Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Editorial

Religious rights and gay rights

If churches pay employees with funds from a federal contract, they must follow anti-discrimination rules

Last month, President Obama issued an executive order prohibiting federal contractors from discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. Equally notable is what the president didn't do: He refused to exempt religious organizations. That was the right call. Religious organizations have a constitutional right to disapprove of homosexuality, but if they are paying their employees with funds from a federal contract they must be bound by the same anti-discrimination provisions as other contractors.

But there is a potential loophole in Obama's order. It leaves in place an executive order issued by President George W. Bush in 2002 as part of his Faith-Based Initiative that allows religious social-service agencies to favor members of their own faith in hiring. (They may not, however, discriminate on the basis of religion in providing services.)

The intent of Bush's exemption was to assure an agency affiliated with one religious denomination that it could continue to employ members of that denomination. A drug and alcohol rehabilitation program offered by a Roman Catholic agency, for instance, could favor Catholics over Methodists or Jews. The problem is that an ingenious lawyer could interpret that provision to allow a Catholic agency to fire or refuse to hire not just non-Catholics but also "bad" Catholics — such as those who marry someone of the same gender.

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which has called Obama's order "unprecedented and extreme," isn't making precisely that argument. But the bishops have stressed that the church simultaneously opposes "both unjust discrimination against those who experience a homosexual inclination and sexual conduct outside of marriage, which is the union of one man and one woman." One could argue that a Catholic agency that fired a "practicing homosexual" would be availing itself of the right to employ people of the same faith.

We don't think the Bush executive order justifies such an interpretation. The Labor Department, which is drawing up regulations to implement Obama's order, should follow the logic of federal courts that have ruled that laws against gender discrimination apply even when such discrimination is religiously motivated. The whole point of Obama's executive order is that discrimination against gays, lesbians and transgender people is just as odious as racial and gender discrimination. A backdoor exemption for religious contractors would dilute that powerful message.

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • So long, California: The next drought remedy?
    So long, California: The next drought remedy?

    Gov. Jerry Brown is calling for fines of up to $10,000 for the state’s biggest water wasters. "We've done a lot. We have a long way to go," Brown said. "So maybe you want to think of this as just another installment on a long enterprise to live with a changing climate and with a drought of uncertain...

  • 4 things Princess Charlotte should keep in mind growing up in Britain's royal family
    4 things Princess Charlotte should keep in mind growing up in Britain's royal family

    I have some words of advice for the newborn Princess Charlotte (Elizabeth Diana) of Cambridge, the first of which -- get a good first name -- her parents have already taken on her behalf. So she’s off to a fine start.

  • The other Mayweather-Pacquiao fight
    The other Mayweather-Pacquiao fight

    Saturday's championship bout between Floyd Mayweather Jr. and Manny Pacquiao generated an estimated $475 million in ticket sales and pay-per-view fees, a tribute to the promoters' ability to frame the long-delayed fight between two past-their-prime welterweights as an epic event. So masterful was...

  • How deep are the problems in Baltimore's police department?
    How deep are the problems in Baltimore's police department?

    The decision by Baltimore State's Atty. Marilyn J. Mosby to bring murder, manslaughter and other criminal charges against six police officers in the death of Freddie Gray brought cheer to protesters in that embattled city and their counterparts in other cities where civilians have long complained...

  • Trust issues at DWP, and City Hall
    Trust issues at DWP, and City Hall

    After a year and a half of political fights, lawsuits and protests, City Controller Ron Galperin was finally able to open the books of two nonprofit trusts associated with the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and reveal, at least partially, how managers spent millions of dollars in ratepayer...

  • Fracking: Jerry Brown's environmental blind spot
    Fracking: Jerry Brown's environmental blind spot

    Gov. Jerry Brown may prove to be the greenest government official in American history — emphasis on "may."