper tooth development. The natural-shaped nipple mimics moms, allowing baby to create a natural latch which helps to ease the eventual transition from breast to pacifier. The one-piece silicone design of this pacifier is super lightweight, making it easier for a newborn to hold onto while the heart-shaped shield creates a comfortable fit around baby’s mouth. This pacifier itself is clear but there are pleasing color options for the border around the pacifiers shield.

Playtex BinkyLatex Pacifier - Best Pacifier Overall

Designed by dentists, the Playtex OrthoPro Pacifier is an orthodontic pacifier that won’t negatively affect the alignment of your baby’s teeth. Thanks to the ultra-thin, wavy stem, the pacifier exerts reduced pressure on your little one’s developing gums as well. The pacificer also features an AirComfort Shield which allows for enhanced air flow while preventing moisture-related skin irritation on babies face. There's also the Snug ‘N Place technology which stops the ring from moving around and making noise while your child is sleeping. This pacifier is available in silicone as well as latex in addition to an array of colors and designs.

MAM Air Silicone Pacifier - Best Pacifier Overall

Because they work closely with pediatric dentists and orthodontists, MAM pacifiers won’t disturb the alignment of your baby’s developing teeth at all stages. In fact, this pacifier comes in 4 different shapes specific to newborns, 0-6 months, 6+ moths, and 16+ months. These pacifiers are anatomically correct to accommodate the contours of bay’s mouth and ensure they're always in the proper position. The curved shield, large air holes, and an innovative, non-irritating surface means these pacifiers can be enjoyed by baby in total comfort. A soft silicone nipple also makes this a good choice for breastfed and bottle fed babies alike. Thanks to the anti-slip surface, these pacifiers stay in place better and you’ll love the wide selection of colors and designs that are available to choose from.

Dr. Brown's PreVent Design Pacifier - Best Pacifier Overall

Designed by a pediatric dentist, the Dr. Brown's PreVent Pacifier won’t get in the way of your baby’s developing teeth. Additionally, the PreVent design lowers the pressure inside baby’s mouth while sucking on this pacifier, so there’s less of a chance that you will have to deal with dental issues down the road. There's also less palatial pressure thanks to the patented "suction-free air channel" which reduces the suction effect while in use so baby has a more comfortable pacifier experience. The pacifer has also been designed with a thin stem design which is minimally intrusive upon your little one’s mouth. As with our other picks, this pacifier comes in a large selection of cute designs and fun colors.

RazBaby Keep-it-Clean Pacifier - Best Pacifier Overall

Thanks to the built-in closing shield that is attached to the RazBaby Keep It Kleen Pacifier, you’ll never have to worry about it getting covered in germs if it drops on. That’s because this contoursd shield instantly closes around the pacifier in the event it's dropped on the ground. Because it's attached to the pacifier, you also won’t have to worry about losing the cover. The entire pacifier also flexes to fit baby’s mouth perfectly, providing him or her with maximum comfort. Ventilation holes allow for improved air circulation around baby's mouth while also working to prevent irritation as well. The orthodontic, vented silicone nipple is soft and won’t negatively affect your baby’s developing teeth. There are also several colors and designs to choose from which baby is sure to love!

Buyer's Guide

When it comes to keeping your child happy, a baby pacifier is an absolute requirement. Pacifiers are not only a fantastic method to concentrate your baby’s attention and quiet them down, but they are also a vital device that may assist you in caring for your baby’s gums and teeth. We’ve put up some ideas and advice for picking the finest baby pacifier to assist you in preventing any headaches.

Why do you need a baby pacifier?

Before diving into the purchase guide, it’s important to understand what a baby pacifier is and what it does. When your child develops, it’s only normal to be isolated from their mother’s natural bodily components and need to locate a replacement. A pacifier is a nipple with a handle, and it was designed with the primary goal of keeping your infant quiet and relaxed. Some newborns like to suckle just when they are being fed, while others prefer to continue the practice after they have been fed. Suckling is not only a fantastic way to quiet down agitated children, but it may also be a terrific solution for one of the most difficult times in a baby’s life: when teeth begin to emerge. This is a period of intense itching in the gum zone and pain and severe discomfort. The pacifier can be used to assist your infant cope with itching and soreness.

When is it appropriate to begin using a pacifier?

Although your baby will not communicate their needs with words, they will most likely give you obvious indications when a pacifier is required. For example, if you observe them sucking on an empty baby bottle or looking for other items to suckle on, the moment has likely come. Alternatively, your baby may be sucking on your breast without really feeding and displaying apparent symptoms of dissatisfaction and displeasure when you take it away. You may see your child sucking their fingers or thumbs, as well as toys, blankets, and other things within reach. All of the indicators mentioned above indicate that a baby pacifier will be useful.

What are the factors to consider while buying a pacifier?

Choosing the right pacifier for your kid isn’t always as straightforward as it appears. Before selecting, consider the following aspects to guarantee that your child will be pleased and comfortable with the new goods.


The size of your baby’s pacifier will change based on their age. Most pacifiers are available in three sizes: small, medium, and big. Every product will have its size and suggested age range. It’s critical to pay close attention to the age guidelines since selecting the incorrect size can result in various unpleasant and sometimes deadly outcomes. Giving your infant a pacifier that is too big may cause pain, while giving them too little may result in choking if there is no age guideline for the pacifier. You should attempt to get as much information as possible from the vendor or manufacturer.


For safety reasons, the pacifier’s guard should be at least 12 inches long. This is the portion that prevents your child from swallowing the pacifier. Every pacifier has a distinctive guard design. A curved shield may be beneficial since most parents prefer it to other forms of protection. Additionally, look for ventilation holes that allow air to circulate between the child’s face and the guard. This will keep rashes and skin irritations at bay.

Nipple material

The pacifier’s nipple section should be made of safe and comfy material for your child. Because it mimics the mother’s breast, it is the essential element of the infant pacifier. The nipple material, especially if this is your baby’s first time using a pacifier, might make your infant adore it or reject it altogether.

A silicone nipple, one of the most widely used, may be seen on baby pacifiers. They are very simple to maintain and clean. You can even clean the silicone pacifier without much effort by putting it in the dishwasher. Others have a latex nipple attached. Latex provides more flexibility and a gentler touch than silicone. Although latex pacifiers are not as robust or long-lasting as silicone pacifiers, infants prefer them because of their pleasant feel and softness. Finally, pacifiers can be made of strong plastic. This option is long-lasting and cleans up quickly and easily. On the other hand, plastic may be harmful to a newborn if a sharp edge forms and many babies reject it.

When is it time to get a new pacifier?

Nothing lasts indefinitely, and infant pacifiers are no exception. Regardless matter how well you clean and care for the pacifier, it will ultimately degrade to the point that it is no longer useful. The amount of time it takes to replace a pacifier varies depending on how it was used and how frequently your infant suckled on it. It’s time to replace the pacifier if you see holes or tears in the nipple, regions where the color has faded, evidence of the nipple being strained, or any loose pieces. Furthermore, if the nipple has gotten so sticky that even cleaning it won’t help, or if the plastic on the handle or guard has become jagged, the pacifier is no longer acceptable for your infant to use.

What are the different types of pacifiers?

There are many various types of infant pacifiers available for you to try.

Baby animal pacifier

If your child has never used a pacifier before, experiment with several varieties to see which one works best for them. You may liven things up with a Baby Animal Pacifier, which is a charming blend of a soft toy and a high-quality pacifier that tiny ones like.

Fresh food pacifier

You may also try the Fresh Food Pacifier, which is an excellent opportunity to sample various fruits and tastes. This device makes it simple to keep your baby healthy and happy by allowing you to fill the pacifier with fresh fruit.

Pacifier thermometer with LCD display

Try the Baby Pacifier Thermometer with LCD Display if you want to keep track of your baby’s temperature in a discreet and convenient method. The device provides a unique and pleasant approach to take your child’s temperature with no effort.


Q: Is it okay if I give my three-week-old pacifier?
A: Wait until your kid is 3 to 4 weeks old before giving him a pacifier, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics. So, sure, you can give a pacifier to your three-week-old.

Q: Is it important to use a pacifier?
A: To prevent SIDS, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that parents give their newborns pacifiers after 3 to 4 weeks old.

Q: Is it true that orthodontic pacifiers are more effective?
A: Orthodontic pacifiers are superior to regular pacifiers because they provide additional benefits. They are well designed to prevent interfering with the natural growth of the jaws and palate.

bestcovery team.jpg
Our research team searches out the best of everything so that you can confidently pick the perfect products and services for your needs.
Go to top