How Comey’s story stacks up to Trump’s

Design by Priya Krishnakumar

It’s the president’s word against his former FBI director’s.

How do James Comey’s detailed memos to top intelligence officials stack up to Donald Trump’s early morning tweets? Now that we have both sides of the story — and an explosive new book from Comey, in which he calls Trump “untethered to the truth” — take a look at what was happening during the-sometimes “uneasy” and “awkward” meetings between fired FBI director James Comey and President Trump.

Jan 6: Briefing

Trump Tower

Trump meets with Comey for the first time at Trump Tower. (Justin Lane / EPA)

Comey's account

The FBI director and other intelligence officials brief Trump and his national security team on their recent findings about Russia’s efforts to influence the 2016 presidential election.

Comey stays behind to make Trump aware of more sensitive information. A salacious dossier suggests that Russian officials had gathered compromising information about Trump that they would use as blackmail. This leaked dossier gets widespread coverage days after this conversation.

Comey’s statements say that he wanted to “minimize potential embarrassment” to Trump.

At that time, the FBI director assures Trump that he personally is not under investigation.

“During our one-on-one meeting at Trump Tower, based on President-elect Trump’s reaction to the briefing and without him directly asking the question, I offered that assurance.”

Comey leaves the meeting. In an FBI vehicle outside Trump Tower, he begins documenting his private conversation with the president-elect. It is the first in a series of notes he makes following interactions with Trump. Comey says he did not routinely write down accounts of such conversations prior to his meeting Trump.

In this statement, Comey notes that during his time as FBI director under President Obama, he had only two one-on-one meetings, and never by phone. Comey says he spoke with Trump nine times.

What Trump was talking about

That morning on Twitter, Trump was consumed by Hillary Clinton’s campaign, the “dishonest media” coverage of the border wall he planned to build and Arnold Schwarzenegger’s ratings on “The Apprentice.”

Trump was clearly frustrated. The night before, NBC had done a story on the intelligence reports that were the subject of his meeting with Comey. He later tweeted that he asked the House and Senate committee chairs to investigate how NBC received the reports before he did.

Jan 27: Loyalty dinner, 6:30 p.m.

White House Green Room

Five days before their dinner, Trump gave Comey a hug in the Oval Office. (Andrew Harrer / Getty Images)

Comey's account

Trump calls Comey around lunchtime to invite him to dinner that evening. Originally, Trump had told Comey he had thought about extending the invitation to his whole family, but decided against it. Comey assumes others will be there, but learns upon arrival that it is a private meal, interrupted only when two Navy stewards enter the room to serve food and drinks.

When Trump asks Comey whether he wanted to remain as FBI director, Comey finds it an odd question “because he had already told me twice in earlier conversations that he hoped I would stay, and I had assured him that I intended to.”

Comey again tells Trump that he intends to serve out his tenure. But the conversation makes him uneasy. He tries to guard his character, and insists that he’s “reliable” – the president can count on him to tell the truth.

“I need loyalty, I expect loyalty,” Trump tells him.

“I didn’t move, speak, or change my facial expression in any way during the awkward silence that followed. We simply looked at each other in silence. The conversation then moved on, but he returned to the subject near the end of our dinner,” Comey writes.

“I need loyalty,” Trump repeats.

“You will always get honesty from me,” Comey responds.

“That’s what I want, honest loyalty,” Trump says.

“You will get that from me,” Comey assures him.

The FBI director would later write that he didn’t know whether he and the president viewed “honest loyalty” in the same light.

Before the dinner ends, Trump revisits their earlier conversation about the dossier.

Trump tells Comey he had considered ordering him to investigate the allegations to prove they were false, but Comey tells the president that is a bad idea because it will create a narrative that the FBI was investigating Trump personally.

What Trump was talking about

The lead-up to that “loyalty dinner” differs slightly in Trump’s account. In an interview with Lester Holt after Comey’s firing, Trump told Holt that it was Comey who wanted to have dinner “because he wanted to stay on.”

And Trump relayed a “we’ll see what happens” message.

In a statement released after Comey’s testimony, Trump’s lawyer Marc Kasowitz offers more conflicting details.

“The President also never told Mr. Comey, ‘I need loyalty, I expect loyalty’ in any form or substance,” he writes.

Just days before the so-called loyalty dinner, former acting Atty. Gen. Sally Yates warned the White House that then-national security advisor Michael Flynn might be subject to Russian blackmail.

She told White House Counsel Donald McGahn that Flynn had discussed U.S. sanctions against Russia with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak. McGahn in turn briefed Trump.

Feb. 14: Briefing

White House Oval Office

A parent-teacher listening conference also occupied Trump's day. (Olivier Douliery/Abaca Press/TNS)

Comey's account

Comey meets with Trump for a previously scheduled counter-terrorism briefing.

“I was directly facing the president, sitting between the deputy CIA director and the director of NCTC. There were quite a few others in the room, sitting behind us on couches and chairs,” he writes.

Trump tells Comey he wants to speak with him alone at the end. Both Atty. Gen. Jeff Sessions and Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, linger behind, before Trump excuses them. Comey elaborates.

In his public testimony less than a week later, Sessions confirms this part of Comey’s story. Similar to Comey’s account, Sessions says Trump asked him to leave the room, leaving the presidetn and his FBI director alone in the Oval Office.

When the two men leave by way of the door next to the grandfather clock that has stood in the Oval Office since the year after Richard Nixon’s resignation, Trump begins.

“I want to talk about Mike Flynn.”

Flynn had been fired the day before.

Trump tells Comey that Flynn did nothing wrong in speaking to the Russians, and that the reason he was fired was because he had misled Vice President Mike Pence.

Trump then jumps to the subject of leaks and the importance of keeping classified information classified. Comey and Trump are briefly interrupted when White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus pops his head in the door. Trump dismisses him and returns to the topic of Flynn.

“I hope you can see your way clear to letting this go, to letting Flynn go. He is a good guy. I hope you can let this go,” Trump says.

“He is a good guy,” Comey responds.

Comey confides his concern to his advisors. He later tells Atty. Gen. Jeff Sessions that he no longer wanted any direct communication with the president.

What Trump was talking about

Kasowitz again dispels Comey’s testimony.

“The President never, in form or substance, directed or suggested that Mr. Comey stop investigating anyone, including suggesting that Mr. Comey ‘let Flynn go.’ As he publicly stated the next day, he did say to Mr. Comey, ‘General Flynn is a good guy, he has been through a lot’ and and also ‘asked how General Flynn is doing.’

In the early-morning hours, Trump returns to an ongoing narrative of media leaks.

“The real story here is why are there so many illegal leaks coming out of Washington, ” he tweeted.

The following day, Trump calls the Russia story “nonsense” and an attempt to distract from the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s emails.

March 30: Phone call

Dark clouds loom in Washington. (Alex Brandon / AP)

Comey's account

During a House Intelligence Committee hearing 10 days before, Comey confirms that the FBI is investigating Russia’s possible coordination with the Trump campaign.

That investigation continues to irritate Trump.

Trump calls Comey and asks what could be done to “lift the cloud” of Russia.

“He said he had nothing to do with Russia, had not been involved with hookers in Russia, and had always assumed he was being recorded when in Russia,” Comey writes.

Comey reminds Trump that he is not under investigation, and has told congressional leaders the same, to which Trump presses that “we need to get that fact out.” Comey does not tell Trump that the FBI’s hesitance for doing so is in case that fact changes.

“I told him I would see what we could do, and that we would do our investigative work well and as quickly as we could,” he writes.

What Trump was talking about

That morning, Trump once again tweets his frustration about the “failing media.”

House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes one week before said that U.S. intelligence officials had picked up communications of the Trump transition team. Now, news spread that the information was coming from inside Trump’s White House.

The following day, Trump tweets speculation that Obama’s national security advisor, Susan Rice, tried to unmask the identities of Trump’s transition team.

“If this is true, does not get much bigger,” he tweeted.

April 11: Phone call

Comey testified once again, nearly a month after his last conversation with Trump. (Carolyn Kaster / AP)

Comey's account

Trump calls Comey to ask him what he’d done to spread the word that he wasn’t involved in the Russia investigation. “The cloud,” as Trump calls it, was preventing him from doing his job.

Comey tells Trump that the White House counsel should contact the Justice Department. Trump agrees to do so.

“Because I have been very loyal to you, very loyal; we had that thing, you know,” he tells Comey.

“I did not reply or ask him what he meant by ‘that thing,’” Comey writes.

This was the last time Comey spoke with Trump. Less than a month later, Trump fired him.

What Trump was talking about

Tensions had been high when news broke that the FBI was monitoring communications of Trump campaign advisor Carter Page. The U.S. believed he was acting as a Russian agent. It was the latest story to fuel reports about the Russia investigation. Trump had made it repeatedly clear that he believes the investigation, and the attention to it, is a distraction.

Three days after Trump fired Comey, the president insinuated that he had tangible evidence to dispel Comey’s claims about their private conversations.