They've turned back the clocks at
For two of these three weeks, the programming has been and will be vintage Salonen. Last week focused spectacularly upon his interests and strengths — new music, Finnish music, new Finnish music, symphonic showpieces. Next week speculates on the future of concert music with the addition of interactive video.
Well, then, what to make of this week's programming, which consists of nothing but meat-and-potatoes Mozart and Beethoven? Unlike Salonen's Beethoven Unbound series of several seasons ago, there was no contemporary composition there for contrast.
And while the Oct. 24 program attracted what looked like only a two-thirds-full house, Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 20 in D minor and Beethoven's "Eroica" Symphony nearly filled the seats Thursday night. I leave it to you to draw the conclusions.
Not only was this an atypically conservative program for Salonen, it would seem to be equally so for pianist Jeremy Denk, last seen around these parts programming the Ojai Festival, which featured his hysterically funny new comic opera, "The Classical Style." So here was Denk, in league with a conductor who also has a wonderfully dry sense of humor, quite seriously and lovingly purveying the style that he sent up in that opera.
Anyway, there was little in the way of brooding or darkness in this performance of the D-minor concerto, with Salonen cultivating light, fast, clear, fluid work from the Philharmonic, with some muscular vigor in the finale, and Denk opening ruminatively yet with clearer definition and variety of color as the piece unfolded. The cadenzas were Denk's own; the more-extensive one in the first movement opened conventionally by paraphrasing Mozart and developed momentum as it pushed somewhat ahead in time to middle-period Beethoven.
Shorn of its repeat, the first movement of the "Eroica" was typical of what one remembered of Salonen's Beethoven from his years as music director — light, fleet, breezy in an unimpeded roll to the finish line — and the second movement had only minimal gravitas.
However, the last two movements fared much better with his approach. The Scherzo had plenty of dash and fire at a racing pace, the variations of the Finale sped along with some forceful accents, the fugues beautifully played by the Philharmonic.
As Salonen once promised when writing about Beethoven Unbound, Beethoven the radical was present in this performance, but I'm not sure if one could feel — as Brahms used to say — "the tramp of a giant."