OpinionEditorial

Don't seek the death penalty

Justice SystemCrime, Law and JusticeAbusive BehaviorPoliticsElectionsSteve CooleyBarbara Lee

When James Lee Crummel hanged himself last month, very few mourned his passing. A child molester who kidnapped, sexually abused and murdered a 13-year-old boy in 1979, Crummel was on death row in San Quentin when he took his own life using an extension cord. What's notable about this is that he was the 20th death row inmate to commit suicide since California reinstated capital punishment in 1978. That's seven more than the number of convicts who have been executed since then.

This figure says something about the false promise of capital punishment: The families of victims may get some visceral satisfaction when their loved ones' killers are sentenced to death, but this turns to frustration and bitterness as decades pass without the sentences being carried out. Fifty-seven death row inmates have died of natural causes since 1978, so such prisoners are almost six times more likely to expire by their own or nature's hand than by the executioner's.

Proponents and opponents of the death penalty have very different reactions to such statistics. To proponents, it's an indication that our court system is hopelessly overprotective of the rights of criminals and that the appeals process should be streamlined. Yet this ignores the moral and legal imperative to do everything possible to ensure, before carrying out the ultimate penalty, that a convict is truly guilty. False convictions happen more often than many realize — according to the Death Penalty Information Center, 140 death row inmates nationwide have been exonerated since 1973 while awaiting execution. Court delays also block unconstitutional and inhumane executions; California, for instance, hasn't executed anyone since 2006 as lawyers wrangle over the pain experienced by inmates during lethal injection. Moreover, even as lengthy and costly appeals drag on, there is no way to be 100% certain of an inmate's guilt, which is why we favor replacing the death penalty with a sentence of life without the possibility of parole.

A measure on the November ballot, the SAFE California Act, would do exactly that, and we hope voters will support it. Meanwhile, California prosecutors, in particular L.A. County Dist. Atty. Steve Cooley, should stop pursuing capital cases until the voters have had their say. There's some evidence that they're already slowing down. Last year there were only 10 death sentences in California, down from 29 in the previous two years; in L.A. County, Cooley pursued death in only five cases, down from eight in 2010.

Experts attribute the downturn to budget cuts, with prosecutors being reluctant to pursue costly capital cases as their resources are slashed. That's a good reason for shutting down the machinery of death, but we have a better one. Public support for capital punishment has been plummeting in recent years, and for reasons of cost, morality and effectiveness, voters may finally be willing to pursue a better course. Let's give them their chance to weigh in before continuing with a penalty that is no more protective of society than life without parole.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Justice SystemCrime, Law and JusticeAbusive BehaviorPoliticsElectionsSteve CooleyBarbara Lee
  • Proposition 34's common-sense appeal
    Proposition 34's common-sense appeal

    On practical and moral grounds, replacing the death penalty with a sentence of life without the possibility of parole is the right thing to do.

  • How to protect celebrities from paparazzi drones
    How to protect celebrities from paparazzi drones

    California was one of many states that strengthened its privacy laws after the shocking death of Princess Diana, who was fleeing paparazzi when her car crashed in a Paris tunnel in 1997. Since then, lawmakers have proposed a seemingly endless series of additions and tweaks to California...

  • Destruction of Syrian chemical weapons shows the U.S. may know what it's doing after all
    Destruction of Syrian chemical weapons shows the U.S. may know what it's doing after all

    Disparate, simultaneous crises around the world have put the Obama administration's foreign policy on trial in recent weeks. The forward march of Islamic State insurgents in Iraq has led to renewed military action in the very country the president so vehemently sought to leave when he...

  • Clean skid row's streets, but then house the homeless
    Clean skid row's streets, but then house the homeless

    The organizers of Operation Healthy Streets, a newly revamped version of an existing Los Angeles city program, vow that filthy skid row streets will be scoured every other month (and spot-cleaned in between) and that city and county outreach workers will be dispatched on a more regular basis...

  • How to boost voter turnout in L.A. -- and it isn't offering prizes
    How to boost voter turnout in L.A. -- and it isn't offering prizes

    In a wondrous proposal that says more about the decline of civilization than its authors surely intended, the Los Angeles Ethics Commission has come up with a way to boost voter turnout in L.A. city elections: Make voters eligible for cash prizes. The recommendation may fail to persuade the...

  • L.A's water ruler, DWP chief Marcie Edwards, on keeping the city hydrated
    L.A's water ruler, DWP chief Marcie Edwards, on keeping the city hydrated

    The Department of Water and Power began 107 years ago, after Los Angeles bought back the civic water system from a group of privateers. Like its top man, William Mulholland, who began as a ditch-digger, the new DWP chief, Marcie Edwards, also started at the bottom, as a clerk. Now she's...

  • U.S. still has time to stake out a position of strength on Ukraine
    U.S. still has time to stake out a position of strength on Ukraine

    American and European stock markets have been jumpy for weeks as they contemplate possible armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Inside Ukraine, certainly, Kiev's forces have been pushing back separatists supported by Moscow , and they've been surprisingly successful in the...

  • It's summertime. Why aren't you on vacation?
    It's summertime. Why aren't you on vacation?

    My wife and I returned Friday from two weeks of vacation in China, hanging out with one of our sons (posted there with the Peace Corps) and his girlfriend. We were mostly unplugged, wandered miles every day, traipsed the Great Wall and watched pandas, among other exotic (to us) exploits. And...

Comments
Loading