Pancake versus prayer dropped
Glendale-based International House of Pancakes has dropped its trademark infringement lawsuit against a church with a Pasadena ministry, agreeing to resolve its dispute with the International House of Prayer out of court.
On Dec. 21, the restaurant chain dismissed its case against the church, with its lawyers citing “ongoing mediation with the defendants,” according to documents filed in federal court in Los Angeles.
The restaurant chain sued the church in September, alleging it misappropriated IHOP trademarks with its website, ihop.org, and in signs and events at its headquarters in Kansas City, Mo., and California ministries. The church also has affiliates in San Jose, Santa Maria and Dublin, Calif.
When the lawsuit was filed, restaurant spokesman Patrick Lenow said the church’s use of IHOP and related phrases confused customers, undermined trademarked uses and risked publicly linking the chain of 1,500 restaurants with a particular faith or church.
He said the International House of Prayer had refused several requests to stop before the case was filed.
The church never filed a response in court. The main church web page is still at ihop.org, and the Pasadena ministry’s website remains pihop.com.
On Tuesday, a church official in Kansas City said most staff members were at a large religious gathering and no one was available for comment on the case. Calls to the Pasadena International House of Prayer were not returned.
Lenow, a spokesman with IHOP parent company DineEquity Inc., declined to discuss the company’s expected remedies for the six claims of trademark infringement, or a timeline, for the matter to be resolved.
“We have agreed with House of Prayer not to publicly discuss the case,” Lenow said in an e-mail.
The first International House of Pancakes opened in 1958, and the first ad campaign emphasizing the term IHOP began in 1973, according to the lawsuit. The International House of Prayer was founded in 1999.